Share on Google Plus Share on Twitter Share on Facebook 1 Share on LinkedIn Share on PInterest Share on Fark! Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Tell A Friend 3 (4 Shares)  
Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites View Stats

OpEdNews Op Eds

What If?

By (about the author)     Permalink       (Page 1 of 1 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

Must Read 12   Well Said 12   Valuable 10  
View Ratings | Rate It

opednews.com Headlined to H2 2/21/13

Become a Fan
  (393 fans)
- Advertisement -
Cross-posted from Paul Craig Roberts



"What If?" histories are a good read. They are entertaining, and they provoke thought and encourage the imagination. How different the world would be if different judgments, decisions, and circumstances had prevailed at history's turning points. Certainly English history would have been different if King Harold's soldiers had obeyed his order not to pursue the defeated fleeing Normans down the hill. This broke the impenetrable Saxon shield wall and exposed King Harold to Norman calvary.

Would there ever have been a Soviet Union if the Czar had stayed out of World War I?

Would there have been a World War II if British, French, and American politicians had listened to John Maynard Keynes' warning that the Treaty of Versailles would result in a second world war? Germany had been promised a different outcome -- no reparations and no territorial loss -- in exchange for an armistice. As Keynes realized, the betrayal of the peace led to another great war.

There are a couple of what ifs that I have been waiting for historians to explore. As no historians have risen to the challenge, I will have a go. Keep in mind that a what-if outcome is not necessarily a better outcome. It might be a worse outcome. As what if did not happen and there is no what if history, there is no way of making a judgment.

Suppose Churchill had not succeeded in pressuring Chamberlain to interfere with Hitler's negotiations with the Polish colonels by issuing a British guarantee to Poland in the event of German aggression. Would World War II have resulted or would it have been a different war?

The British guarantee emboldened the colonels and frustrated Hitler's attempt to restore a Germany dismantled by the Versailles Treaty. The result was Hitler's secret pact with Stalin to divide up Poland, technically known as the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact.

- Advertisement -

Having given the guarantee, Britain was honor-bound to declare war on Germany (fortunately not also on the Soviet Union), which pulled in France because of the British-French alliance against Germany.

Without Britain's guarantee, the German (September 1, 1939) and Soviet (September 17, 1939) invasions of Poland would have been prevented by the Polish colonels' acquiescence to Hitler's demands and would not have resulted in Britain and France starting World War II by declaring war on Germany, resulting in the fall of France, the British driven off the continent, and Roosevelt's determination to involve the US in a foreign war unrelated in any significant way to Americans' interests.

Historians write that Hitler's ambitions were in the East, not the West. Without the British and French declaration of war, the war might have been contained, with the two totalitarian powers fighting it out.

Alternatively, Hitler and Stalin might have continued their cooperation and together seized the oil rich Middle East. The British, French, and Americans would have been a poor match for the German and Soviet militaries. General Patton, the best American commander, thought he could take on the Red Army that had crushed the Wehrmacht, but his hubris did not worry Red Army commanders, who defeated the bulk of the German Army, which was deployed on the Eastern Front, while the Americans, aided by German motorized units running out of fuel, struggled to contain a small part of German forces in the Battle of the Bulge. Today we would be buying our oil from a German/Soviet consortium.

This outcome implies a different history for the Middle East, and so does another what if. What if the 9/11 Commission consisted of experts instead of politicians with their fingers in the wind, and what if the commissioners had too much integrity to write a report dictated by the executive branch? The unlikely and untenable failure of every institution of the American national security state would have been investigated, and the collapse of WTC 7 at free-fall speed would have had to have been acknowledged in the report and explained. A totally different story would have emerged, a story unlikely to have locked Americans into permanent war in an expanding number of countries and into a domestic police state.

- Advertisement -

Americans might still be a free people. And American liberty might still be a beacon to the world.

On the other hand, a finding of government complicity in 9/11 could have threatened powerful interests and resulted in violent conflict and martial law.

What ifs are provocative, and that is what makes them fun. Thinking is America's national disability. I'm all for anything that provokes Americans to think.

 

http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/

Dr. Roberts was Assistant Secretary of the US Treasury for Economic Policy in the Reagan Administration. He was associate editor and columnist with the Wall Street Journal, columnist for Business Week and the Scripps Howard News Service. He is a contributing editor to Gerald Celente's Trends Journal. He has had numerous university appointments. His book, The Failure of Laissez Faire Capitalism and Economic Dissolution of the West is available here. His latest book,  How America Was Lost, has just been released and can be ordered here.

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon


Go To Commenting

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles
- Advertisement -

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Libya - The DC/NATO Agenda And The Next Great War

The Road to Armageddon

American Job Loss Is Permanent

A Story...The Last Whistleblower

Pakistan TV Report Contradicts US Claim of Bin Laden's Death

Comments

The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
17 people are discussing this page, with 25 comments
To view all comments:
Expand Comments
(Or you can set your preferences to show all comments, always)
Hitler invaded Poland because it he needed it to b... by Peter Winkler on Thursday, Feb 21, 2013 at 10:44:44 PM
I think PCR would be impressed by your thinking, p... by Paul McArthur on Sunday, Feb 24, 2013 at 12:15:38 PM
JFK, MLK and RFK hadn't been assassinated? Or at t... by 911TRUTH on Thursday, Feb 21, 2013 at 11:49:41 PM
to enforce the law?Say, "What?!?" No one told us n... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 11:50:11 AM
most folks who claim to care don't care enough to ... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 11:40:57 AM
Woodrow Wilson hadn't signed the Federal Reserve A... by intotheabyss on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 8:15:18 AM
However, I wonder if Wilson had much of a choice.F... by Amy Schreiner on Saturday, Mar 30, 2013 at 9:04:19 PM
that  was said once by a Russian historian.&n... by Mark Sashine on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 9:11:19 AM
Possibly a ruling by the International Court of Ju... by manifesto 2000 on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 2:08:27 PM
"If certain acts of violation of treaties are cri... by Lance Ciepiela on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 10:05:01 AM
Is the screenplay written by them ? Could they hav... by Ad Du on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 9:56:10 PM
even when considering Woodrow Wilson signing the F... by Amy Schreiner on Saturday, Mar 30, 2013 at 8:52:47 PM
What if Pres Johnson had publisized the fact that ... by Poor old Dirt farmer on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 11:10:32 AM
What if Eisenhower hadn't hired the thoroughly cor... by Poor old Dirt farmer on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 11:48:10 AM
had to happen.  The Jews insist upon dominati... by Mike Stewart on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 2:13:10 PM
not all jews are banksters, for heavens' sake! yo... by JoAnne VanDatta on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 4:24:49 PM
Is the above statement correct?Certainly you are c... by Mike Stewart on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 6:35:23 PM
In fact, taking into account gender and other cons... by Kim Cassidy on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 11:30:22 PM
Is there a reading comprehension problem on this s... by Mike Stewart on Sunday, Feb 24, 2013 at 10:54:43 AM
What if the people actually woke up, took notice a... by Deborah Dills on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 5:48:55 PM
People need to educate themselves and stop believi... by dorothy przystas on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 9:11:42 PM
  School, of course. Not doing multiplic... by Ad Du on Friday, Feb 22, 2013 at 9:40:10 PM
but it turned out that many people were tired of t... by Mark Sashine on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 9:12:16 AM
and I see what you see and it sickens me also. It'... by intotheabyss on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 3:17:50 PM
The Iroquois Nation had decided not to allow Europ... by Daniel Geery on Saturday, Feb 23, 2013 at 12:40:45 PM