Share on Google Plus Share on Twitter
  5
Share on Facebook
  6
Share on LinkedIn Share on PInterest Share on Fark! Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Tell A Friend 11 Shares     
Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites View Article Stats
4 comments

OpEdNews Op Eds

Collective Occlusion: American Narratives and Silencing of Important Cultural Memories

Become a Fan
  (6 fans)
By (about the author)     Permalink       (Page 1 of 2 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (more...) ; ; ; ; ; , Add Tags  (less...) Add to My Group(s)

Must Read 1   Well Said 1   Valuable 1  
View Ratings | Rate It

Headlined to H4 5/30/13

opednews.com

From http://www.flickr.com/photos/23471940@N02/6025686799/: Maui 2011 042
Maui 2011 042 by M I K E M O R R I S

Maui 2011 042 by M I K E M O R R I S

I have taken a lot of time to write on collective memory in film and society over the years.  I have written, for example on the Holocaust and on the presentation of memory in Germany and commemorations and/or memorials in other lands. I have written about memories of WWII on three continents.  Finally, I have written about the Vietnam era and post-Vietnam war education--and memories surround the movie Forrest Gump and the film's relationship to images used in other films, i.e. its relationship to the reality on the ground of which it represents

Recently, I came across an older--but trailblazing--article on the topic of USA history and how society teaches it:  " What Can Forrest Gump Tell Us about Students' Historical Understanding?" It was published in 2001 by Sam Wineburg, Susan Mosborg, and Dan Porat in a journal on social education. Again, in this article, the topic of Forrest Gump, the film, is used to make the case that media may have a stronger influence on the teaching of Vietnam Era history in America than do any classroom experiences of our American students in either our primary or secondary schools these days.  

The authors go further, though, and indicating that media is also overwhelming possible family practices in educating our youth about America's own history. The authors of the article,  " What Can Forrest Gump Tell Us about Students' Historical Understanding?" were concerned with how America students are acquiring their American history up through the period of the 9-11 events (which have since transformed further our Vietnam era memories). The article exposes the initial findings of both a social-educational experiment and a set of investigations involving students in their last years of high school.  Moreover, it also involved the students and their parents in extensive interviews and engaged them in written responses on similar historical topics, themes, events, and images. [1] Note:  As it has been claimed that even more than the Vietnam War, the events of 9-11 have supposedly changed living-American-generations' filters of history. I would certainly like to see similar new research (as undertaken by Weinburg, et. al) to be undertaken today.

I personally find that the Cold War-Era with its own particular narrations have, however, continued to fuel American memory even as the period of Global Terrorism has supposedly overtaken our current new conceptualizations of reality and memory.

The article by Weinburg et. al. begins [2] as follows: " HISTORICAL NARRATIVES envelop us everywhere--at home, at church, at the movies; in the buildings we inhabit, the parks we visit, the stamps we lick; in the days we take off from work, the newspapers we read, and the six-o'clock news we receive from Tom Brokaw, Peter Jennings, and Dan Rather. By the time young people reach their eighteenth birthday in our culture, they possess a rich narrative of origins--how the United States came into being, the roots of the race issue that divides American society, something about Pilgrims, colonists, and settlers. In terms of impact and influence, no algebra or French teacher can compete with such famous history teachers as Steven Spielberg or Oliver Stone, whose devoted students number in multiples of millions.

Each of us grows up in a home with a distinct history and a distinct perspective on the meaning of larger historical events. Our parents' stories shape our historical consciousness, as do the stories of the ethnic, racial, and religious groups that number us as members. We attend churches, dubs, and neighborhood associations that further mold our collective and individual historical selves. We visit museums. We travel to national landmarks in the summer. We camp out in front of the TV and absorb, often unknowingly, an unending barrage of historical images. By the time children have celebrated a decade of Thanksgivings and Martin Luther King Days, they are already seasoned students of American culture and history.

But, the notion that all these sources form a coherent whole mocks the complexity of social life. Historical consciousness does not emanate like neat concentric circles from the individual to the family to the nation and to the world. Lessons learned at home contravene those learned at school. What we hear at school conflicts with what we hear at church or synagogue--if not in the pews then certainly in the bathrooms. If we pay attention to the lyrics of rap music or tune our dials to Rush Limbaugh or Howard Stern, we confront more disjunctures. To make historical sense, we must navigate the shoals of the competing narratives that vie for our allegiance.[ p. 55]"

Collective Occlusion In writing their piece for a social education journal, Weinburg et. al. have decided to use the wording "collective occlusion" to describe what concerns them the most in the wake of their research on cohort generations [3] of America, their media, and their education in history, specifically Vietnam War Era social education.  The researchers and authors explain that they prefer the term "collective occlusion" to a term, such as "collective amnesia" for several different reasons. 

"First, occlusion conveys a sense of blockage; it is not that these memories are erased or forgotten but they are not salient or easily seen.  Second, even when memories are occluded, they are, in historical and archival cultures. Available in books, on the Web, and often taught in specialized university seminars. "Amnesia' misrepresents the complexity of social memory by conveying monolithic, socially uniform processes.  The partiality and opacity of "occlusion' conveys this complexity more fully [p.58]."

