Exclusive to OpEdNews:
Not Shown

Does the Supreme Court Represent the Citizens of America?

By       Message Dana Jill Simpson     Permalink
      (Page 1 of 2 pages)
Related Topic(s): , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

View Ratings | Rate It

opednews.com Headlined to None 4/8/10

- Advertisement -

Does the Supreme Court Represent the Citizens of America?

Every fall in the United States thousands of first year law students, start law school. Most have a dream of some day sitting on the Supreme Court bench. However, very few if any of those students will ever sit in the United States Capital on the Supreme Court. There are one hundred and ninety nine accredited law schools, according to the ABA and over a hundred unaccredited law schools in the United States. There are over one million one hundred forty three thousand three hundred fifty eight lawyers today in the United States, according to the ABA. There are only nine seats on the Supreme Court at any one time. The likelihood of winning the lottery is probably more likely for a lawyer than acquiring one of those seats on the Supreme Court.

It has recently been announced that in the next couple of months Judge John Paul Stevens, the senior associate on the Supreme Court, will be retiring. So one of the one million one hundred forty three thousand three hundred fifty eight lawyers is about to get a new job on the United States Supreme Court. There have been several candidates recently named for this position. No one knows who will get the position but it is likely that only a very extremely elite group of lawyers from Ivy League schools in the northeast will even be considered. There are fifty states in the United States but if one carefully reviews the Supreme Court Justices, one will notice that for many years the Ivy Leagues have dominated the Supreme Court. Further, one would also notice that the Supreme Court member's religion plays a role in the selection as well. It is my intention to outline the colleges that the current Supreme Court Justices sitting on the Supreme Court attended to show a bias for three Ivy League schools. Further, it is my intention to outline the potential candidate's education for the soon to be open seat on the Supreme Court to show that the President is looking at continuing to allow the Supreme Court to be dominated by Ivy League Northeasterners. I believe the public will be startled when they see just how elitist getting on the United States Supreme Court is. This situation needs to be corrected by President Obama, who is the "Peoples President' of America. He should considered appointing Supreme Court Justices from all over the United States while he is sitting as President of the United States in Washington. For far too long the Supreme Court has been an elitist Ivory Tower dominated by Harvard University and New York lawyers. It is time for the Supreme Court to represent the people of the United States of America all across this great land. President Obama needs to look at this list and how lopsided it is. When you consider that, we have over one hundred and ninety nine accredited law schools across the United States.

Currently sitting on the Supreme Court is John Roberts; he is Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. He was born in Buffalo New York. His family moved to northern Indiana when his father retired as the CEO of Bethlehem Steel. He graduated from Harvard College and Harvard Law School. While at Harvard Law School, he was managing editor of the Harvard Law Review. He taught at Georgetown University for several years as well during his career as a lawyer. Justice Roberts is one of six Catholics on the Supreme Court.

Another lawyer on the Supreme Court bench is Stephen G. Breyer. He grew up in San Francisco California where his father was a lawyer. He received a B.A. in philosophy at Stanford University. He then attended Magadalen College in Oxford and received a bachelor of law degree. Upon returning to the United States, he received an LLB at Harvard University. He practiced law a few years and taught at Harvard University from 1967 until 1994. Justice Breyer is one of the two Jews on the Supreme Court.

The third lawyer to attend Harvard Law School currently sitting on the bench is Ruth Bader Ginsburg. She was born in Brooklyn New York and received her B.A. at Cornell University at Ithaca New York. She attended Harvard Law School and had already been put on the Harvard Law Review when her husband graduated and got a job in New York. She then transferred to the University of Columbia Law School and was placed on law review. Ms. Ginsberg during her career taught at Rutgers Law and Columbia University. Also during the summers, she taught at Tulane University. Justice Ginsberg is one of the two Jews currently serving on the Supreme Court.

The fourth Harvard trained lawyer on the United States Supreme Court currently is Anthony M. Kennedy. He was born and raised in Sacramento California. He received his B.A. from Stanford University in California. He attended his senior year of under graduate school at the London School of Economics. He received his law degree from Harvard University Law School. Mr. Kennedy has been teaching for years at the McGeorge School of Law at the University of the Pacific. He teaches each summer, as he sits on the bench, at Salzberg Austria. Justice Kennedy is one of the six Catholics serving on the Supreme Court.

The fifth Justice on the bench to be trained at Harvard Law School is Antonin Scalia. He is the first Italian Supreme Court Justice even though he never learned to speak Italian in his home as it was not allowed by his parents. Justice Scalia was raised in TrentonNew Jersey. He attended school in New York, which is where his family moved when he was a little boy. Justice Scalia obtained his under graduate degree at Georgetown University in Washington DC. During the time, he was at Georgetown University he went to Fribourg Switzerland to study. He attended law school at Harvard Law School and was notes editor for the Harvard Law Review. After graduating, he became a Sheldon Fellow at Harvard. That fellowship allowed him to travel to Europe. During the time, that Justice Scalia was practicing law he taught at the University of Virginia, the University of Chicago and a visiting professor at Stanford in California. Justice Scalia is famous for being one of the first faculty advisors for the Federalist Society at a law school in the United States. Justice Scalia is one of the six Catholics serving on the Supreme Court.

