Tags for This Article:

McCain-John (3584)  Rights (1343)  Barack Obama (1115)  Women (619)  Hillary Clinton (512)  Presidential Campaign Democratic (432)  Presidential Campaign Republican (284) 

Populum Tag Cloud
       Control Panel
Fine tune your search to access content
Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s): ; ; ; ; ; ;
Add to My Group
February 8, 2008 at 07:50:45

Headlined on 2/8/08:
WHEN ANATOMY TRUMPS COLOR: Race and Gender Patterns and their Possible Effect Upon the 2008 Presidential Race

by Meryl Ann Butler     Page 1 of 2 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 

Tell A Friend

View Ratings | Rate It  

In race and gender patterns in the United States, men of color have traditionally been granted their rights in advance of women. Therefore, as long as this pattern continues, Barack Obama is better positioned than Hillary Clinton to beat John McCain, or any other white male Republican.


Barack Obama


Hillary Clinton


John McCain

Patterns, whether grounded in fact or fiction, are by definition, deeply rooted and cyclical. Consider one odd pattern in American politics often referred to as Tecumsuh’s Curse: for 120 years, every president elected in a year ending in the numeral zero died in office, the majority from assassination. [1]

Patterns of race and gender are mixed inextricably into the mortar of society, right or wrong, and typically only change very gradually.

Free black men in post Revolutionary America could own land, but it was not until the 1850’s that states began passing women’s property rights legislation. [2]

Black men were allowed into the military before women.[3] In 1870, James Webster Smith became the first African-American admitted to the United States Military Academy at West Point.[4] Women were finally admitted, over a century later, in 1976[5].

Black men were granted the right to vote via the fifteenth amendment in 1870[6]. Women did not get the vote until 1920, through the nineteenth amendment[7].

So, it seems likely that these race and gender patterns will affect the timing of the nation’s first black and female presidents.

Anatomy trumps skin color. This is not a judgment by the author, simply an observation of the pattern. (So don’t shoot the piano player! She’s a feminist!)

If Hillary were to receive the Democratic nomination, she would have to overcome this pattern. However, Obama could win, based on the foundations of this pattern.

Obama, who is half black, is obviously also half white, and therefore could become a stepping stone toward racial equality in the White House, if he receives the Democratic nomination.

McCain could use the “gender card” against Hillary, but it is very unlikely that he would ever use the “race card” against Obama, as McCain himself is the adoptive father of a daughter of color, born in Bangladesh in 1991.

In the 2000 primaries, McCain was the target of a racially based smear campaign in South Carolina, falsely attributing his daughter Bridget’s birth to the result of McCain’s supposed liason with a black prostitute. This may have cost him the race in that state. When dadmag.com asked McCain about it, he replied, “There were some pretty vile and hurtful things said during the South Carolina primary. It's a really nasty side of politics. We tried to ignore it and I think we shielded (Bridget) from it. It's just unfortunate that that sort of thing still exists. As you know she's Bengali, and very dark-skinned. A lot of phone calls were made by people who said we should be very ashamed about her, about the color of her skin. Thousands and thousands of calls from people to voters saying, ‘You know, the McCains have a black baby.’ I believe that there is a special place in hell for people like those.”

Ironically, if the final race is between Obama and McCain, whatever the outcome, a person of color will be living in the White House. It’s about time.

 1  |  2

 

www.merylannbutler.com

Meryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she appear too uppity, it should be revealed that she also has family ties to James Butler Hickok, better known as Wild Bill. Butler has been actively engaged in utilizing the arts as stepping-stones toward joy-filled enlightenment for the past two decades. A native of NYC, her response to 9-11 was to pen an invitation to healing through creativity, entitled, "90-Minute Quilts: 15+ Projects You Can Stitch in an Afternoon" (Krause 2006). They don't call quilts "comforters" for nothing! www.90minutequilts.com Butler was faculty advisor for "The Love for All Mankind/Anti-Apartheid Quilt" project at ENMU (1993), now in the collection of the Hon. Nelson Mandela. As Arts Advisor for the Center for Improving U.S.- Soviet Relations (CIUSSR) Baltimore, MD; her activities included the "First U.S.-Soviet Childrens' Peace Quilt Exchange" (1987-88), an historic project chronicled in the media of both countries. Citizen diplomacy trips to the U.S.S.R. in 1987 and 1988 included lectures and presentations to fashion designers, craftspeople and artists in Odessa, Moscow, Kiev and St.Petersburg, in which she focused on the topic of creating global peace through international art exchanges. Butler is the proud mother of a daughter and seven stepchildren (all grown), and a passel o' grand younguns. It is to these new generations that she dedicates her political activism. Archived articles www.opednews.com/author/author1820.html Older archived articles, from before May 2005 are here.,

