Home
Refresh   Tag(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (more...) ; ; ;  (less...)
Add to My Group
May 24, 2006 at 02:09:17

View Ratings | Rate It

Bushian apologetics

submit to twitter
submit to reddit
submit to digg

Tell A Friend

By Mark Anderson (about the author)     Page 1 of 1 page(s)

opednews.com     Permalink

For OpEdNews: Mark Anderson - Writer

In Stanley Brubaker's exculpation[1] of the NSA's warrantless eavesdropping in theWeekly Standard , one can see the mental somersaults neo-conservatives will go through to defend lawlessness. Brubaker's commentary is significant, because it is the quintessential neo-conservative interpretation of the Fourth Amendment. If it wasn't the Constitution being menaced, the argument would be amusing.

His first ad nauseam excuse for warrantless searches is that contra legem searches aren't unprecedented. I should like to make clear that neither is rape unprecedented - does this make it okay? Pursuant to Brubaker's logic, everything the government does is ipso facto Constitutional.

Brubaker's next error is letting grammatical law obfuscate his vision of Constitutional law. By the way, statutory law has totally separate paragraphs in outline form, with each paragraph being equally-important and relating to the same main point. I wonder if Brubaker would dare use his analysis to nullify whole paragraphs of the PATRIOT Act.


The Fourth Amendment:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

That we are dealing with two independent clauses is something I do not dispute. But, what Brubaker says is that an "originalist" interpretation would be "first clause dominant." Translated: he sees only the proscription on "unreasonable searches." Ignoring the second clause, he then concocts his own Fourth Amendment with the help of that great Yale scholar, Akhil Amar. John Jay, eat your heart out.

Brubaker writes, "The first clause states the general rule: All searches must be 'reasonable.'"

Maybe I have bad eyes, but I'm not seeing anything about a warrantless search being okay, as long as it is "reasonable." It seems self-evident to me that the second clause explains what makes a search reasonable. Otherwise, pray tell me, what, objectively, makes a search reasonable or unreasonable? Although Brubaker doesn't explicitly answer this, I can only infer the arbitrary discretion of government agents.

According to Brubaker, "The second clause provides an important specification of the first: If a warrant does issue, it is per se unreasonable unless supported by probable cause, etc."

Every time I see Brubaker's hermeneutics my surprise quotient drops a few points. If he is saying a search is only unreasonable with a warrant, but without probable cause, then why get a warrant? Otherwise, since he says that a "reasonable" search needs no warrant, the only room left for a warrant would be for an unreasonable search.

[1] -

 

www.NoAnthraxVaccine.net

Mark served for four years on active duty in the Marine Corps infantry, and was a candidate for a municipal office in 2002. Mark has helped raise awareness of military and veterans' issues, by establishing more...)
 

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author
and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles

 

Book Recommendations for "Australia Constitution The Issues"
A New Constitution for Australia (Australian)
by Harris

$64.95
Lowest New Price $55.17

Number of pages: 350
Publisher: Routledge Cavendish

The Victory: The inside Story of the Takeover of Australia
by Pamela Williams

$35.27

Number of pages: 240
Publisher: Allen

Politics of the High Court: Study of the Judicial Branch of Government in Australia
by Brian Galligan

$29.95

Number of pages: 333
Publisher: University of Queensland Pr (Australia)

View All Book Recommendations

Share this page: (what's this?)                   Tell a Friend: Tell A Friend

FACEBOOK      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      NETSCAPE      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
No comments

 
Want to post your own comment on this Article? Post Comment


 

 

 

Tell a Friend: Tell A Friend

Copyright © 2002-2009, OpEdNews

Powered by Populum