Tags for This Article:

Children (920) Environment-Ecology (647) Congress 110th (553) Children (192) Activism Environmental (134) Parents (123) Activism Environmental (122) Environmentalism (94) Environment-Ecology (79) toxic products (64) CHILDRENS HEALTH CARE (55) Congress 109th (53) Product Safety (21) Product Recall (19)


Populum
Tag Cloud
Control Panel

Fine tune your search to access content

Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (more...) ; ; ;  (less...)
Add to My Group
June 20, 2008 at 18:09:55

View Ratings | Rate It

Lead Toy Recalls Continue While Congress Piddles

by Patty Bates-Ballard     Page 1 of 2 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 

Tell A Friend

Lead Toy Recalls Continue While Congress Piddles: Parents Urged to Fill Gaps with Advocacy and Vigilance 

With all the attention on lead in toys after the seven Mattel/Fisher-Price recalls in 2007, you might have assumed the issue was resolved. Think again. From January through June 2008, the there have been more than 50 recalls of over a million products due to high lead content. The vast majority of these recalled products are children's products. 

The latest was a recall of children's camouflage(!) pajamas with leaded paint from The Children's Place. Last month, Disney Tinkerbelle wands, Pirates of the Caribbean sleeping bags, Rawlings batting helmets, and children's brightly painted storage bins sold at Lowes were recalled because they violate the US lead paint standard. Inexpensive children's jewelry and other similar metal items continue to be recalled regularly. 

Why should this register on your very full parent-radar? Just one instance of ingesting lead can permanently harm a child, potentially lowering his or her IQ and impulse control, among other things. Yet many children do not show obvious symptoms. If not identified by a blood test, lead poisoning can continue undetected for years. 

Why do lead recalls continue unabated? Chinese manufacturers as well as manufacturers in many other developing countries have used lead paint on wooden and plastic toys for years because it makes the paint last longer and it's inexpensive. Many continue to sidestep US protocols against the use of lead, putting profit above child safety. Current product inspections can't possibly catch every product that contains lead.  

So parents must do two things: we must be advocates and we must be vigilant. If Congress were to pass legislation that imposes hefty fines on importers of products that violate the US lead paint standard, I think we'd find violations plummeting. 

House Resolution 4040 and Senate Bill 2663 are two measures that would increase penalties for violations of lead content standards from $ 1.25 million to $20 million, require third party testing, reduce the number of allowed parts per million from 600 to 100 and increase the budget of the Consumer Public Safety Commission.  

But even after parents whose children were lead poisoned by toys visited Washington to tell their stories, the bills are treading water in Congress. HR 4040 has passed the House and is in conference. Representatives Dingell, Waxman, Rush, DeGette, Schakowsky, Barton (TX), Whitfield (KY), and Stearns are the House conferees. S 2045 passed the Senate and then was replaced by S 2663, which has not yet come up for a vote. Senator Harry Reid controls the calendar for senate votes. Congress meets for only 2 ½ more months this year, so please take a moment to contact your elected officials to help push these measures through. You can check the website Open Congress and the Center for Justice and Democracy for the latest information. 

The Wall Street Journal reports that as many as twelve states have grown weary of waiting on Congress and are working on their own varying standards, which means confusion for manufacturers and eventually higher priced toys.  Either way, it's too late to have new standards in place to affect toys being made for the 2008 Christmas season. So in the meantime, parents need to become ever-vigilant experts at minimizing the risk of lead poisoning to our children.  

Vigilance means keeping up with lead related recalls of toys, children's jewelry, children's clothing and more by watching the news regularly and frequently checking the Consumer Product Safety Commission's recall announcements and product safety alerts here: http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prerel.html. But since there is a recall every few days, something you already own could contain lead. So vigilance means keeping all toys out of children's mouths as much as humanly possible. 

Vigilance also means avoiding toys, shower curtains, clothing etc. that have a strong chemical smell because they are probably made of softened PVC, a material that often includes lead. If you buy US or European made toys, you'll decrease the risk greatly, though they are hard to find these days.  

But because lead accumulates in the body, we can't restrict our vigilance to toys and other children's products. Lead is everywhere in our environment. Electronic components contain lead, cadmium, mercury and other heavy metals. So, as tempting as it is when a child is crying, don't let small children play with cell phones, remote controls, batteries and other similar electronic items until they are old enough to keep them out of their mouths.   