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
11 comments

Meryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Meryl Ann ButlerMeryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

FROM THE AUTHOR

OOPS!

 

I had a paragraph in my article that somehow disappeared when I posted this! YIKES!

…so here it is:

 

Shirley Chisolm, the first black woman to serve in the United States Congress, also ran for president in 1972. She said, “I've always met more discrimination being a woman, than being black.”

 

 

Footnote:

 

http://womenshistory.about.com/od/quotes/a/shirleychisholm.htm

Shirley Chisholm was the first black woman to serve in the United States Congress. An early education expert, Shirley Chisholm was elected to the New York Legislature in 1964 and to Congress in 1968. She ran for president in 1972, winning 152 delegates before she withdrew. Shirley Chisholm served in Congress until 1983. During her congressional career, Shirley Chisholm was noted for her support for women's rights, her advocacy of legsislation to benefit those in poverty, and her opposition to the Vietnam war.

by Meryl Ann Butler (43 articles, 42 quicklinks, 3 diaries, 344 comments) on Friday, February 8, 2008 at 10:57:38 AM
 


Meryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Meryl Ann ButlerMeryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

reply to editing

Dear Amy,

 

thank you, yes i knew that i could revise it, but i was worried about how adding this with the footnote would work ... that seemed like it could be problematic - in other words, would the little box where i make the changes know how to change the numbers of all the other footnotes? or would that just mess it all up? I guess i could wipe out the entire article, and just repost the whole new version...that might be the way to go ...  thanks! 

by Meryl Ann Butler (43 articles, 42 quicklinks, 3 diaries, 344 comments) on Friday, February 8, 2008 at 11:19:33 PM
 


Amara Rose is a "midwife" for our global rebirth. She is the author of the eBook trilogy, What Shines: Practical Wisdom for Unleashing Your Inner Brilliance, and a contributor to many health, business and new thought publications. You can subscribe to Amara's inspirational monthly newsletter, What Shines, through LiveYourLight.com.
Amara RoseAmara Rose is a "midwife" for our global rebirth. She is the author of the eBook trilogy, What Shines: Practical Wisdom for Unleashing Your Inner Brilliance, and a contributor to many health, business and new thought publications. You can subscribe to Amara's inspirational monthly newsletter, What Shines, through LiveYourLight.com.

Presidential Paradigm Shift

I was also musing earlier this week about how interesting it is that for the first time ever, the D-choice is between two "minorities", either of whom will be up against "tradition" in the form of a SWM. And as you write, it's about time! I feel this evolving presidential pattern signifies the global paradigm shift that's well underway. Thanks for eloquently expressing (with such solid supporting research) what I ~ and no doubt many others ~ have been pondering...

by Amara Rose (2 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 3 comments) on Friday, February 8, 2008 at 12:14:01 PM
 


Student of social dynamics, especially as it relates to issues of race and sex.
HargroveStudent of social dynamics, especially as it relates to issues of race and sex.

When it Comes to Trouble - Anatomy Doesn't Trump Color

When you can show me a dead white woman, hanging from a tree, for exercising her "right" to vote, then I'll buy that anatomy trumps race argument.

The reason Barack Obama is doing so much better than Hillary Clinton is because he is so much better than Hillary Clinton. His campaign reflects it. He built it himself, without money or a network of rich and connected friends. He did it over a few years, and he's using it to compete with Hillary's organization, that was built by her husband, over more than two decades, used for two senate victories, 4 governor victories, and 2 president victories, connected to money and power. That's never been done before, not by anyone!

