The present dispute over Gay rights legislation and same sex marriage is only one of the latest incidents in the Judaeo-Christian religion's history of persecuting Gays and Lesbians. The question that arises is whether Christianity can be reformed of this bigotry or whether it is an intrinsic part of this religion. To answer this question, we must go back and examine the historical record.
When we examine the Old Testament, the anti-sexual erotophobic nature of the Judaeo-Christian tradition becomes immediately clear. The God of the Hebrews, in contrast to the gods of all the other ancient religions, is never reported to have engaged in sex with goddesses or humans. It might be objected that a monotheistic religion by its very nature cannot have other divinities for the God to have sex with, but when the oldest portions of the Old Testament were written the religion of the Hebrews was not monotheistic.
Like all their neighbors, the ancient Hebrews believed that their god was supreme in the territory they controlled, not that he was the sole god. If they were victorious or defeated in battle with neighboring people, it meant that their god had been victorious over or defeated by the neighboring god. Yet the mythologies of all the surrounding peoples attributed full sex lives to their gods, while the Hebrew god was never portrayed as having any sexual experience whatsoever. This is a clear sign that the Hebrews, in contrast to all their neighbors, believed that there was something wrong with sex, so it would be sacrilegious to attribute it to the deity.
The myth of original sin in the Garden of Eden is another example of Judaeo-Christian erotophobia. The phallic symbolism of the serpent and the "forbidden fruit" is quite clear. But if this symbolism is not enough to convince, we also learn that after they ate the forbidden fruit, Adam and Eve were ashamed of their nakedness and covered themselves with fig leaves.
Furthermore, the punishment for the original sin also is sexual, for the myth has God saying to Eve in Genesis 4:16: "I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception. In sorrow thou shall bring forth children. And thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee."
Because of the above passage in the Biblical myth, many Christians in the past opposed all medical efforts to facilitate painless childbirth, and some still use it to argue against equal rights for women.
This erotophobic attitude of the ancient Hebrews was intensified to an even greater extreme in Christianity. There is no sex in the Christian heaven and Christian mythology claims that when God became incarnate in human form, he was born of a virgin without the aid of sex.
Paul intensified Christian erotophobia even further when he stated in I Corinthians 7: 8-9: "I say therefore to the unmarried and widows, it is good for them to abide even as I. But if they cannot contain, let them marry: for it is better to marry than to burn."
It is instructive, while examining the connection between the religious mythology of a culture and its sexual mores, to look at an offshoot of the Judaeo-Christian tradition where the erotophobia has been attenuated. Muslim law prescribes death for Gays. Yet in most Islamic countries this law is seldom enforced and sexual relations between members of the same sex are viewed to be as normal a part of life as heterosexual relations. This is especially the case in Morocco. C.A. Tripp points out in The Homosexual Matrix that "A number of sex researchers from Havelock Ellis to Kinsey have estimated that homosexual activity outnumbers heterosexual activity in Arabic countries."
The recent press coverage of Islamic fundamentalism may give the impression that Islam is even worse than Christianity when it comes to anti Gay bigotry. Yet the law calling for the death penalty is seldom enforced, especially since several witnesses are required for a conviction. Even in Afghanistan, where rural women will often run and hide in their houses if a strange man approaches their village, local warlords would often select youths to be their concubines. The youth's family would say he was working for the local warlord so it was not talked about openly, but everyone knew what the family meant when they said their son was working for the local warlord.
And when we look at Islamic religious mythology, we find an attenuation of Judaeo-Christian erotophobia. There is sex in the Muslim heaven. Sura LII, 20-24 of the Koran promises that in paradise one can enjoy "houris with large eyes," while the pleasures of Gay sex are promised in Sura LXXVI, 19, where one may enjoy "immortal ephebes, whom you might take for separate pearls."
Almost all authorities are agreed that virtually all the cultures of the ancient world accepted Gays and Lesbians. These authorities include Hans Licht, Sexual Life in Ancient Greece; Edward Westermarck, The Origin and Development of Moral Ideas; Wainwright Churchill, Homosexual Behavior Among Males; and C.C. Ford and F. A. Beach, Patterns of Sexual Behavior.
These authorities report acceptance of Gays and Lesbians among the Greeks, Germans, Scandinavians, Egyptians, Etruscans, Cretans, Carthaginians, Sumerians, Chinese and Japanese. In India, the penalty was only a ritual of self-cleansing in water instead of the Christian penalty of death by fire. Ford and Beach report that in a recent survey of anthropological data, 49 out of 76, or 64 percent of the cultures for which information was available, accepted some form of Gay or Lesbian sex.
In a study of 193 world cultures, P. Hoch and J. Zubin reported in Psychosexual Development in Health and Disease that 28 percent of the cultures totally accepted male Gays, 58 percent partially accepted them, and only 14 percent rejected Gays. The corresponding figures for Lesbians were 10 percent, 79 percent and 11 percent. It is no wonder then that psychologist Wardell B. Pomeroy stated in his essay "Homosexuality", printed in The Same Sex, that Western culture is almost unique not only in its rejection of Gays and Lesbians but in the prescriptions, the anxieties and the rigidities with which it has surrounded sex in general.
D.J. West states in Homosexuality; "for a perfect example of a homosexually oriented civilization none can compare with classical Greece. When Plato wrote so sublimely of the emotions and aspirations of love he was describing what we would call perversion." The pre-Christian Romans had only one law dealing with Gays, the Lex Scautinia, and it only prohibited sex between a freeborn youth and a slave. By the time of the Empire, even this was not enforced.
However, there was an increasing asceticism in the last centuries of the ancient world as people turned from the increasing hardships of this world to the joys of an imaginary better world. Christianity, as a fusion between Hebrew religion and Greek philosophy, combined the worst aspects of the erotophobia in both. Although the first Christian emperor, Constantine, did not pass any laws against Gays, his successor, Constantius issued a decree in 342 A.D. calling for Gays to be beheaded. The penalty of burning alive was first decreed by Valentinian II on August 6, 390 A.D. The practice of burning gays alive continued in Europe until the latter part of the 18th century.
DOB -- September 20, 1940. Became active in civil rights and peace movements in 1962. Active in socialist and antiwar movements -- 1963-69. Active in Gay Liberation from 1969 to present.