My wife Trudy was born in Germany and
came here as a young child. When she was in her late teens, she returned
there for a year to live and work. As she began to reacquaint herself with
family members, she felt bold and comfortable enough to ask them the
difficult questions: How was it that the Holocaust could happen? What had
they known? What had they done?
The answers she received could be summed up as: "We’d heard
rumors about the death camps, but our government told us it was American
propaganda -- and that’s what we believed." Now before we cast
judgment about how bad the "good" Germans were, a little
perspective. In his book Laughter In Hell: The Use of Humor During the
Holocaust, Steve Lipman (who is Jewish) maintains that in the early
days, Hitler was an object of ridicule. Many, if not most Germans didn’t
like him. However, once Hitler came to power -- and showed muscle -- the
average non-Jewish, non-communist, non-homosexual German faced a decision:
Enroll themselves in Hitler’s vision of Deutschland Über Alles -- or
make their lives unpleasant and their deaths untimely.
In "Matrix" language, they could either choose the Red Pill
of painful awareness, or the Blue Pill of blissful ignorance. Those
Germans whose conscience and consciousness offered them no choice but to
choose the Red Pill realized they were very likely choosing a death
sentence. For the Germans who swallowed the Blue Pill, the initial
decision was easier. But as the war dragged on and the illusion shattered,
they too ultimately had to face the awful truth about the devil’s
mission they’d signed on to. While some continued, no doubt, to deny any
wrongdoing until the day that they died, others had to live with the sad
truth that there had been a "tipping point" which gave the Nazis
absolute power -- and that the German people had missed the point.
Fast forward sixty or seventy years from Nazi Germany to Not-See
America, and those of us who haven’t swallowed the pill of
"American Security Through World Domination" are seeing that
tipping point looming on the horizon and coming closer each day. To use a
familiar analogy, when you throw a frog into boiling water (please don’t
try this at home), he will immediately leap out and save himself. But if
you put a frog in room temperature water and bring it to a slow boil, the
frog will never sense the increase in temperature ... until he’s cooked.
As soon as Richard Nixon left office in disgrace nearly thirty years
ago, a small cadre of conservatives made their own twisted vow of
"never again." Beginning with the Reagan Administration (which
friends of mine living in Washington at the time called "the meanest
and most ruthless" they’d ever seen -- up until that point, of
course), on through the Lee Atwater campaign for George the First, through
Gingrich era in Congress, through the stealing of the election in 2000,
and up to the current stonewalling going on, the temperature has been
rising. And folks, we’re nearly cooked.
1 So what is it that will cause us to sit up, take notice, and jump out
of the pot? When will we realize -- a la that 50s song "Stranded In
the Jungle" -- that what we smell cooking is our cherished freedom
and democracy? What will it take for us to say, "Great googamooga
-- lemme outta here!"?
First we must face that it is the "Not-Sees" who enable the
Nazis to come into power. In further conversation, Trudy’s relatives
admitted that they believed what their government was telling them because
it was easier to believe that than to face the huge lie and horrible
truth. A little closer to home, here is an actual response that a real
human being offered recently when confronted with a particularly egregious
perpetration by our current Administration: "Well, it may be true
but I don’t believe it."
Unbelievable? Believe it. Notice how out-of-the-comfort-zone topics get
relegated to the box of "conspiracy theories." Here is my new
working definition of "conspiracy theory": a conspiracy theory
is something that if true, would be too threatening to face. So why even
go there? Well, because we may be "going there" like it or not,
and if we have the awareness we can stop the chain of events before we
find that it is we who are in chains. And maybe it’s time for us to call
those who refuse to connect the very connectable dots "coincidence
theorists."
To put it another way, what if you had a life-threatening condition and
finding out about it now would make it treatable and curable? Would it be
worth the temporary discomfort -- if not outright horror -- in facing
something too threatening to face? There are people, after all, who
"wouldn’t face the truth to save their life." I assert the
body politic -- or at least the design offered to us by the Founding
Fathers -- is in grave danger. What Lincoln called "government of the
people, by the people, for the people" has not yet perished from this
earth. But it is on life support. And its life is in our hands.
So what are we not seeing? And what can we do?