Hillary's response to Barack's challenge has been to try to become him. She's borrowed his "change" slogan. She attempted his admonition about change not being easy. She's used his reminder that former presidents haven't asked the people to do anything difficult when people have to work hard for change. And when she spoke to an audience in Tacoma Washington, she even invoked his chant, declaring to her audience, "Yes we can!"

Hillary's trying to become Barack because she knows that if she can fade the distinction, she can reduce the issue to, do you want this product in, white female or black male. She wants the competition reduced to race or sex because, unlike the writer of "When Anatomy Trumps Color," she knows that if that's the choice, white female wins.

The reason there's no history of white women hanging from trees is because they're the daughters, wives and sisters of the people who do the hanging. And contrary to the idea that more allowances are made for race, all you have to do to is look at this campaign and how we're passively allowing Hillary to use her husband's resume to establish her "experience." Remember, the only formal assignment Hillary had in the White House was to reform health care, and she failed miserably. Meanwhile, every challenge put before Barack Obama has yielded success!

Shirley Chisolm must have spent so much time as a woman among men that she forgot what it is like to be a black person among white people in America.

by Hargrove (11 articles, 3 quicklinks, 1 diaries, 19 comments) on Friday, February 8, 2008 at 10:47:33 PM
 


retired and loving it
dave stanleyretired and loving it

Anything

Except the correct choice,We have Black Americans voting for Obama,We have Woman voting for Clinton,Mormons voting for Romney,Warmongers voting for Mccain. America is a myth it no longer exists,it is reduced to a loose collection of interest groups,lobby groups,Carpet baggers and scaliwags.Americans do not really care what happens as long as they  get jobs and are fed .christians will even vote for Bush and Mccain,there is no convictions .Save for a pocket of people that are educated, the vast majority of America do not give a hoot .50% do not even bother to vote. elections are gab fests a reason to talk about something, not about deciding who is the right person for America,most delgates can be bought out. The result of which has brought the  richest Nation in to banruptcy.

Ring around the rosie

The dumbo chases the ass

Shh Shhh SSsh

we all fall down

by dave stanley (5 articles, 1 quicklinks, 7 diaries, 286 comments) on Saturday, February 9, 2008 at 4:38:41 AM
 


Rob Kall is executive editor and publisher of OpEdNews.com, President of Futurehealth, Inc, inventor . He is also published regularly on the Huffingtonpost.com. He is a frequent Speaker on Politics, Impeachment, The art, science and power of story, heroes and the hero's journey, Positive Psychology, Stress, Biofeedback and a wide range of subjects. He is a campaign consultant specializing in tapping the power of stories for issue positioning, stump speeches and debates. He recently retired as o...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Rob KallRob Kall is executive editor and publisher of OpEdNews.com, President of Futurehealth, Inc, inventor . He is also published regularly on the Huffingtonpost.com. He is a frequent Speaker on Politics, Impeachment, The art, science and power of story, heroes and the hero's journey, Positive Psychology, Stress, Biofeedback and a wide range of subjects. He is a campaign consultant specializing in tapping the power of stories for issue positioning, stump speeches and debates. He recently retired as o...

to see more of bio, click on member name

War against women

Leonard Shlain wrote a fascinating book, THE ALPHABET and the GODDESS, which described how the advent of writing changed the way the brain processed information. Cultures went from storytelling and oral transmission of cultural history to the more linear writing. This changed the way the brain worked and culture changed from a female, priestess and empress, earth mother worship culture to a male dominated one.

Today, right wing values include rejection of the feminine-- not just women, but the whole spectrum of feminine archetypal ways of seeing, living, thinking.  Bush and his machismo offer undereducated men who have lost their jobs through globalization and outsourcing a dose of viagra to make them feel more masculine.

Hillary is a huge threat to their sense of self, sense of power. There's nothing rational about it.

