Most Popular Choices

 

 

TOP EDITORIALS:
Trump has opened Pandora's Box by bombing Iran's nuclear sites
by Dave Lefcourt
Finding strength in struggle for gender equality and human rights
by Citizen News Service - CNS
Democrats Outraged Over Trump's Unauthorized Bombing of Iran
by Mark Lansvin
The Constitution Won't Save Us From Trump's War Idiocy
by Thomas Knapp
Peaceful Protest, Violent Response: LAPD's Legacy Continues
by Carl Petersen
Day 624 & thuds of explosions
by DR MAZIN QUMSIYEH
World United Against the USA
by John Little
It's been a long, long year, so far
by Bob Gaydos
The Illusion of Pragmatism: Andrew Cuomo, the New York Times, and the Crisis of Centrist Identity Politics
by Michael Roberts
TrumpRepubloFascism is Here: How Long Will It Stay? It depends
by Steven Jonas
Design health services around people, not the disease
by Citizen News Service - CNS
Trump: A richness of embarrassments
by Bob Gaydos
From Charles Manson to the Israeli Attack on Iran
by Steve Schneider
Day 621: Iran explainer and more (read/act)
by DR MAZIN QUIMSIYEH
At This Point, A Nuclear Iran Is Probably The Least Bad Option
by Thomas Knapp
Gavin Newsom's Speech: A Great Political Marker of Our Time
by Robert Weiner
Despite Hillary, Kamala & Haley's Near Misses, and Both Parties' Current Reluctance, a woman could still win the preside
by Robert Weiner
Palestine will free us all
by Rick Staggenborg, MD
Deporting Children to Die Is Not Pro-Life
by Carl Petersen
The Magic Solution to the Conflict in Ukraine
by Pavlo Kuliuk
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is the most dangerous leader in the world
by Dave Lefcourt
Why the U.S. Should Pivot to Diplomacy in Iran
by Mark Lansvin

 

Classics of Liberal Thinking

Progressive Radio Links

FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions

Writing Tips

Skepticism Triggers -- Signs of Poor or Deceptive Arguements

As readers and editors we often need to make judgments about the veracity of an author's assertions on topics where we lack personal knowledge and expertise. Here is my list of signs and signals that herald an argument that is not well grounded in objective fact:

1. Extreme or absolute phrasing. (Words like always and never which allow for no exceptions.)

2. Characterizations. Adjectives that attribute merit or adjectives that demean without factual support. (Outstanding authority John Smith". Discredited activist judge Jim Jones ")

3. Citation of anonymous authority. (A nationally famous physician states ")

4. Absence of contrary information. (Writer withholds or fails to discuss dissenting opinion and conflicting data.)

5. Ad-hominem arguments that appeal to emotion rather than reason.

6. Ad-hominem phrasing that attacks the character of an individual.

7. Innuendo, insinuation an indirect statement that implies something without actually asserting it.

8. Metaphors and similes that grossly oversimplify, usually diverting attention from the inconvenient complexity of reality. (A great way to finesse flawed logic.)

9. Denial. The refusal to even consider well known conflicting information, dismissing it or ignoring it.

10. Sophism. Clever or fallacious argument that leads to a wrong conclusion. Sophism can look like a rational, reasonable argument, but usually ignores some facts and embellishes others to make a case. Connecting some of the dots, omitting others, to show a false pattern. Patternicity that imagines or creates meaning from noise.

11. Misapplied authority Seeking to attribute authority to the opinion of someone whose expertise does not extend to the topic. (Medical opinions of a Disk Jockey)

12. Fear mongering.

13. Hate.

14. Sensational assertions.

15. Too good or too bad to be true.

16. Arguments that assert a conspiracy that would be hard to conceal -- one that would require the silent complicity of a large number of diverse people. (In real life, leaks happen, whistle-blowers surface, etc.)

17. Writing that sounds like a sales pitch. (one sided and persuasively phrased. Infomercial-speak.)

18. You infer a hidden motive or agenda. (Political mud slinging.)

19. Absence of obvious questions that an objective author would raise and answer.

20. Absence of independent sources and externally verifiable fact patterns. No references.

21. Use of a false name or handle to obscure author's identity and avoid accountability.

22. Extrapolation of a peripheral issue to discredit or embellish a core issue. (The sexual behavior of a judge or authority as evidence to question his competence in law.)

23. Anecdotes as evidence of a generalized truth. ("My cousin got the flu after he was vaccinated.")


You will find plenty of examples on Fox News, and regrettably, in much of what is available from internet blogs and similar sources. My list is by no means complete, and I invite you to contribute your own items -- send me a message here on OEN.

-- Richmond Shreve, Senior Editor OEN

 

TOP LIFE NEWS:
Film Review: Gaza: Journalists Under Fire
by John Hawkins
Irish seals
by Gary Lindorff
Sonnet for Trump the Peace Bringer
by John Hawkins
What do we do with brilliant old damaged men?
by Gary Lindorff
Vignettes from Monhegan
by Gary Lindorff
Reasons Galore for Attacking Iran!
by Philip Kraske
The Glitter Is in Everything (fiction)
by John Hawkins
No Mr Eliot, this is how the world ends
by Gary Lindorff
Once and for all -- who are our ancestors? (and what I mean by "wisdom field")
by Gary Lindorff
Pomp and Circumcision (poem)
by John Hawkins
Thomas J. Farrell's Further Reflections on the Tragic Anti-Body Heritage of Christianity (REVEW ESSAY)
by Thomas Farrell
Goodbye ghosts
by Gary Lindorff
An Artistic Alternative to Marching on "No Kings" Day
by Meryl Ann Butler
David Brooks on Trumpism versus Abstractions, and Walter J. Ong's Thought (REVIEW ESSAY)
by Thomas Farrell
Maia Szalavitz on Love as a Drug, and Walter J. Ong's Thought (REVIEW ESSAY)
by Thomas Farrell
Will I Survive Two Weeks in Kiev?
by Philip Kraske
Something you need to see for yourself
by Gary Lindorff
The fate of the Selfie Yacht
by Gary Lindorff
Breaking Free: Reclaiming Your Authentic Self in a High-Speed World
by Dan
Review of Genocide Bad by Sim Kern
by John Hawkins
An Elon Musk Sonnet
by John Hawkins
Advice to Israeli pacifists
by Gary Lindorff

Tell A Friend