Tags for This Article:

Immigration (585)  Globalization-WTO-WB-etc (257) 

Populum Tag Cloud
       Control Panel
Fine tune your search to access content
Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s): ;
Add to My Group
April 1, 2006 at 22:00:00

The taboo subject at the heart of the immigration debate

by David Sirota     Page 1 of 1 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 
Tell A Friend

(0.0 from 0 ratings) View Ratings | Rate It

Amid all the buzzword phrases like "border security," "guest workers," and "amnesty" being thrown around in the superheated immigration debate, one buzzword phrase has barely been mentioned: "free trade." It's not that border security and guest worker status discussions aren't important. But, as I discuss more fully in my upcoming book Hostile Takeover, America's free trade policies get almost no attention, no matter how central their role is in the major challenges facing our country. How, you ask, does "free trade" fit into immigration? It's pretty simple: had America actually had a trade policy that lifted up the economic conditions for ordinary workers both at home and in other countries, there would likely be far less demand by desperate workers for illegal entry into our country.

Thankfully, at least one major media outlet, Time Magazine, has now addressed (albeit briefly) the free trade policies at the center of the immigration issue. In its coverage today, the magazine explains exactly how free trade and immigration are connected:

"When Bush, Fox and Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper meet today in Cancún to discuss the continent’s dysfunctional immigration situation, they might consider that one solution lies not so much in guest-worker programs or a 2,000-mile-long border fence, but in trade—namely, a revision of NAFTA, the North American Free Trade Agreement. Perhaps they should ask why NAFTA—which took effect 12 years ago amid promises to raise the fortunes of Mexico’s beleaguered workers—hasn’t done more to reduce desperate labor migration over the U.S. border. That illegal flow, about a million migrants a year, is as heavy as ever...Free trade has also failed to generate enough U.S. and other foreign investment in new industries and small- and medium-size businesses—and, as a result, hasn't created enough new Mexican jobs. Even when new jobs do appear, the nation’s unforgiving low-wage business culture—the dark shame of Mexico's political and economic leaders, which NAFTA was also supposed to reform—makes sure that they still often pay in a day what similar work would pay in an hour in the U.S. Add the recent deluge of dirt-cheap Chinese imports into North America that are taking business previously provided by Mexico, and the urgency for Mexican workers to head north only heightens."

Think of it like the concept behind the Academy Award-winning movie Traffic. The movie makes the compelling point that the way to really address the drug issue is to address not just supply through interdiction of drugs in Latin America, but consumer demand for the drugs themselves. You tamp down demand, and you go a long way towards addressing the issue.

But with immigration and trade, we've done exactly the opposite - our trade policy has actually ratcheted up the desire of millions of Mexican workers to come to our country. Ten years after NAFTA, the Washington Post reports that 19 million more Mexicans are living in poverty. Similarly, former Labor Secretary Robert Reich notes in today's New York Times that "Mexico's real wages are lower than they were before [NAFTA]" and economic inequality has grown.

That means millions more Mexicans potentially have an even more intense desire to head to America to better their economic situation. Had our trade policy actually included real labor, human rights, wage and other economic development provisions, maybe 19 million fewer Mexicans might be living in poverty. That would likely mean less desire by millions of Mexicans to head north of the border because things were actually developing well in their home country. And, of course, this says nothing of our government's unwillingness to seriously crack down on big employers here at home who exploit illegal immigrant labor, and thus further fuel the incentive/demand for illegal immigration in general.

Now remember - it should be obvious why so few politicians want to actually talk about trade as it relates to the immigration debate - even though it is at the center of the controversy. Congress is a place filled with people whose campaigns are financed by Corporate America, which loves the immigration debate pitting nations' working classes against each other, and loves the free trade policies that have driven down wages, human rights and environmental protections all over the globe. For these politicians, it is far easier to bash Mexicans, or propose building walls, or criticize border security than to actually confront the Big Business-bought trade policies that have helped create the situation we are now in.

But it is becoming increasingly difficult for the political Establishment to ignore trade, while focusing on immigration. We are going to have to start asking questions like the one Reich asked in his piece today: how can richer nations be convinced to reform their trade policies so that they actually help workers, both at home and abroad?

The answer points to the silver lining in the current furor over immigration: namely, that Americans' concerns over mass illegal immigration provides an opportunity to educate the public about the very tangible, real benefits of bettering conditions in the developing world. Demand that our bought-off politicians start reforming our trade policies to actually help ordinary workers - as opposed to only executives at multinational corporations - and our country will start moving to address global poverty and thus illegal immigration. And there's also an additional benefit: such a reformed trade policy that helps raise wage/workplace/environmental standards in the developing world will also start preventing American workers from having to compete in an economic race to the bottom with the most oppressed workers on Earth.