Until the left faces this reality-- that part of winning with progressive, liberal values includes changing men's and religion's reactions to the feminine-- the left's strategy for success will be unsuccessful. That's a challenging assignment. Just look at how so many religious organzations are built upon "values" that  reject equal rights and treatment for women.  Southern Baptists, the Catholic Church, Islam, Orthodox Judaism-- they all require different and not equal treatment for women. Most, if not all of them, argue that women are better off that way, with more power in the home, protection from men, etc. 

This is not an easy battle. I do think "battle" is the right word, because the churches, temples and mosques that  oppose equal rights for women, that oppose the ascendance of the feminine, consider efforts to give women equal rights, to give women the right to control their bodies an assault upon the faith, upon the church. 

When we look at the progress women have made-- that it took just 50 more years to give women the vote, then we can be hopeful, that such change has overcome the millenia old cultural inertia that has resisted the changes sought.

This comment ought to get me in trouble. Sadly, the battle for women's rights may actually be stoking Islamic terrorism. I believe that the main inspiration and motivation for Islamic terrorism is the assault of western culture and values upon Muslim culture. When Christian missionaries attempt to evangelize and convert Muslims, it is understandable that religious leaders and practitioners see t his as an attack on their culture and values.

The fact is, Christianity has an ugly history of demonizing non-christian cultures as heathen, as despicable, and of going in and destroying those cultures, often assisted by devastating diseases carried by the missionaries and soldiers. Many cultures, even whole civilizations have fallen in the face of Christian evangelical assaults.

Unlike the indigenous tribes and south american cultures, which fell to the missionary armies, the Muslim world has fought back against both the Christian evangelism and the secular media assault. Combine the two western forces of cultural change and you have something that may seem quite malevolent to major portions of the Muslim world. When Bush says they hate our freedoms and our democracy, there IS some truth to it, but it is also our Christian evangelism, our hypersexualized television and movies and our cultural values which involve very different rights and roles for women. 

The road to equal rights and equal opportunity for women has not been easy and will continue to be a challenging one.

 

by Rob Kall (808 articles, 3921 quicklinks, 332 diaries, 1702 comments) on Saturday, February 9, 2008 at 6:34:06 AM
 


Steven Leser specializes in Politics, Science & Health, and Entertainment topics. He has held positions within the Democratic Party including District Chair and Public Relations Chair within county organizations.

Steven Leser writes for www.opednews.com, an internet only media site that has grown to become one of the highest traffic news sites in America, reaching more traffic, according to alexa.com, than all but the thirty largest daily newspapers in the US. Mr. Leser is one of t...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Steven LeserSteven Leser specializes in Politics, Science & Health, and Entertainment topics. He has held positions within the Democratic Party including District Chair and Public Relations Chair within county organizations.

Steven Leser writes for www.opednews.com, an internet only media site that has grown to become one of the highest traffic news sites in America, reaching more traffic, according to alexa.com, than all but the thirty largest daily newspapers in the US. Mr. Leser is one of t...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Forgive me Meryl Ann, but you are wrong, AND I am sick of

Hillary folks making this argument. Actually, even though I am in the Obama camp, I am getting sick of the back and forth and bickering between the Hillary and Obama folks in general, but this attempt by Hillary advocates to paint herself as somehow more of a victim than Obama and therefore more deserving of some sort of sympathy is really wearing thin.

For those of you who dont know, the most childish and visceral arguing and bickering IMAGINABLE is going on between advocates of the two campaigns. If you want a taste of this ideological sewer fight, just look here ---> http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_topics&forum=132

Obama people are being called cultists and mysoginists, HIllary people are being called racists, etc. Some of the attacks have a shred of truth, more dont.

This argument by Hillary supporters though is really intellectually dishonest. I dont know you Meryl Ann and perhaps you are just repeating stuff that has been all over the web recently, but let me set you and any other Hillary folks reading this straight.

