By Paul Jacobs for The Californian, a newspaper for southwest Riverside County, CA as published and posted (www.nctimes.com) for 4/6/08:
On two separate occasions, Riverside County Supervisor John Tavaglione has referred to Secretary of State Debra Bowen as "nuts" or "nutty" for having the audacity to test and conditionally recertify voting systems found to be vulnerable to tampering.
While Tavaglione resorts to name-calling, last month Ms. Bowen was named a winner of the John F. Kennedy Profile in Courage Award for challenging the reliability of electronic voting systems. The award is presented annually to public servants who have made decisions of conscience without regard for personal or professional consequences.
It confounds me how Tavaglione and Supervisor Jeff Stone act like babies when it comes to these voting machines. Babies will cry when you take away a favorite toy after you discover it's dangerously coated with lead paint. Voting machines have the potential to poison the well of democracy.
Stone is a pharmacist by trade and relies heavily on science in his occupation. How can he reject the science that analyzed a number of voting systems and found them to be insecure?
It took courage for Bowen to severely restrict the use of touch-screen voting machines after university computer scientists determined that they could be hacked. The decision infuriated voting machine manufacturers and their advocates serving as county election officials. There have been cries and complaints that the machines weren't tested in real-world conditions.
The real world recently showed us that besides being courageous, Bowen was correct in her action. A March news article revealed that each of 300 separate computer servers in an East Coast supermarket chain had been infected with malicious software that sent credit card information offshore for three months before being detected.
The attack involved a level of sophistication that seemed to surprise even some computer security experts. The first sign of the software breach was when a credit card company notified the Hannaford chain of the fraudulent activity.
Nobody rechecks much of anything three months after an election, and any hidden malware is likely to remain undiscovered forever.
Money is precious and financial institutions go to great lengths to protect their digital transactions. Hannaford had its software certified for security a year ago and again as recently as Feb. 27. If nefarious programmers have the capacity and inclination to steal information, what would it be worth to be able to steal an election?
Bowen is certainly deserving of this recognition, but all is not well just because most of us are now using paper ballots. The ballots are counted with the use of high-speed optical scanners that use secret, proprietary software to tally the votes. The touch-screen cartridges made a bad system ridiculously vulnerable, and the removal of 80 percent of the voting machines from the precincts only lessens the risk.
We must insist that our ballots be counted in the precincts and then checked against a central tally of the votes. Audit methods that ensure a statistical validity of the results must be employed, and the counting process has to be transparent to the public.
It isn't nutty to take steps to protect a democracy that is more precious than money. It takes courage to seek the facts and then act upon them. Where is that courage in our county seat of government?
Paul Jacobs is a regular columnist for The Californian. E-mail him at TemeculaPaul@aol.com.
Paul has worked in health care for the past 30 years and writes a weekly column for a local newspaper in California. He is involved in local civics, a member of Citizens for Democracy, Temecula Valley and active in the election integrity movement. Paul has been on the planet for 48 years and married to his soul mate for 27 years and counting.
I am so pleased today to read that you have won a “Profiles in Courage” award. My warmest congratulations. I read all about the sensible, fair and courageous stand you took at the time. I believe you blazed the way for others in other states to take similar stands --although, until we are back to paper ballots and hand counting, our efforts to regain our democracy are not over.
“It is not the votes that count; it is the vote counters.” Stalin, cynically.
“It's not the voting that's democracy, it's the counting.” Tom Stoppard
“The spirit of resistance to government is so valuable on certain occasions, that I wish it always to be kept alive.” Thomas Jefferson
Thank you for helping us regain our democracy after two stolen presidential elections.
by
Christie (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 143 comments)
on Monday, April 7, 2008 at 12:57:21 PM
The great CA Secretary of State Debra Bowen showed great courage last week when announcing her continuing advocacy for the open source code voting movement. While she commended those of us on the front lines of this battle, we are reminded of the slow pace of the painstaking process. The open voting community stands in solidarity with the Secretary while continuing to urge her to expedite at all cost. Certainly November 2008 was the initial goal for all activists- now we are being pushed back to 2010 and beyond. We look to leader Bowen to decertify (and not recertify) all scientifically concluded vulnerable systems. SOS Bowen has the expertise and bravery to move California towards open source paper ballot systems - We applaud her for her encouragement and appreciate her direction towards specific California counties that may be the first to step into the light of transparency-
At the California Democratic Convention- Everyone from Speaker Pelosi to Chairman Torres received a " voting system on a disk" to highlight the available open source technology ballot printer. With this system, developed by Alan Dechert and vetted by UC Berkeley and MIT, the open source system produces a flawless papaer ballot. No more errant markings- No more ballot shortages. Hopefully the officials will analyze their "gift " and we will; move towards better systems soon- Brent Turner
by
Brent Turner (1 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 94 comments)
on Monday, April 7, 2008 at 1:08:26 PM
2 comments
How would you rate this?
You must be logged in (if signed up) to do ratings.
It's free to signup! And easy. And takes just a minute or two....
Must Read (
Well Said (
News (
Touching (
Funny (
Supported (
Interesting (
Inspiring (
Valuable (