Did you know that porcelain bathtubs and sinks can leach lead, especially if the enamel is worn, chipping or stained? If you want to know for sure whether your tub is leaching lead, you can pick up an inexpensive test kit at a hardware store. You might be surprised at what you find. Many bathtub refinishers say that the majority of the tubs they examine test positive for lead. Until you know for sure, don't let your child drink bath water. Keep all sponges, brushes and anything else you use to clean the tub and sink in child-proof cabinets because they will end up in a toddler's mouth in a flash.  

Ceramic dishes with lead glaze and lead crystal are additional sources of lead poisoning, including leaded glass in doors. Many Christmas light cords, some off-brand crayons, some cosmetics and home remedies, and even some candies made outside the US contain extremely high levels of lead. 

Don't let children chew on any painted surfaces and keep paint chips off the floor because the paint may contain lead. Children should be removed from a house built before 1980 that is being sanded for repainting. Vinyl materials like window blinds can contain lead, so keep them out of little mouths.  

The burning of leaded gasoline until 1996 emitted lead into the air which settled everywhere in the soil and dust. So don't let children eat dirt. Wash children's hands several times a day and especially after playing outside to remove any traces of lead they may have picked up from our ubiquitous lead-laden dirt and dust.  

 1  |  2

 

Take action -- click here to contact your local newspaper or congress people:
Move HR 4040 and S 2663 to the president's desk! Protect our children from lead toys and other hazards!

Click here to see the most recent messages sent to congressional reps and local newspapers

Patty Bates-Ballard is a mother and writer who advocates respect for the earth and its people. The owner of WordSmooth, a Dallas based communications company, Patty has just published her first book, Navigating Diversity. She also has written for Environmental Design & Construction Magazine, the American Association of Naturopathic Medical Colleges and World Press, among others. Patty's Socha diversity + effectiveness workshops have been delivered to thousands of employees across the country. A graduate of Austin College, Patty works from her home in Dallas, Texas, where she raises her sons, Kory and Kaden.

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
3 comments

Patty Bates-Ballard is a mother and writer who advocates respect for the earth and its people. The owner of WordSmooth, a Dallas based communications company, Patty has just published her first book, Navigating Diversity. She also has written for Environmental Design & Construction Magazine, the American Association of Naturopathic Medical Colleges and World Press, among others.

Patty's Socha diversity + effectiveness workshops have been delivered to thousands of employees across th...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Patty Bates-BallardPatty Bates-Ballard is a mother and writer who advocates respect for the earth and its people. The owner of WordSmooth, a Dallas based communications company, Patty has just published her first book, Navigating Diversity. She also has written for Environmental Design & Construction Magazine, the American Association of Naturopathic Medical Colleges and World Press, among others.

Patty's Socha diversity + effectiveness workshops have been delivered to thousands of employees across th...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Letter from parents whose children suffered lead poisoning

If you're not sure whether it's worth your time to keep toys out of your children's mouths and wash their hands, please read this letter from three parents whose children suffered lead poisoning. They describe symptoms of stomach pains, bowel problems, behavior changes and more. http://www.centerjd.org/LettertoMattel.pdf

by Patty Bates-Ballard (7 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 7 comments) on Saturday, June 21, 2008 at 9:11:02 PM
 


Product safety consultant who has worked in the field of child safety for over 10 years
Don MoffettProduct safety consultant who has worked in the field of child safety for over 10 years

Amazing the ignorance

The ignorance of people on this subject continues to amaze me. These new regulations will do absolutely nothing to change what is happening. Let's talk about a few points this author raises.

First, the author claims this new "miracle bill" will stop the flow of defective products into the US. I'm sorry, no matter how much you would like this to happen, it simply won't. There are laws in place right now that make this illegal and outline how companies can be fined. The new law being proposed does nothing to alter this structure. We recall products that don't comply, and the reason we see so many more recalls right now is because companies are doing more testing and finding out about issues that went unnoticed previously.

Second, the author claims that the new penalities will force companies into fixing their process. There are fines on the books right now that CPSC could use against companies, but they don't because they are more interested in companies coming forward and removing products they discover that don't comply (more of a partnership). If CPSC started fining every company that had a recall, it would have a chilling effect on the industry and recalls would actually drop. The most success CPSC has had is getting the Fast Track Recall program up and running that makes it easier for companies to recall. If they now start fining every company, nobody would come forward willingly. Having a heavier fine looks great on paper so the politicians can "look" tough, but it would never be used except for companies that actively ignore the requirements. These companies are already fined significant amounts. Any "big" players have more at stake and a larger fine is not a major deterrent.