First of all, I think it is wise to not strain the Nazi / Not-See
analogy, but rather to use the parallel for clarity. So here is the point:
Good, decent people can be manipulated by fear and prejudice to bring to
power a force of evil disguised as security and protection. All it takes
is for them to look the other way (i.e., not see) or wish it weren’t so,
for that dark power to entrench itself absolutely. And we all know that in
human affairs, power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Here are a few dots, and you can make your own connections:
1. The 2000 Election. There is irrefutable evidence that tens of
thousands of African-American voters in Florida were purposely
disenfranchised by a plan implemented to weed out "felons." Most
of the people turned away at the polls were not felons, but no matter.
There was no redress, no revote, and the results stood. Tom DeLay
dispatched a gang of intimidators disguised as "citizens" to
disrupt the vote recount in Dade County. The Supreme Court made the final
decision, and the selection results were 5-4, along ideological lines.
2. Sen. Jim Jeffords. In 2001, Sen. Jim Jeffords of Vermont
actually left the Republican Party and switched to Independent so as to
deny the Republicans a majority in the Senate. Why? He was concerned about
the strong-arm tactics being used by the Republican leadership.
3. 9/11. On September 10th, President Bush’s popularity
ratings were ... well, they were unpopularity ratings. Afterward?
He became the Fearless Leader of the "Free" World. Four big
unanswered questions about 9/11 still remain unanswered, and largely
unasked:
1 v Why were the FBI agents on the trail of the actual hijackers in
this country -- in their own words -- "thwarted"? Who did the
thwarting and why?
v Who profited from United and American airlines stocks plummeting in
the wake of 9/11? Who did the selling?
v Why were jets not scrambled immediately after the plane hit the first
tower? Why the delay?
v Why were Osama bin Laden’s relatives whisked out of the country
right after 9/11, and never interrogated by the FBI?
4. The 2002 Election. Let’s start with the elephant -- I mean
the donkey -- in the living room, Sen. Paul Wellstone (D-Minnesota), and
his death in a plane crash. Now imagining that this was "no
accident" is far-fetched, and over a line not many of us would like
to cross. But when a regime is ruthless and secretive, conspiracy theories
proliferate and undermine trust. The fact that many non-paranoid citizens
harbor suspicions about this event, should in itself be considered a cause
for concern.
So I would leave this one entirely up to the coincidence theorists: Two
elections over a two-year period, two Democratic Senators (one of them the
leading liberal voice in the Senate, the other running against John
Ashcroft in Missouri), and two plane crashes. What are the odds? Pete
Rose, can you help us out here? Or, it could very well be that Pat
Robertson is right, and God is indeed siding with the Republicans.
Meanwhile in Georgia, where Diebold touch screen voting machines were
used, there were two electoral upsets that defied the polls done just days
before the voting. Both the Democratic candidate for Governor and the
popular war veteran Sen. Max Cleland were inexplicably defeated. Sen.
Cleland, incidentally, was subject to a mean and merciless character
assassination campaign. Guess that beats real assassination.
5. The War on Iraq. According to recent testimony by Richard
Clarke and others, this war was being planned from the day George W. Bush
set foot in the White House (earlier, actually) and that the
"diplomatic efforts" were a charade while war plans proceeded
unfettered (shades of Hitler). In the wake of 9/11 and based on what is
now known to be "spun" information, Congress was leveraged into
a new War Powers Act, giving President Bush the power to make war on Iraq.
While the majority of Americans would have supported this war only with
the full backing of the United Nations, the war went forward without the
support of the UN, the majority of people in the world, or for that matter
the majority of Americans.
6. The Joseph Wilson, Valerie Plame Case. When Joseph Wilson
blew the whistle on the false report of Saddam getting nuclear weapons
from Niger, someone at the White House leaked the identity of his wife,
Valerie Plame, and blew her cover as an antiterrorist CIA operative,
putting her life in danger and ending her career. This is not only an act
of high treason, but we lost a valuable operative, someone it took years
to establish and perhaps millions of dollars to train. So far ... no one
has been prosecuted, and the White House has not been held accountable.
And on and on and on. We see an Administration that has put itself
above the law in every way imaginable. We have a President who received
less than 50% of the popular vote, who was elected by barely 25% of
eligible voters. He proclaimed himself "a uniter, not a divider"
and a "compassionate conservative," and yet he has consistently
represented only two groups: The huge corporate interests that contributed
to his campaign, and the Religious Right. He has ruled, not as an elected
President but as a dictator who has forced his worldview (or more likely,
his handlers’ worldview) onto all of us.