Weinburg, et. al. wrote the following concerning the need to have awareness of collective occlusion in our curriculum development in history and social education in America by noting: "When we began this work, we hypothesized that there would be significant points of tension between the history taught in schools and the history available in film, music, and TV in the culture at large.  This may be the case but it is not what we found.  In fact, rather than forming a separate sphere, the school often became the purveyor of the history curriculum offered by popular culture, the place where young people first sat and sampled its wares:  Hollywood movies, made-for-TV documentaries, and the like. [p.57]"

I should add that the researchers spent hundreds of hours observing classrooms at three different high schools in the American Northwest for their research.  This enabled them to observe what kind of interaction the students under  investigation had with teachers in their own "official" history classes. Based on their home and family discussions (as well as blindly submitted written reports submitted from the two cohort generations in each household), the researchers  wrote, "Similarly, the home" has become "a venue in which parent and child often shared in the joint experience of the past by turning on the VCR [nowadays the CD/DVD or digital memory of mass media sources] and together [have been] witnessing a celluloid version of it."  

Importantly,  the child-generation (or younger of the two cohort generations), i.e. who had had no personal direct experience living in the Vietnam War Era, seem to have absorbed the biases and misleading information of mass-media rather than relying more on what expert witnesses and expert researchers tell them about history on-the-ground in the Vietnam era. Note: Some of these expert witnesses may have even been the parents of the very high school students under study--hence, there have certainly been some disagreements between or among the generations as to how to interpret images and history. For example, the movie Forrest Gump crept up in 60% of the interviews conducted with parents and their children, i.e. concerning the topic of the Vietnam War era.  In other words, for some of those youth interviewed "the sequences of images and dialogues, invented by director Robert Zemeckis [creator of the film Forrest Gump], was the sharpest and clearest recollection of the entire Vietnam era.[Ibid.]"

One example of occlusionary memory  (or exclusionary memory) presented by Weinburg has been the absences of information in films concerning the massive support for the Vietnam War in the USA throughout the 1960s. From watching movies and some documentaries in recent years, one often has the view that the Vietnam War was proceeding along for a decade or more with only a few supporters. This was, in fact, generally not true. Throughout the Cold War, too many Americans bought into the government's and CIA's domino theories about communism. This occlusion of memory is important because the biggest lesson of the Vietnam War is for individuals and society to not any longer simply follow our leaders (like lemmings over the next cliff).  When they try to lead us off to fight the Great Communist Myth--or the Great Eternal War on Terror Myth we must be more analytical and do our homework on the facts.  American youth have to be more introspective, question our leaders very tough early on, and stand up for what is right early on--and not stop fighting to end war and other global nonsense until all our children are brought home again.

According to Weinburg, et. al., "As late as 1972, the war . . . . having spread to Cambodia and Laos, still commanded overwhelming support in public opinion polls." This reality reflects the same lacks attitude that people have had in the USA in putting up with 13 years of endless war on terrorism that we are experiencing in 2013. Weinburg and his fellow researchers noted that despite fact that Americans had allowed themselves to be hoodwinked en-mass for so very long about the Vietnam War's importance in the greater scheme of things, "Domestic support for the Vietnam War was rarely mentioned in our interviews." 

In short, this important detail has not been made clear to subsequent generations of America, i.e. in post 1975 America. These sort of discoveries about "occlusion" and American memory led the authors to these conclusions: The belief that the "family as educator" is a dominant source for moderating or revising media, textbook and school history lessons is less of a reality than has been perceived. In short, the family's role as "history educator" is possibly not as important as it was before the age of electronic media. 

Next Page  1  |  2

 

http://eslkevin.wordpress.com/2009/07/09/3-big-paradigms-hol

KEVIN STODA-has been blessed to have either traveled in or worked in nearly 100 countries on five continents over the past two and a half decades.--He sees himself as a peace educator and have been-- a promoter of good economic and social development--making-him an enemy of my homelands humongous DEFENSE SPENDING and its focus on using weapons to try and solve global (more...)
 

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

BED-INs and Other Protests Needed Now

GULF CIVIL SOCIETY FORUM calls for Gulf Monarchies to abandon absolutism and to adopt European-style Parliaments

TRIBE, TRIBALISM AND CULTURAL CHANGE-KUWAIT 2008

PHILIPP ROESLER, of Vietnamese Descent. to Head the Health Ministry in Germany, as his own Party Plans to Push for more

WHY ARE THE TOTAL FIGURES ON UNINSURED AMERICANS and Residents between 30 MILLION & 90 MILLION? CAN'T ANYONE COUNT??

Mitigation of Tsunami's and Earthquakes--Has JAPAN DONE ENOUGH?

Comments

The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
2 people are discussing this page, with 4 comments
To view all comments:
Expand Comments
(Or you can set your preferences to show all comments, always)

The belief that the "family as educator" is a dom... by Kevin Anthony Stoda on Thursday, May 30, 2013 at 10:40:24 AM
The early years after Vietnam, there were only se... by Judy Swindler on Thursday, May 30, 2013 at 10:47:24 AM
DOD is trying to Retell the Vietnam Story-- nd is ... by Kevin Anthony Stoda on Friday, May 31, 2013 at 11:54:19 AM
The Cold War Redux?  Are Washington, Moscow... by Kevin Anthony Stoda on Friday, May 31, 2013 at 11:56:58 AM