OpEdNews Op Eds

Time to Shake Up the Anti-War Movement

By (about the author)     Permalink       (Page 1 of 2 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

View Ratings | Rate It

opednews.com

In what country will a huge peace coalition hold an anti-war rally have nothing to say about Iran, Israel and Palestine or Afghanistan? Is the answer Israel? Turkey? Micronesia? Sadly it 's the USA. On April 29 United for Peace and Justice is holding a big demonstration in New York City called "March for Peace, Justice and Democracy ". The only "peace " demand mentioned is bringing troops home from Iraq.

The silence about Iran is staggering. On April 9 the Washington Post reported on US military planning for an attack. In includes this sentence, "Pentagon planners are studying how to penetrate eight-foot-deep targets and are contemplating tactical nuclear devices ". Contemplating? We 're not talking about mediation here, but dropping "tactical " Hiroshima-size atomic bombs. And UFPJ has nothing to say.

The conventional wisdom smugly says this is all a bluff, that with all the losses in Iraq and sagging polls at home Bush would be crazy to attack Iran. But Sy Hersh reports [New Yorker April 17, 2006] that a government consultant with ties to the Pentagon told him " that the President believes that he must do 'what no Democrat or Republican, if elected in the future, would have the courage to do, ' and 'that saving Iran is going to be his legacy. ' " Mission is part of Bush 's "reborn " personality. Remember he seriously believes that he was chosen by God to be President.

Who is going to stop him? The non-cooperation of France and Germany of 2003 is a thing of the past. Russia and China? Can anyone believe that these money-sotted regimes would put up any opposition to a US full court press? How about the US Congress? Hersh reports that the White House briefings of the leadership are underway and the only questions that are being raised are "How are you sure you can hit the targets deep enough? " What about the Democrats? Kerry and Obama tried to win the macho crowd by claiming in 2004 that Bush wasn 't taking a hard enough line on Iran. They 're not about to change their spots now. Lieberman? He 's probably signing his name on the nukes themselves.

The peace movement seems paralyzed by the charge that Iran is developing nuclear weapons. Never mind that Scott Ritter, who was dead right about Iraq 's WMD, has said repeatedly in interviews and speeches that Iran has no nuclear weapons program. [See my Jan. 24 video interview http://thestruggle.org/mediap.htm ] or that the IAEA officials have no evidence of such a program. Never mind that the US has thousands of nuclear weapons that could holocaust Iran in minutes. Never mind that Israel has hundreds of nuclear weapons pointed at Tehran.

Oops I mentioned Israel. UFPJ doesn 't want to say anything about it. Condemn "unending oil war " and that 's the beginning and ending of analysis. The Christian Zionists who see a Jewish conquest of Palestine as the start of Aramageddon? They don 't really matter. AIPAC, which draws half the Senate and a third of the House to their blood-curdling conventions. Not really worth mentioning, not even the 2006 gathering which was devoted to demands that the US "take care " of Iran. Bush himself has stated, "We will use military might to protect our ally Israel ", but why get into that?


And those pesky Palestinians. Yes, they have their troubles, but why mention them in an anti-war movement? As if Israeli war-mongering wasn 't based on its aparthied-like oppresson of Palestinians. As if an Israeli official hadn 't publicly said that wiping out Saddam would help Israel impose a new "order " on the Palestinians. As if the al-Qaeda killers haven 't tried to adopt the Palestinian cause as their own. Bringing up Palestine in connection with the war will just alienate us from those thousands and thousands of Israel partisans who are just itching to join the movement once we get rid of our "anti-Semitism ". Uh-huh.

Unstated in the UFPJ rally call is a rush to the Democrats. After grassroots activists pushed the UFPJ and ANSWER coalitions into having one successful giant demonstration on September 24, 2005, UFPJ passed a resolution to never work with ANSWER again! Instead it found new allies with liberal environmental groups, feminists and Jesse Jackson 't PUSH. Jesse Jackson, father confessor to war criminal Clinton, is going to teach us morality. Grand. Dump all the bleeding hearts who sympathize with the Arabs and Muslims and the Dems will pick up votes in the heartland.

Well, in CT this strategy of pandering to the so-called center has been tried and it 's failed.

The Connecticut Experience

We in Connecticut have had a statewide umbrella group, Connecticut United for Peace, that for over three years has run the large statewide demonstrations. We 're members of UFPJ, but years ago we formally decided that the oppression of Palestinians was intimately tied up with the war and have mentioned it in all our rallies.

We started making plans for this year 's March 18 rally last November, and we held two ultra-democratc votes about the demonstration 's demands. Anyone who showed up at the meetings could vote. In November we proposed the slogan "End Israeli Occupation and Apartheid ". We also had slogans for immigrant rights, opposition to persecution of Muslims and rejection of war with Iran.

At our final meeting in January (with 125 in attendance) a number of people demanded a single issue rally, totally on Iraq, saying by going for the lowest common denominator we 'd get labor, the Democrats and anti-war Jews. The majority wouldn 't go for it. We weren 't going to abandon the immigrants and Muslims and we 'd be fools not to mention Iran, but we figured the real sticking point was Palestine. So we offered a compromise. Instead of the slogan "End Israeli Occupation and Apartheid " we offered the vague "Justice for the Palestinian People ".

People voted for the compromise by a large majority. Still the very notion that the Palestinians were the victims was too much for some and others were afraid of offending the Democratic Party and the Democratic Party oriented labor leaders. So the Israel-apologists, the Peace Council and some labor leaders went off and did their own thing. They held a rally on March 19, a day after ours and formed a group with the acronym COW, Connecticut Opposes War.

On March 18 we marched 20 blocks from a largely Latino neighborhood and held and rally on the New Haven Green that according to the AP attracted 1,000. We think it was larger. Perhaps 10% were Muslim and Palestinians. We had pro-immigrant speakers in English and Spanish and a section of the Green with Spanish translators. It was a great demo, but we had expected double that number to attend and we blame it mostly on the split.

So how well did the splitters do on the 19th in Hartford? Politically the rally sucked. It was two blocks from Senator Lieberman 's office and none of the speakers denounced Lieberman. Neither Democrat Ned Lamont who was challenging Lieberman for anti-war reasons nor Ralph Ferrucci who was running as a Green were invited to speak. The only chant was this embarrasing bleat, "We are Americans, This is Our Country ". Imagine after three years of the war they still think we have to defend our patriotism? All the speeches denounced one person and one person only, George Bush. As if the Democrats hadn 't pushed for the war enthusiastically and as if they weren 't still supporting it. Iran was mentioned in one sentence. And, of course, they didn 't say a word about Israel 's constant pressure for war against Iraq and Iran or the fact that Gaza is now without flour.

Next Page  1  |  2

 

www.TheStruggle.org

Stanley Heller is host of "The Struggle" a weekly TV news program seen on public access stations in the northeast and at www.TheStruggle.org. He is chair of the Middle East Crisis Committee.

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Grand Theft Flotilla

Foreign Soldier Shoots American. What will Obama Do?

We Need Movies About Heroes, not "Basterds"-

Create Uncle Sam Motors

International Jewish Statement in Opposition to an Attack on Iran

Report from the Land of Apartheid

Comments

The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
2 people are discussing this page, with 2 comments
To view all comments:
Expand Comments
(Or you can set your preferences to show all comments, always)

Since the massive demonstrations during the run up... by ardee D. on Monday, Apr 17, 2006 at 7:29:47 AM
Peace movement is a tool. Until power uses it it... by Mark Sashine on Monday, Apr 17, 2006 at 9:14:56 AM