The Administration’s heavy-handed dictates have squeezed scientists
who don’t buy the fundamentalist Christian ideology out of research
positions, and pushed moderate Republicans and all others who don’t
agree with him out the door as well. Think of Paul O’Neill, Richard
Clarke and other lifelong Republicans who were drummed out of government
service, then subjected to smear campaigns and worse. Think of the OMB
employee who was prohibited from telling Congress the real cost of the
Prescription Drug Bill under threat of losing his job.
And take the press -- please! We have an Administration playing full-on
hardball and a press playing hardly-have-balls, lobbing hittable
grapefruits and failing to field the easiest grounders. Where have you
gone, Edward R. Murrow, our nation turns its lonely eyes to you? Why isn’t
the press doing any pressing? Well, probably because the press is owned by
the same corporate interests who’ve bought the Presidency.
Here is an interesting stat: Even when polls show George Bush trailing
a Democratic opponent, a majority of people nonetheless believe that Bush
will be reelected. What’s that about? It would seem to indicate a
"disheartenment in the heartland," a sinking feeling that a
regime that has consistently used lying and intimidation to thwart the
will of the people and flaunt the rule of law will somehow find a way to
stay in power once again this fall.
But seriously, folks ... we here in Not-See America may be coming very
close to the tipping point where there is no longer any check or balance
against a regime that knows no restraint. Or, we may just as likely be
reaching a turning point where concerned citizens from all shades of the
political spectrum begin speaking out and acting out to return the rule of
law to America, and to reestablish a government that is truthful, just,
and appropriately transparent.
I guess I am basically an idealist with a profound respect for the
vision and courage of our Founding Fathers. They went up against a
worldview that had dominated for centuries, proclaiming each individual a
sovereign citizen, not a subject. The cliché is that every generation
must defend freedom, liberty and our democratic way of life. In the past,
this has looked like stepping onto foreign soil armed with a weapon. In
our time it means standing on our own soil, unarmed except for the
Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.
So, what is to be done? What comes to mind (to the cynical part of my
mind, anyway) is the classic cartoon. It’s a dungeon scene, and two very
old men with long, white beards and in tatters, are strung up in chains.
One is saying to the other, "Now, here’s my plan..." At the
risk of sounding like that cartoon, here is my plan:
1. The Committee of 100. What if one hundred (or more) prominent
Americans from all political stripes declared a state of Emerge ‘n See,
where we emerge from our fear and our Not-See trance, and face the truth
of where our nation has been going, and make the conscious and courageous
choice to change direction? They say the truth shall set you free, but
first it will piss you off. In order to face the truth, we need
leadership. And in this case, one hundred leaders are better than one. One
hundred leaders can speak in one hundred different places at once. And by
sheer numbers, they can encourage other truth-tellers and whistle-blowers
to stand up and speak up.
As for who would be involved, I see Democrats, Republicans, Greens,
Libertarians, Independents -- people like Bill Moyers, Arianna Huffington,
John Dean, Gen. Anthony Zinni, George Soros, Sen. Robert Byrd, and
well-known names from the fields of entertainment and media, the clergy,
science and academia, business and finance, arts and letters, organized
labor. In fact, I would expect to be surprised by who shows up for this.
Imagine the sense of relief for Americans to realize that we need not
fear our own government. Imagine the genuine inspiration for the
democratic impulse around the world. Imagine a nation facing the threat of
terrorism, and the need to create a just world order -- together,
disagreeing agreeably, but focused on finding the wisest and most
functional pathways.
The Declaration of Emerge ‘n See would be supported by two things:
Truth and reconciliation. In other words, the declaration should proclaim
that the truth will inevitably come out, and that the truth emerging for
us to deal with is more important than punishing any particular
perpetrators. Therefore, those who come forward now will experience
leniency, if not outright pardon. This is a controversial notion, but it
points us in the evolutionary direction of foregoing "getting
even" for getting "odd." In seeing our collective
complicity in the way things are, in creating a profound ceremony of both
grief and forgiveness, we pardon not just the perpetrators, but ourselves
-- the tacit participants.
2. The Canary Project. If we are going to ask the truth-tellers
and whistle-blowers to emerge from hiding, we must take steps to protect
them. The Canary Project is initially a website where anyone can see and
hear video affidavits from the "canaries" who have been
silenced, intimidated or worse. I say "canaries" for two
reasons. First, canaries "sing." Secondly, there is the
tradition of releasing canaries into mines to test for toxic gases. If the
canaries die, then miners know not to enter. In our toxic political
climate, if our own canaries cannot be protected -- well, then ... guess
who’s next?
