If Bush wants to run for the Presidency in 2016, he should
answer questions about his involvement, and media should fact-check and obtain
Jeb Bush may have a problem in the primaries with his family name
because of his father and brother's legacies of the Iraq war and the 2008
recession -- issues that may have been handled very differently in a Gore
presidency-- and now attempts to distance himself from them with the widely
covered "I'm my own man." The media has not, however, even mentioned what may
be his biggest problem: his level of responsibility in Florida for taking
the 2000 election from Gore, and the national repercussions.
Bush's communications director in July 2001, Katie Baur, said, "While he
recused himself from any involvement in what happened after Nov. 7, he did not
recuse himself from his role as a brother." What's not known is that
the level of direct involvement was, frankly, enormous. The Los Angeles Times
reported on July 14, 2001, "The Florida governor's office in Tallahassee made
95 telephone calls to the George W. Bush presidential campaign, its advisors,
lawyers and staffers during the 36-day recount period, records show. At least
10 calls came from an office number used primarily by Jeb Bush."
At least one call from Jeb Bush's number "went to Karl Rove,
his brother's campaign strategist... One went to the Texas governor's chief of
staff, Clay Johnson. Additional calls were logged to cell phones assigned to
Bush campaign staffers."
Bush emailed in July 2001: "I have no clue what these
calls were about." He had "no clue" of what his own calls were about
while his brother was on the cusp of winning or losing the Presidency?
Even before the recount, Florida officials were aware of flaws in
the voting system that Katherine Harris, the Secretary of State under Governor
Bush, directed. Harris was Co-Chair of the Bush campaign, itself a likely
conflict of interest for the state's top voting procedures official.
"There emerges a confluence of circumstances that indicates
intimidation and harassment of the Florida voters, and that was set in motion
long before the November election," said Commissioner Victoria Wilson of the
U.S. Commission on Civil Rights in their report, "Voting Irregularities in
Florida During the 2000 Presidential Election." Issued June 8, 2001, the
report accuses Florida election officials of "gross dereliction" and
The report revealed that 14.4 percent of Florida's black voters cast ballots that were rejected, compared with 1.6 percent of nonblack Florida voters. 11 percent of Florida voters were African American; they cast 54 percent of the 180,000 supposedly spoiled ballots.
The report adds, "This overall lack of leadership in protecting
voting rights was largely responsible for the broad array of problems in
Florida during the 2000 election."
Proper conversations between Bush and Harris would have been how
to expedite the counting of the most voters possible. Improper
conversations would have been how to stop counts in pro-Gore areas. Which were
Other questions include:
- Who did Jeb call within the Bush camp, including Rove, to strategize before and during the recount, and what was discussed?
- Did he help suppress targeted votes before and during the recount?
- What instructions or guidance did Bush and Harris discuss concerning the slow walk in the election recount until the US Supreme Court finally said "enough?"
To this day, Bush has not updated his "no clue" statement, but current presidential voters including in the Iowa Caucuses deserve answers. The actions were only 15 years ago and have impacted the economy and Iraq to this day. Until Jeb says what he did (if anything) to slow walk the count so that Gore would lose by a U.S. Supreme Court stop of the counting, there is reason for voters to question his role, and to factor that role into their voting this time around.
Editor's note: Jeb Bush's office declined to respond last week to this op-ed
Robert Weiner is former spokesman for the Clinton White House and House Government Operations Committee and was senior staff for Congressmen John Conyers, Charles Rangel, Claude Pepper, Ed Koch, and a political aide to Sen. Ted Kennedy. Daniel Wallace is Policy Analyst for Robert Weiner Associates.