Can you imagine the noise that the American conservative noise machine is going to make after the pope's encyclical is released?
Historically in American culture, Protestant preachers routinely denounced the pope as the Anti-Christ and the prostitute of Babylon. After Pope Francis' encyclical about the environment is released, perhaps American conservatives will recycle those old epithets to characterize the pope.
But already certain American conservatives have criticized the very idea of a pope issuing an encyclical on the environment.
Now, according to various news reports, Cardinal Oscar Rodriguez Maradiaga of the Honduras, the coordinator of the pope's kitchen cabinet of nine cardinals, is pushing back in no uncertain terms.
Cardinal Rodriguez is being quoted as saying, "The ideology surrounding environmental issues is too tied to capitalism that doesn't want to stop ruining the environment because they don't want to give up their profits."
Cardinal Rodriguez's statement has been reported by the Vatican correspondent Ines San Martin ("Key advisor blasts US criticism to [sic] pope's environmental stance") at the Crux feature of the Boston Globe and repeated in pieces by Nick Gass (Pope Francis Aide blasts U.S. climate skeptics") at Politico and Timothy Cama ("Pope's top adviser blasts US climate skeptics") at The Hill. All three pieces are dated May 12, 2015.
Cardinal Rodriguez sounds like he's channeling the ancient Hebrew prophet Amos.
But who does Cardinal Rodriguez think he is criticizing capitalism, hey? Why, unregulated capitalism is as American as apple pie.
No doubt American conservatives worship the so-called "rugged individualism" of the so-called "self-made man" in classic capitalism -- who supposedly pulled himself up by his bootstraps -- unencumbered by government regulation of course.
Besides, everybody knows that Latin America, where Pope Francis comes from, has historically been under-developed economically compared to the United States, because of the cultural dominance of the Roman Catholic Church in Latin America. Therefore, Americans should be skeptical about the first Latin American pope's views of capitalism and/or the environment.
But will American progressives and liberals push back against the conservative noise machine after the pope's encyclical about the environment is released? If progressives and liberals do push back, the debate in American culture about the pope's encyclical promises might be a war of words between American conservatives, some of whom are American Catholics, on the one hand, and, on the other, American progressives and liberals who are interested in the environment, some of whom are not Catholics.
ONG'S ACCOUNT OF OUR WESTERN CULTURAL HISTORY
Now, I want to work with the basic paradigm of a two-sided debate: Position A versus Position B. But I want to work with a much bigger conceptual framework than either capitalism pro and con, or the environment pro and con.
Comments
Click Here to View Comments or Join the Conversation