Back   OpEdNews
Font
PageWidth
Original Content at
https://www.opednews.com/articles/genera_edwin_ru_080411_progressive_values_s.htm
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).

April 11, 2008

Progressive Values Stories: More Creative Progressive Metaphors

By Edwin Rutsch

I didn't get many responses to my last post about creating a metaphor for progressive and conservative values. Come on progressives, be more imaginative. Let's make creativity a progressive value. I quite enjoy hearing and seeing the metaphors. When I individually sit down and ask progressives for a metaphor, after a little prodding,  they always come up with great metaphors.  Here are some more.

::::::::

"The greatest thing in style is to have a command of metaphor."  Aristotle

I didn't get many responses to my last post about creating a metaphor for progressive and conservative values.  Come on progressives, be more imaginative. Let's make creativity a progressive value.   I quite enjoy hearing and seeing the metaphors.   When I individually sit down and ask progressives for a metaphor, after a little prodding,  they always come up with great metaphors.  Here are some more.

Progressive Values are like:


Herman Blackmon -  Evolution

If I were able to construct a metaphor, it would not be a static one, it would be something that  would be changing and enduring and not seasonal, like human evolution, it's evolutionary in it's essence.

It's a trek towards..., by definition,  it's movement towards something in the future. Hopefully if you move and evolve, you get smarter and get wiser, more humane, and you become more civilized.  You hopefully hone the capacity to love  and interact and that kind of thing.

So, it would have to be evolution. Evolution is progressive.

Diane Strack -  Mother Earth


You can equate progressive values with Mother Earth in a way.  That comes to my mind, because the earth as it should be if it’s not eroded by wind or rain or something, is fertile and allows all things to grow, however, that are capable of growing.  And to me that’s what liberal values are.  It encourages people to be what they are capable of being.  You know, be your best self. 

Barbara A Levin -  the Delicate Oak Tree

Well, I know I’m delicate like an oak tree.  Well, an oak tree knows it’s principles and stands up straight.  Unlike the present Congress.  So, you know what your values are and you stand up for them.  Some people on the right do that too, but I have a problem with their values.  That’s the metaphor.

And the tree has deep roots.  Goes into the ground.  There’s your grassroots.  How’s that?  You like that?  Made it up on the spot.

William Francisco Grisolia -  Sailing Ships

Conservative values on one hand would like to see the status quo, they’d like more of the same.  They believe the ship is sailing and with minor course corrections we can sail on to progress in society.

Progressives on the other hand think the ship either is sinking or needs to turn around, or you need more ships, etc.  That’s the contrast with that simple analogy.

Richard J Wagner - Open Land
 
A metaphor for progressive values.  The term progress itself means improvement – continuously.  Not just the U.S., but everyone in the world.  We have a potential that is not even being beginning to be tapped because of repression and strife in the world.  People are expending energies in the wrong directions. 

A metaphor for progress would be working together to achieve prosperity, freedom and enlightenment and success for everyone.

Edwin:  If progressive values was a piece of land, what kind of land would it be?

Answer:  Open land, a land in which everyone was free to share resources in a fair and equitable way.  A land continuously improving, that wasn’t wasted away or overused.  A land regulated in a way where everyone could be ensured it would get better and better in the future.  Things would grow – instead of barren and dusty soil you’d have shade and streams and productivity.  That’s what progress means – improvement.

Ahjamu Makalani - Scale of Justice

I’m much more grounded in the reality in which I live.  When Eugene Debs went throughout the country in the late 1800 and early 1900’s, he made it clear that a chicken in every pot, a man is in prison, I feel you.  That’s what I’m talking about.  Having a connection in terms of social realities, and how we can improve upon our realities.

But I’m not very much in coming up in some kind of metaphors on what progressive values are.  I would say a metaphor for justice would be, what was it Plato said.  I remember about the scale with the woman who is blind, but given our reality I’d rather for the woman to take the blinds off and see the reality for what is, because sometime when you’re blind, you don’t have justice.  In fact, you have a great deal of injustice.  I’m not quite sure that’s an appropriate metaphor either.  That’s why I’m sort of stymied with that one.

Carol Hanelberg - a Flower

I’m very found of flowers, so that really struck me when you went down your list.  There’s a particular flower that I really like, it’s very pretty to look at.  I don’t know the name of it, but it’s purple, and the bush has narrow, pointed leaves.  So that’s what comes to mind.  I think of it as being perfect to look at, attractive, inviting,

Jason Theirs - a Flat Land

We’re leaning to equality and the type of language would be an example of a flat land, or something that is very even, where beliefs are pretty much the same, there’s no sense that everybody is equal or not.  We are unique individuals, but at the same time, being able to understand that even though this person talks different or has a different personality or looks different, that on the inside they’re the same.  They have a heart, a liver, just like us.


Phil Specht  - 
 Wild Native Prairie

my metaphor for progressives is a wild native prairie with dozens of symbiotic interwoven relationships that define diversity while demanding inclusion; with recognition that the strength is hidden from view but the wholeness and beauty is not, all for one and one for all

Edwin Rutsch  - a Progressive Spaniel versus Conservative Ostrich

for me, Progressive Values are like a spaniel on the hunt.  Jumping through the fields, sniffing, searching, full of energy. Spaniels have an openness, exploration and friendliness to them.  Always looking for the next  new find, adventure and  idea. One of the most important progressive values to me it Seeking, that's the ongoing open-minded exploration and discovery of the world around us and searching for how to make things better.

Conservative Values are like the Ostrich with it's head in the sand. It's the opposite of the searching, instead it's being fearful and hiding from reality.  Someone told me, conservatives values start with the idea and try to fix the facts to fit them.  (For example the Failure of the occupation of Iraq.)  Hence the Failed Conservative Values of fear, dogma and close-mindedness.

"Metaphor gives light and strength to description." John Brent

 Can you create a metaphor for what Progressive Values are like and another one for what Conservative Values are like?  Describe and explain your metaphor. How do the images relate to the values?

For more Progressive Values Stories:

Edwin Rutsch

What Are Progressive Values? Documentary Project
http://ProgressiveSpirit.com 
and Study Group
http://www.dfalink.com/group.php?id=2285 



Authors Website: http://cultureofempathy.com

Authors Bio:
Founder of the Center for Building a Culture of Empathy.
http://cultureofempathy.com
The Culture of Empathy website is a growing portal for resources and information about the values of empathy and compassion. It contains articles, conferences, definitions, experts, history, interviews, videos, science and much more about empathy and compassion.

I am also working on a documentary on empathy
more bio here:
http://humanityquest.com/Projects/Bios/EdwinRutsch/

Back