Making the reform of our trade policy be an integral part of any reform of our immigration policy is the only way ordinary citizens on both sides of our borders will win. This is exactly what the Big Money interests don't want to happen - but it is exactly what must happen if we are to find real solutions to these very pressing problems.

 


David Sirota is a full-time political journalist, best-selling author and
nationally syndicated newspaper columnist living in Denver, Colorado. He blogs for Working Assets and the Denver Post's PoliticsWest website. He is a Senior Editor at In These Times magazine, which in 2006 received the Utne Independent Press Award for political coverage. His 2006 book, Hostile Takeover, was a New York Times bestseller, and is now out in paperback. He has been a guest on, among others, CNN, MSNBC, CNBC and NPR. His writing, which draws on his extensive experience as a progressive political strategist, has appeared in, among others, the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, the San Francisco Chronicle, the Baltimore Sun, the Nation magazine, the Washington Monthly and the American Prospect. Sirota was a twice-a-week guest on the Al Franken Show. He currently serves in a volunteer capacity as the co-chairperson of the Progressive States Network - a 501c3 nonpartisan organization.

In the years before becoming a full-time writer, Sirota worked as the press secretary for Vermont Independent Congressman Bernard Sanders, the chief spokesman for Democrats on the U.S. House Appropriations Committee, the Director of Strategic Communications for the Center for American Progress, a campaign consultant for Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer and a media strategist for Connecticut Senate candidate Ned Lamont. He also previously contributed writing to the website of the California Democratic Party. For more on Sirota, see these profiles of him in Newsweek or the Rocky Mountain News. Feel free to email him at lists [at] davidsirota.com Note: this online publication represents Sirota's personal views, and not the official views of the organizations he works with.


Contact Author
Contact Editor
View Other Articles by Author

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
1 comments

Robert Chapman is greatly interested in developing political awareness among as many people as possible.
Robert ChapmanRobert Chapman is greatly interested in developing political awareness among as many people as possible.

Massive Human Rights Abuse

My reasons for believing in and supporting human rights stem from what I saw growing up in El Paso, Texas, less than two miles from the border with Mexico and Mexico's second largest city, Cuidad Juarez. Like most border cities, Juarez was filled with very poor people who had left the countryside looking for a better life. They were prey to every kind of abuse, from harrassment to false imprisonment to beatings to rape to politically-motivated murder by authorities and others on both sides of the border with more power and influence than they had.

The above quotation comes from a web-site known as the Human Rights Web.

It is highly likely that the author is describing accurately the current and pervasive situation for the poor Mexicans.

In the persons of the undocumented Mexican and Central American workers, we are living with a massive human rights violation right here among us.

Violations of these people's human rights are endemic on both sides of the border. It seems to me that we might see this migration in the search of a better life partly of the historical legacy of colonialism and partly as our failure to extend the benefits of democratic institutions in our society.

Who is in greater need of the benefits of self-determination, political freedom and equal protection of law than people like the undocumented workers whose rights have been systematically violated their entire lives?

Given the massive scope of human misery and deprivation in Mexico, and its immediate effect on conditions in the US, it would seem to me that Mexico and hemispheric relations would be our first priority.

It seems to me that extending the benefits of democracy: voting rights, equal justice under the law, protection of the home and family, education, and guaranteed political rights should become our national mission.

Our entire hemisphere is aching for our dedication to honestly and fairly fulfilling our promises of democracy and freedom.

America's democratization of Iraq will always be seen as a mere charade as long as as we hold our detached attitudes concerning Mexico's festering social problems.

Robert Chapman
Lansing, New York

by Robert Chapman (28 articles, 0 quicklinks, 2 diaries, 557 comments) on Monday, April 3, 2006 at 5:11:54 AM
 

 

1 comments

 

Tell A Friend

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2008

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

"Welcome, Rich White Oligarchs!" --Daily Show Billboard Greets Republicans In Minnesota Posted by Rob Kall

Why I Won't Vote for John McCain by Phillip Butler

Carville is a Spy for Bush Posted by Josh Mitteldorf

Virgo New Moon, August 30, 2008 by C.L. Pagano

Got a Traffic Ticket in the Mail for a Right on Red at an Automated Enforcement Light? by Tumerica

Howard Zinn's Advice to Obama by Rob Kall

McCrash: McCain's Military Record Revisited by Hill Kemp

The Rise and Fall of the US Dollar as the The World Reserve by John Little

"Now, This!" by Stephen Pizzo

Torture As Official Israeli Policy by Stephen Lendman

Popularity Navigation
Control Panel:

Select Time
6 hrs 12 hrs
1 Day 2 Days
3 Days 1 Week
2 Weeks 1 Month
2 Months 3 Months
6 Months Last Year
Select Content
Articles Diaries
Polls Events
All Op-Eds
News Life/Arts/Science
Select Popularity
Page Views
# of Comments
Recommend Emails
  

Go To Top 50 Most Popular