- Advertisement -

The sixth Supreme Court Justice that should be looked at closely is John Paul Stevens. Justice Stevens is the Justice retiring this term. He is currently the oldest member of the Court. He is from Chicago Illinois. He obtained his B.A. degree at the University of Chicago. He was working on a master's degree when he decided to join the United States Navy. While in the Navy, he became an intelligence officer in the Pacific Theater between 1942 and 1945. Justice Stevens during his military time was awarded a bronze star for his code breaking team whose work led to the downing of the Japanese Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto's plane in 1943. When he finished his military tour, he enrolled in Northwestern University School of Law where he had the highest GPA in the history of the school in Chicago. Justice Stevens in 1969 was hired as lead council by the Greenberg Commission. The Greenberg Commission was appointed by the Illinois Supreme Court to investigate corrupt judges on the state bench. Justice Stevens proved to be an extremely tough special prosecutor for the commission and was able to force out of office Chief Justice Klingbiel and Chief Justice Solfisbugor. As a result, he caught the eye of President Richard Nixon who appointed him to his first position and then several years later President Gerald Ford appointed him to the United States Supreme Court. Justice Stevens is the only Protestant on the Supreme Court today. His seat on the bench is going to be very hard to fill.

The seventh Supreme Court Justice is Clarence Thomas. Justice Thomas is the only current African-American Justice sitting on the bench. Mr. Thomas grew up in Pin Point Georgia and attended high school in Savannah Georgia. After attending high school there was a period in Justice Thomas' life where he thought he wanted to be a Catholic Priest. During that time, he attended Saint John Vianney's Minor in Savannah on the Isle of Hope. He also attended Conception Seminary College, a Roman Catholic Seminary in Missouri. On recommendation of a Catholic Nun, he attended and received his B.A. from the College of the Holy Cross in Worcester Massachusetts. He then attended Yale Law School and has always said he was in the middle of his class. Justice Thomas is one of the six Catholics that sit on the Supreme Court today.

The eighth Supreme Court Justice, Samuel Alito, is the second Justice on the Supreme Court to attend Yale Law School. He is also the second Italian on the United States Supreme Court. He grew up in Hamilton Township New Jersey. He received his under graduate degree from Princeton University. He then attended Yale Law School where he served as editor of the Yale Law Journal. He also studied Italian legal system for a while in Italy. Upon returning to the States, he practiced law and taught at Seton Hall University School of Law in Newark New Jersey. He is a member of the Federalist Society. Justice Alito is a member of the Catholic faith.

The ninth Supreme Court Justice is Sonia Sotomayor, who was born in the SE Bronx New York. She is the first Hispanic Supreme Court Judge and is of Puerto Rican descent and is the third Yale Law School trained Justice on the Supreme Court. She received her under graduate degree at Princeton University. After graduating from Princeton, Justice Sotomayor attended Yale Law School and was an editor on the Yale Law Journal. After graduating, she practiced law in New York City and taught at the law school at Columbia University. She is also one of the six Catholics on the Supreme Court.

As one can tell all of our Supreme Court Judges except for one graduated at either Yale or Harvard Law School. The exception to this rule is Judge Stevens who is the lone Protestant and non Ivy Leaguer, even though he attended the pricey Northwestern University Law School.

- Advertisement -

Clearly, he is the voice of all the ordinary Joe's and Jane's in the United States so whoever replaces him needs to be similarly situated. However, I think it important to let you know what kind of person President Obama is considering replacing his seat with. In recent weeks, five potential candidates have been named as a replacement for Justice Stevens.

The first candidate is Diane Wood who is a seventh circuit court of appeals Judge. Judge Wood is also a professor at the University of Chicago Law. She was born in New Jersey and moved with her family to Texas when she was sixteen years old. Her father worked for Exxon and was transferred to Houston Texas. Judge Wood received her B.A. from the University of Texas at Austin. She then attempted to obtain a doctorate at Yale University in Comparative Literature but changed her mind and ended up obtaining her law degree from the University of Texas School of Law. Judge Wood was the editor of the Texas Law Review when she was in college. Upon researching Judge Wood, it was discovered that Judge Wood has never disclosed her religion in print. So currently, her religion preferences are unknown. A Daily Kos article suggests that she is not religious at all but it is unclear as to whether that is accurate or the opinion of the editor to that article. Another article suggests she may be a Protestant. Her religious preferences need to be further explored and maybe some curious reporter will ask her if she believes in something divine and what faith she is.

The second candidate is the current United States Solicitor General, Elena Kagan. Ms Kagan was born in New York and grew up around the Hunter College area in Manhattan. Her father was one of the founders of Kagan and Lubic, a Real Estate Boutique firm in Manhattan. It is rumored that she is the cousin of Arch Neocons Robert and Frederick Kagan. She graduated from Princeton University. She received her masters in Philosophy at Worchester Law in Oxford England and then attended Harvard Law School where she was the supervising editor of the Harvard Law Review. After practicing law for a very short time, she started teaching at the University of Chicago Law School and became the first Dean of Harvard Law School and also taught at Harvard Law School. Ms. Kagan is of the Jewish faith.

Next Page  1  |  2


- Advertisement -

View Ratings | Rate It

I am a graduate of the University of Alabama and University of Alabama Law School. I practice law in Rainsville Alabama. I believe in Justice and equality for all. I believe that government should be for the people and should be free of corruption.

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

Go To Commenting

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
Related Topic(s): , Add Tags
- Advertisement -

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Is Elena Kagan the Best Legal Mind in the United States for the Supreme Court Bench?

Does the Supreme Court Represent the Citizens of America?