Recently Alexandria Ocasio Cortez (AOC) stirred controversy by characterizing U.S. immigration detention facilities as concentration camps. Critics said her comparison was over the top
It was an insult, some said, to families of Holocaust survivors. After all, none of the U.S. detention facilities is an extermination camp like Auschwitz or Buchenwald.
In response, AOC doubled down on her charge. Along with others, she was joined by historians, and even by the editors of The National Catholic Reporter in affirming her accusation. Concentration camps, they all said, are not synonymous with extermination camps. In essence, the former are locations where prisoners are held without charge. In that sense, the U.S. indeed maintains concentration camps, but nothing like German practice. The intention in making that distinction was evidently to distance U.S. camps from the horrors and death of Hitler's infamous hell-holes.
The argument here takes issue with that distinction. It maintains instead that our burgeoning camps are every bit as brutal as Hitler's. In fact, the number of deaths connected with the U.S. system dwarf the iconic number of six million incinerated, gassed, shot, or otherwise executed under Hitler.
To begin with, we must first of all realize that U.S. concentration camps are not a new phenomenon begun with the presidency of Donald Trump. No, they have been with us at least since the end of the Second Inter-Capitalist War in 1945.
In fact, the argument can be credibly made that our country was explicitly founded on extermination, genocide and concentration camps. Using rationale supplied by John Locke, our Founding Fathers wiped out 90% of North America's indigenous peoples, eventually confining survivors and their descendants in concentration camps (called "reservations"). They employed the same logic to enslave workers kidnapped from Africa imprisoning them in labor camps (called "plantations").
For Locke, who inspired Jefferson's Declaration of Independence, the crucial and ironic pronouncement behind such operations was that "All men are created equal." But note well that in his formulation, the statement had no liberating relevance for Native Americans, African slaves, women or propertyless whites. Instead, its expressed intention was to establish the right of imperialists like him and his cohorts to steal land and resources from the continent's indigenous inhabitants and to exterminate resisters.
Locke's point (as explained in my book, The Magic Glasses of Critical Thinking) was that just because the "Indians" were here first, they had no special claim on the lands they called home. That is, since (in Locke's estimation) huge tracts were not being farmed as they would be in England, they were there for the taking by the Indians' equals from Great Britain.
Locke said that a refusal by the Indians to recognize such equality amounted to a declaration of war against the British. So, the natives could be slaughtered with abandon a task our country's great Indian Fighters took on with enthusiasm and relish creating a holocaust that killed millions.
Adolph Hitler himself took inspiration from the examples just cited. He liked the concept of concentration and work camps. He was expressly impressed by the efficiency of U.S. extermination of our continent's First Peoples. It inspired him and evidently the minds behind contemporary concentration camps.
With all this in mind, it is no exaggeration to say that the camps are reincarnating today before our very eyes. Our government has set them up world-wide. They are so ubiquitous and normalized that they remain practically invisible. But consider their contemporary equivalents in:
- The U.S. prison-industrial complex itself for blacks, browns and poor whites transforming "Americans" into the most imprisoned population on the planet
- Guantanamo Bay for holding "terrorists" who after years of internment and torture have yet to be charged with crime and which Fuhrer Trump promises to fill to the brim
- Black Sites (sic!) concealed throughout the world where kidnapped Muslims and others disappear without a trace and are tortured without mercy
- Fort Bliss (sic!), a concentration camp for immigrant children
- Baby Prisons for infants as young as four months
- Detention centers for refugees from U.S. wars of aggression in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Yemen and elsewhere
- Family prisons for immigrant workers from Mexico and Central America as they await trials which can be postponed indefinitely
- The Gaza Strip, the world's largest open-air prison for Muslim Palestinians, "the Jews' Jews" unconditionally endorsed by U.S. politicians of all stripes
In such hell-holes the criminals (often the guards) commit murders, rapes and inflict torture with impunity. Nonetheless, after Hitler, it is no longer permissible for such polite company to crudely incinerate victims in ovens or to poison them in gas chambers. (That would be too "inhumane" and reminiscent of the unspeakable.) So, today's executioners murder and incinerate Muslims (today's "Jews"), and others on site. (It saves the trouble and expense of packing them into box cars.)
In other words, the executioners travel to the victims' countries of origin in the Middle East and Africa and do the dirty work there often from 10,000 feet in the air, where the screams of incinerated Muslim children cannot be heard. They cremate their victims more humanely in the targets' own homes with napalm and white phosphorous. Alternatively, "pilots" seated comfortably in their air-conditioned "theaters" send automated Gestapo (killer drones) to decapitate those suspected of evil thoughts. In the process, the system's butchers have massacred millions far exceeding anything imagined by that little man with the toothbrush mustache:
- Already by 1978, John Stockwell, the highly decorated ex-CIA Station Chief in Angola, estimated that his agency's "Secret Wars" had killed more than six million in its dirty wars against the world's poor. In Stockwell's own words, every one of those wars was illegal and "bloody and gory and beyond comprehension almost."
- Add to that
- The hundreds of thousands slaughtered during the 1980s in El Salvador, Guatemala, Nicaragua, and Honduras
- More than a million victims in the completely illegal war in Iraq
- Untold fatalities in Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Ethiopia,
- The 10,000 already killed in Yemen, the poorest country in the Middle East with the numbers increasing each day from cholera and intentionally-inflicted starvation
Again, the numbers are staggering far beyond anything accomplished in Hitler's death camps.
Meanwhile, at home, "Americans" are dissuaded from protest by a militarized skin-head police force of body-builders and thugs. "Dressed to kill" in their black or camouflaged flack suits, and anonymous under their helmets and behind polarized face-shields, they stand ready with batons, tasers, and AK47s as well as employing surplus military tanks, and Humvees to punish anyone who dares opposition.
So, congratulations to Ms. Ocasio-Cortez. She's right again this time about concentration camps. However, she and others are wrong to downplay the comparative horror of the U.S. system. It is every bit as horrendous as Hitler's. To see the misery all one has to do is connect the dots. They're there, and though scattered are just waiting to be linked (exactly as they were in Germany during Hitler's rise to power).
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).