Who knows? Some of these people may need to have their voices disguised
or wear cloth bags on their heads. In order for truth to out, there needs
to be a place for anyone and everyone to hear the evidence, and the truth.
These individuals may in the future testify in a court of law, once
protections are guaranteed. And the best way for protection to be
guaranteed is to have as many Americans as possible to know about these
truth-tellers.
There is the legendary -- and it turns out, apocryphal -- story about
King Christian of Denmark. As the story goes, when the Nazis invaded
Denmark and announced that all Jews must wear a yellow star, the King and
all Danes emerged wearing the star on their shoulders. While this never
actually happened, the story accurately reflected the Danish attitude of
solidarity with its Jewish citizens. Indeed, Danish citizens often sent
care packages to Jews who had been taken to concentration camps, and just
this concern made Danish Jews more protected from brutality. The lesson
is, when we’re all "us" we cannot be separated, isolated, and
picked off.
3. Concerned Clergy. Before the invasion of Iraq, many, many
clergy people in this country expressed concern and opposition to
preemptive warfare. Once the war began -- particularly in the light of Ari
Fleischer’s ominous warning to "watch what you say" -- many of
these concerned ministers, rabbis, priests and other religious people
faded back into the "silenced majority."
Facing the truth requires moral authority, and not the moral authority
of the Religious Right which rails against the "abomination" of
two people of the same sex lying together in love, but looks the other way
when an entire government lies together to perpetrate a
"bomb-a-nation." Instead we need the simple moral authority of
the Golden Rule, a version of which is the keynote of every major
religion. We need right now the spiritual power of many, many people of
conscience representing any and all faiths coming together to pray for the
good of all.
Our national motto is E Pluribus Unum, out of many One. There are many
paths, and One Spirit. In recognizing this, we see from a higher
perspective, and religion becomes a true moral compass, not a tool for
political manipulation. Why not have our spiritual leaders raise the
question: How can we create a society where we are One Nation, Under Good
-- instead of what we have now, one nation, under guard?
4. Mothers for a Healthier Future. Just as the principles of the
Golden Rule (at the heart of every religious path) needs to inform our
community and political life, we need the nurturing impulse of the real
"pro-life" movement: mothers who care about their children’s
future. Yes, we must take America back. And to do so, we must have a
vision that takes America forward.
The current powers that be in power offer us perpetual warfare,
environmental destruction, loss of civil liberties, growing gap between
rich and poor, and rule by the Christian version of fundamentalist
ayatollahs. They are pointing us directly backward, to a past of
feudalism, theocracy and rule by royal decree. Let’s allow the mothers
of our nation and the world -- the bringers of life -- to point us towards
a life-affirming vision where we use our resources lovingly, wisely and
creatively.
The fall of the Nixon presidency turned on one small decision that
could have gone either way. Katherine Graham, still "green" as
publisher of the Washington Post and not part of the old boy network, didn’t
realize she was supposed to kill the Watergate story. She went ahead with
it, and we all know what happened. Right now we have a regime which -- to
paraphrase John Dean, who should know -- makes Mr. Nixon look like Mr.
Rogers. They’ve learned their lessons well from the Vietnam and Nixon
eras, to slam shut every possible door of inquiry, to make sure Americans
don’t see pictures of dead soldiers in flag-draped coffins, or dead
children, forever collaterally-damaged.
Look at us. The world’s biggest and baddest superpower, and we are
afraid of our own shadow. Our delicate psyches need to be protected from
pictures of returning coffins. It’s time to courageously face the heart
of darkness – as our Founding Fathers did, and as we are asking our
soldiers in Iraq to do – and shine the light of truth on all that we
have been unwilling to see.
I propose that we declare this Fourth of July a day of courageous truth
telling and visioning for the future of our republic and the healing of
the world. We might even call it "Man Hog Day" and declare a
State of Emerge ‘n See, where we emerge from fear and denial and see our
shadow. Otherwise, we face a long, dark winter season that truth, justice
and the real American way might not survive.
Steve Bhaerman is a writer and comedian. His alter ego Swami
Beyondananda has a new book out in May, Swami for Precedent: A 7-Step Plan
to Heal the Body Politic and Cure Electile Dysfunction. Steve and Swami
can be found online at