Send a Tweet
Most Popular Choices
Share on Facebook 35 Share on Twitter Printer Friendly Page More Sharing
Life Arts    H4'ed 9/18/21

Three Strikes You're Out for Western Psychotherapy: The Dark History and its Shortcomings With Collectivists

By       (Page 1 of 6 pages)   4 comments
Follow Me on Twitter     Message Barbara and Bruce MacLean-Lerro
Become a Fan
  (2 fans)

Fritz Perls Gestalt Psychology
Fritz Perls Gestalt Psychology
(Image by Howtohaveabreakdown.org)
  Details   DMCA

Written by Bruce Lerro, Planning Beyond Capitalism

Orientation

Patient questions and therapeutic answers

The therapist says to the client, "tell me about your dreams" and the client shakes their head slowly and says "I had this dream..." A therapist says to a teenager, "who are you?" The teenager answers, "I don't know". The therapist says to the teenager, "that's normal at your age." A client tells their therapist, " I am very angry at my father." The therapist says, "let's do a role play. You be your father and I'll be you. I'll show you how to do it." A client says they are sick of their job but they stay because the money and benefits are good. They want to get into another field. The cognitive therapist says, "let's brainstorm the different fields you want to get into. We can look at the Occupational Handbook for the skills and pay scale for the different kinds of jobs. Then we can set some goals and seasonal objectives so we make sure you follow through with your goals." The client feels overwhelmed but agrees. A mother expresses great sadness when her thirty-three-year-old son is getting ready to move out. The therapist says to the client, "it's long overdue for your son to leave." After the patient leaves the therapist adds "dependent personality" to her diagnosis.

If you are an individualist living in an industrial-capitalist society, both the problems and the therapeutic responses probably sound familiar and the therapeutic interventions sound reasonable. But how good are these interventions with people whose home culture is collectivists outside Yankeedom, specifically India, China or Japan?

What are collectivist and individualist selves?

Roughly 80% of the world's population is "collectivist", consisting of most parts of the world with the exception of the United States and Western Europe. The latter country and part of a continent have been characterized as "individualist." For collectivists, the group is prior to the individual in two senses. The caste group is prior to the family, and the family is prior to the individual. For individualists, the importance of the individual is prior to that of the family and the family is prior to one's membership in a social class. In the history of human societies, there have been two kinds of collectivists, horizontal and vertical. Horizontal collectivists have been hunter-gatherers, simple horticultural societies who do not have castes or classes. This is why they are called "horizontal" collectivists. Agricultural states are vertical collectivists because they have social castes. We will be using the agriculturalist states of India, China and Japan for our case studies for collectivists . Industrial-capitalist societies will be the type of societies we will characterize as individualist.

For collectivists, society is like an organism and extension of nature. Different castes within that society are pictured as being like the organs of a body. Individuals are like different cells in the body. For individualists, society is autonomous from nature and is governed by its own laws. Social institutions are built up by individuals via a social contract. Individuals are independent of society and social relations appear to them as being voluntary, contractual and accidental. Lastly, collectivists value stability. What is old is revered and what is new is looked upon with suspicion. For individualists it is the reverse. There are many other interesting differences, please see Table A in our article on our site for the full list. The question we will seek to address is how well will Western theories of personality work with collectivists?

Six western theories of personality

There are six western theories of personality: Psychoanalysis; Behaviorism; Humanistic; Biological Physiological; Biological Evolutionary and Cognitive. Each of these theories can be broken down into sub-schools which have various kinds of quarrels and emphasis, but for our purpose the six original theories are plenty.

Unit of analysis

The basic unit of analysis for psychoanalysis is dreams, fantasies and drives. For behaviorism the basic unit is habits - what people do, over and over again. For humanistic psychology the most important focus is curiosity and peak experiences. For the biological-physiological school, what matters most are hormones, genes and brain chemistry. For the biological evolutionary school what drives individuals is survival and reproduction. For the cognitive school the main focus are the qualities of reasoning.

Structure of the psyche

The structure of the psyche for psychoanalysis is the id, ego, superego and the unconscious, the conscious and the preconscious. For behaviorism, the structure surrounding the habit it is what happens just before the habit (associations, Pavlov) and what happens after (consequences, Skinner). Maslow's hierarchy of needs focuses on where to place the individual for humanistic psychology. For the biological physiological theory, one major topic is temperament theory. For biological evolutionary school adaptation and sexual-selection strategies is where the action is at. For the cognitive school automatic thoughts, cognitive interpretations, explanatory styles and assumptions is the focus.

Next Page  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6

(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).

Well Said 1   Interesting 1  
Rate It | View Ratings

Barbara And Bruce MacLean-Lerro Social Media Pages: Facebook Page       Twitter Page       Linkedin page url on login Profile not filled in       Instagram page url on login Profile not filled in

Barbara MacLean and Bruce Lerro are co-founders and organizers for Socialist Planning Beyond Capitalism. Follow them on Facebook and Twitter. http://planningbeyondcapitalism.org/

Go To Commenting
The views expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.
Follow Me on Twitter     Writers Guidelines

 
Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
Support OpEdNews

OpEdNews depends upon can't survive without your help.

If you value this article and the work of OpEdNews, please either Donate or Purchase a premium membership.

STAY IN THE KNOW
If you've enjoyed this, sign up for our daily or weekly newsletter to get lots of great progressive content.
Daily Weekly     OpEd News Newsletter
Name
Email
   (Opens new browser window)
 

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Polytheism vs Monotheism: Building Bridges Between Polytheism and Atheism

Towards a Communist Theory of the Emotions: Why Your Emotions are Not Your Private Property

Letters From Moscow Across the Class Divide: Impact of Sanctions, Homelessness, and Sports Fanaticism

Letters from Moscow: Education, Health Care, Unions, and Political Parties Across the Class Divide

The Social Anatomy and Dynamics of Power: Bases, Depth, Scope, and Dimensions

Bringing our Socialist Baby to Life: History of Socialist Planning Beyond Capitalism

To View Comments or Join the Conversation:

Tell A Friend