 Lastly, the author's claim about PVC being the cause of the smell from shower curtains is a big example of the ignorance being spread by those people who don't know anything about the issues. The smell is not caused by PVC, it is caused by chemicals called VOCs (volatile organic compounds) typically mixed in with PVC for processing or that are a result from the processing. These gases also dissipate to non-existent levels with 48-72 hours, so there are not the "killer shower curtains" out there killing people like the author would love for you to believe. Other uninformed people link this smell to phthalates also, which is an outright lie. Please get your facts straight and do a better job researching before spreading more misinformation.

All in all, I am all for more consistent regulatory standards (especially to preempt State requirements that are driven entirely by politics). However, these bills in Congress are nothing but political posturing so the parties on both sides can look tough and say they're doing something. Why is it that politicians think they know more about product safety than the agency that has scientists working in the area of product safety every day for the past 30+ years? Fix the funding issue with the bills to get CPSC funded properly, but let them do their job on the scientific parts. The issue is with the funding, not the regulations.

PS - Another point about electrical products. The paranoia and ignorance of the author shows here also. The components that contain lead (typically solder) is all internal to electrical products. There is little to no risk of anything outside these products likely to cause harm. You should be more concerned about small parts than lead in these items, so this is just more paranoia from an uninformed source.

 

Plus did anyone note the great enlightenment of "So don't let children eat dirt." I think this says it all...

by Don Moffett (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 1 comments) on Monday, June 23, 2008 at 2:15:59 PM
 


Patty Bates-Ballard is a mother and writer who advocates respect for the earth and its people. The owner of WordSmooth, a Dallas based communications company, Patty has just published her first book, Navigating Diversity. She also has written for Environmental Design & Construction Magazine, the American Association of Naturopathic Medical Colleges and World Press, among others.

Patty's Socha diversity + effectiveness workshops have been delivered to thousands of employees across th...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Patty Bates-BallardPatty Bates-Ballard is a mother and writer who advocates respect for the earth and its people. The owner of WordSmooth, a Dallas based communications company, Patty has just published her first book, Navigating Diversity. She also has written for Environmental Design & Construction Magazine, the American Association of Naturopathic Medical Colleges and World Press, among others.

Patty's Socha diversity + effectiveness workshops have been delivered to thousands of employees across th...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Discourtesy does not promote solutions

Don, 

Perhaps your line of work has given you insight into some of these issues beyond mine. While I may not be the foremost expert on manufacturing or on lead, your name-calling is extreme and discourteous. Ignorant I am not. Neither am I paranoid. Lead poisoning of a child is no trivial matter and it's likely that I know more about it than you do.

You make a number of other misstatements in your diatribe as well. I don’t claim the bill will stop the flow of defective products. I write that I think the number of toys that violate the lead standard will plummet if hefty fines are levied. I respect your right to your disagree.

 

But it’s not hard to find evidence that large fines have the ability to elicit greater compliance. Millions of parents disagree with you about the success of the current system. Sure, fix the CPSC funding issues and help manufacturers access the information and tools they need to comply, but it’s time to send a loud message that the status quo is unacceptable. It doesn’t have to be either-or; it can be all of the above.

 

While vinyl’s chemical smell doesn’t come from the PVC itself but the plasticizers that are added to soften the PVC in toys and shower curtains (that point is now clarified in the article), your parsing is a red herring that diverts attention from the point, which is that PVC often contains lead.

 

I’m guessing from your snide comments about not letting children eat dirt and the low threat of the insides of electronic items that you have not been a parent of a small active child recently.

 

I welcome additional input but in the future please leave the judgments out of the discussion. They don't bring us any closer to solutions.

by Patty Bates-Ballard (7 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 7 comments) on Tuesday, June 24, 2008 at 12:17:56 AM
 

 

3 comments

 

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

Breaking The Real "Last Taboo" - The Things No One Dares To Say by Frank Schaeffer

John S. Greenway by AJ Buttacavoli

Cancer Full Moon January 10-11 2009 by Cathy Lynn Pagano

Who is Black America's Moral Emissary to the World? by Glen Ford

Amnesty vs. AIPAC: Senate to Consider AIPAC Resolution Endorsing War in Gaza by Robert Naiman

Unlawful Assembly by David Swanson

Boot Bush on 19th by David Swanson

Will There Be a Recovery? by Paul Craig Roberts

More about sociopaths in American politics by Gene Messick

Orangutans Hate Changes in Their Cages by Stephen Pizzo

Go To Top 50 Most Popular

 

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2009