Hillary's issues, including her negative/unfavorable rating in the high 40 percents, do not come because of her gender. They exist because she and the Clintons have a 16 year record to which one can point and either stress the good points or the bad. The GOP have done a good job of stressing the bad points. I think that is pretty unfair, but it is not a gender bias issue. If you were to assert that it is, you would have to explain away the several dozen other national level women political figures on both sides of the aisle who do not have unfavorable/negative ratings as high as she does.

by Steven Leser (212 articles, 45 quicklinks, 33 diaries, 1389 comments) on Saturday, February 9, 2008 at 2:05:22 PM
 


Meryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Meryl Ann ButlerMeryl Ann Butler is an artist, author and educator who counts First Lady Dolley Payne Todd Madison as well as two signers of the Articles of Confederation among her ancestors. Mary Ball, mother of George Washington is in the ancestral lineage of Butler's great grandmother, Blanche Ball. Grateful to know that the blood of America's founding mothers and fathers runs in her veins, Butler has been newly filled with matriotism as a direct result of the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. Lest she a...

to see more of bio, click on member name

RESPONSE

Dear Steve Leser,

 

Hmmm, I am unclear about what you are calling “wrong.” I believe my dates are backed up with footnotes appropriately, and that my characterizations of the historical patterns are correct, as well.

I am aware of the “childish bickering” going on, and, for the most part, prefer to stay out of it. However, I am answering you because you have made a couple of directly attacking statements. But I can’t help mentioning, that your words seem so angry, that it is hard for me to determine which side you are on, other than just the side of being angry at everything.

I am neither an Obama nor Clinton supporter nor advocate. It is possible that might change in the future, but this is where I am right now.

I am not repeating “things I have heard over the web recently.”  I am a student of patterns, and I am simply observing how these patterns interconnect, archetypically, through time and space, with possible effects on the current presidential race. I believe that the more conscious we become of our patterns, the more empowered we are to change them, if desired.

I do believe that if the Democrats want to win, then they are better off choosing a candidate who is empowered by the current patterns than one who is outside of that stream. From the perspective of these patterns, if the Dems nominate Hillary, they will more likely lose, and if they nominate Obama, they have a much better chance to win.  So I guess, you could say that I might lean a bit more toward Obama, as I would prefer to have a Dem in the White House than a GOP. So your rant about “you and any other Hillary folks” is beyond me, honestly. Did you actually read the article?

Do I want a woman president? Hell, yeah! I personally think the world would be much better off with more women leaders. For one thing, women, as a rule, are less likely to send their children so quickly off to wars. The American Indians knew this, that’s why the Iroquois Confederacy had the Grandmothers Council as an integral part of their government. They couldn’t go to war without the approval of the wise women. That’s the one detail this country failed to adopt, when we copied their government, which had been successful for hundreds of years, as I recall. And, in my opinion, that might be a fatal omission.

The only female contender in the 2008 Presidential race that I feel I could get excited about is Green Party Presidential Candidate Cynthia McKinney. From what I have heard so far, I feel that I owe her a closer look.

So, if modern political tendencies follow the patterns I mention in my article, a black man will inhabit the White House before a female president will, and that may have little to do with individual fitness for the job, ethics, or anything else, other than the pattern.

I might accept an apology, if you have the balls to offer one.

by Meryl Ann Butler (43 articles, 42 quicklinks, 3 diaries, 344 comments) on Saturday, February 9, 2008 at 3:01:03 PM
 

 

11 comments

 

Tell A Friend

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2008

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

BARACK OBAMA On Gandhi's Birthday by Stephen Fox

The dangerous McCain/Palin character assassination of Obama by Sherman Yellen

PECK, PECK... SQUAWK! by Rip Rense

Sarah Palin; Secessionist-- powerful new Youtube Video by youtube

Obama Must Appoint a Consumer Protectionist as FDA Commissioner by Stephen Fox

Race in the 2008 Election by Sally Liuzzo-Prado

Naomi Wolf Must Watch Video: A Coup Took Place on October 1, 2008 by youtube

Sarah Palin Broke The Ethics Law In Alaska, And Can Be Impeached by Rev. Bill McGinnis

A Solution? by Paul Craig Roberts

Northern Exposure: Sarah Palin's Toxic Paradise Posted by Rady Ananda

Go To Top 50 Most Popular