Cross-posted from To The Point Analyses
Part I -- Denying the Connections
The display of anxiety and aggressive agitation in Israel, triggered by the kidnapping of three young men from an illegal settlement on the West Bank, seems to be accompanied by a near total denial of any legitimate relationship between government actions (the occupation) and Palestinian reactions (the kidnapping). No matter what the Israelis do to the Palestinians they insist that those actions are justified, and no matter how the Palestinians react, the Israelis insist those actions are never justified. By objective standards this Israeli attitude borders on the pathological.
Part II -- Resulting Tragedies
There are multiple tragedies that result from this disconnect. The tragedy of the three Jewish kidnap victims is the one that is foremost in both Israeli consciousness and also in the Western media. At this level there is lots of speculation that the young men were taken as hostages to be exchanged for Palestinian prisoners. As if to put out the message that the government of Benjamin Netanyahu will not play that game, the Israeli military is arresting hundreds of Palestinians, including some who had been released in exchange for Gilad Shalit. They are also are destroying property in a wholesale manner, wounding scores and even murdering a steady number of Palestinians as they search for the kidnap victims.
However, all this mayhem, which only deepens, if possible, Palestinian hatred, may be based on an Israeli false assumption. Quite likely this kidnapping was not carried out so as to set up some future exchange. Quite likely it was a simple opportunistic act of revenge. If that is the case, the kidnap victims are almost certainly dead.
That many Zionists cannot fathom the fact that there are literally millions of Palestinians desiring vengeance for Israeli acts of abuse is part of their denial that their own actions define much of Palestinian reactions. This denial is reinforced by the gambit of labeling all Palestinians as terrorists.
Then there is the tragedy of the collectively kidnapped people of Palestine. That is the phrase used by Avraham Burg, a disillusioned Zionist who, apparently, is slowly but surely replacing his old ideology with contemporary disgust. As Burg puts it...
"All of Palestinian society is a kidnapped society ... many of the Israelis who performed 'significant service' in the army " entered the home of a Palestinian family in the middle of the night by surprise, with violence, and simply took away the father, brother or uncle... That is kidnapping and happens every day."
No doubt some Israelis deeply resent the fact that much of the rest of the world has come to agree with Burg. More and more, those on the outside know that the Israelis have created the context for this latest kidnapping and they no longer believe Zionist justifications for Israeli behavior. The result is that the Israelis are increasingly isolated in a misshapen world of their own. For instance, an editorial in the Jerusalem Post dismisses the world's principal human rights organizations as hypocrites because they did not express "immediate outrage, demand action, and even demonstrate at the United Nations demanding the immediate release" of the "three Israeli teens."
Alas, the major human rights organizations, which have in fact expressed disapproval at the kidnapping, cannot do as the Jerusalem Post editorial wishes because they understand the degree to which Israeli policies bring upon them their own tragedies. This fact makes very difficult the otherwise natural sympathies the Israelis insist upon.
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).