"They've got to realize there are consequences to that," she said. "The rhetoric is incredibly heated." (- Rep. Gabrielle Giffords ' remarks about Palin's mailer after vandals attacked her office in March.)
Rhetoric: it's protected by free speech, it's guilt free, and can bring
out the creative evil in anyone. It can also kill people through
righteous assassination. And so many people have used it in history:
Pope Urban II used it to spur on the Crusades; Hitler used it for
political purposes; Father Charles Caughlin used it in this broadcasts.
And today: Ahmadinejad uses it; Osama Bin Laden uses it; Glenn Beck
uses it; Bill O'Reilly uses it. Repent Amarillo uses it. Lou Engle uses
And now we know that Sarah Palin uses it.
Ok, EVERYBODY uses it. So why is America just waking up to its very real consequences? Are we just now looking at the deleterious effects of popularity and position? Or have we become so totally bombarded with the bloviations of power and celebrity that we only skim the barest buzzwords and pay no attention to other meanings? Sarah Palin's little map with target sites says different things to different people, but with her one-track mind, Palin didn't care if anyone drew different conclusions. She probably thought she was being clever (fat chance) or folksy (better). She aimed for a metaphor of political annihilation which could have resulted in actual annihilation.
TONING IT DOWN
country's Rotten Rhetoric has got to be toned down. What we say has
become second to how we say it: impact has become more dependent on
imagery than meaning. The steam-roller effect of the imagery, however,
has gotten totally out of control and to rein it in will take a massive
effort on our part. It will take a major pushback against people like
Palin who will slough off situations like the Giffords shooting.
And the sloughing off and pious distancing has already started: "tragic" - "sickened" - "horrified" are starting to pump out of people like blood from a bullet wound. Get used to them for the next several days, because they'll be coming ad nauseum from people who vilified Giffords in no uncertain terms.
"My sincere condolences are offered to the family of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and the other victims of today's tragic shooting in Arizona. On behalf of Todd and my family, we all pray for the victims and their families, and for peace and justice."
- Sarah Palin"I am horrified by the violent attack on Representative Gabrielle Giffords and many other innocent people by a wicked person who has no sense of justice or compassion. I pray for Gabby and the other victims, and for the repose of the souls of the dead and comfort for their families.
- John McCain
BFD. Words: they can't heal as much as they can hurt. Politicians know that.
what can we do to tone down the rhetoric? Boycott Glenn Beck's
sponsors? Bombard Sarah Palin with vicious tweets of our own?
Unfortunately, we're caught in a free speech conundrum: by telling
people to tone down their Rotten Rhetoric, we're committing an act of
censorship. And waiting for political suicide to set in could be a very
long time, since people like Beck and Palin are never truly erased from
public discourse. The solution may involve education and creativity:
somehow we must make civil discourse look totally cool and Rotten
Rhetoric look totally stupid. Ironically, we may have to use the
Giffords shooting to shock people with lampoon and laughter, reminding
people like Palin that Rotten Rhetoric is a two-edged sword, resulting
in political suicide.
So SNL, what's keeping you?