Power of Story Send a Tweet        
- Advertisement -
OpEdNews Op Eds

I did not realise I was Anti Semitic

By       Message Hamish       (Page 1 of 1 pages)     Permalink

Related Topic(s): ; ; , Add Tags  Add to My Group(s)

View Ratings | Rate It


Author 1681
- Advertisement -
I have stopped writing to the Guardian. I love the paper ..have read it for 30 years. It has been a giant voice in the world and has answered the questions I have wrestled with. "It says so in the Guardian" is a conversation stopper. Even folk that hate it, give it a kind of grudging respect.

Readers are "So-called lefty liberal pinko etc etc . Guardinistas". It is now a form of odd flattery. The strange thing is that a huge number of people write merely to complain. Which is odder. Writing to a world famous left wing paper to complain that it is left wing seems a futile gesture. Yet it has driven me away from its warm embrace.

When I first started posting comments I was struck by the similarity of the posts which were clearly pro Israeli. This was in July 06 during a time of horrific war. For a fundamentally pacifist paper it was unsettling that 5 posts in a row would all say the same thing to within a couple of words.

a) Why is the Guardian so Anti Semitic?
b) Why do its readers never mention Darfur?
c) Israel has been an island in a sea of hostility.
d) The action is totally justified.

I did some research. I found some articles


Which alarmed me... about the manipulation of news by giyus : http://giyus.org/ but I thought all I would have to do is mention it and this would stop.

I also campaigned for the rules of post to be changed to those of Ha'aretz, the Israeli paper which banned insults and likening the situation to WW2 as some found " Islamofascist" and " Judeo Nazi" so offensive. This worked but I was called a fascist for stopping free speech.

I started picking off the posts one at a time. I am actually quite famous here as an anti racist and have been for decades. Yet I was transformed into a Jew-Hating Jew-Hater who hates Jews. Complaining made it worse.. "so now he is denying it?"

I think it was LBJ who said "it doesn't matter if the guy never slept with a camel...let him deny it.".." I am not anti Semitic" actually does sound like "I am anti Semitic."

I plowed on. I found a way of only condemning only Palestinian terror which was unswervingly pro Israel. I was accused of being smarmy. I appealed. I was scorned. I am a Social Worker and know a hundred ways to lower tension. I raised it.

I defended Chomsky. One poster " Canadian Jew" called him "Herr" Chomsky ,friend of fascists and holocaust denier. He was supported by a host of posts. I appealed that this giant was a man of peace. I was ridiculed by a dozen posts.

What finally drove me out was an article about Gilad Atzmon, a left wing anti Zionist who had been a paratrooper in the IDF. He likened the Zionist expansion in Israel with Nazism. Now I disagree with this, but because it raises tension ,not because it was per se anti Jewish. I read Atzmon and could find no AntiSemitism at all.

Bang. You would have thought I had organised Kristallnacht. I got a wall of complaints some in Islamophobic ranting.I carefully appealed for proof in case I had missed something. None came.Just more insults. In the finest paper in the world. I know my parents were legally married.

The tactic worked and I was sickened by it. By the way I asked for the word " Islamofascist " to be removed on 20 occasions.. maybe more. I never once had to ask for" Judeo Nazi " to go.


- Advertisement -

View Ratings | Rate It


'Hamish ' is an antiwar writer socialist- scientist and musician living in Scotland.

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon Share Author on Social Media   Go To Commenting

The views expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
- Advertisement -

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Glorifying Violence

Moshad could sniff out Gibson.


This is not Vietnam all over again.

Be proud to be a Republican

I did not realise I was Anti Semitic