Post a Comment
Original Content at
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Associate Member, or higher).

December 7, 2013

Redefining Citizenship Can End the War on Drugs

By Eric Lucas

"Jim Crow laws were wiped off the books decades ago, but today an astounding percentage of the African-American community is warehoused in prisons or trapped in a permanent second-class status..." from The New Jim Crow.


From http://www.flickr.com/photos/98688665@N07/10130841943/: Martin Luther King, Jr. Monument
Martin Luther King, Jr. Monument
(Image by treewoman8)
  Permission   Details   DMCA

"Jim Crow laws were wiped off the books decades ago, but today an astounding percentage of the African-American community is warehoused in prisons or trapped in a permanent second-class status..." from The New Jim Crow.  

Warehousing People:   The New Jim Crow 

The War on Drugs has resulted in an unnecessary and unjustified warehousing of the minority community.   In her book, The New Jim Crow, author Michelle Alexander writes:

When the War on Drugs gained full steam in the mid-1980s, prison admission for African Americans skyrocketed, nearly quadrupling in three years, and then increasing steadily until it reached in 2000 a level more than twenty-six times the level in 1983.   The number of drug admissions for Latinos was twenty-two times the number of 1983 admissions. Whites have been admitted to prison for drug offenses at increased rates as well -- the number of whites admitted for drug offenses in 2000 was eight times the number admitted in 1983 -- but their relative numbers are small compared to blacks' and Latinos'.   Although the majority of illegal drug users and dealers nationwide are white; three-fourths of all people imprisoned for drug offenses have been black or Latino.

These facts reveal that our criminal justice system is threatening to create a permanent sub-citizen underclass.    And our society should not accept this.

Work and Significance  

When faced with this data it is hard to escape the conclusion that we are just warehousing huge numbers of our people.    And it becomes even clearer that the activity itself suggests that as a society it appears that we believe the "warehoused" individuals have no significance.

My book, The Tao of Public Service, rejects this posture of non-significance, asserting:

We make a mistake when we assume some people are significant and others have no significance at all... these ideas... can apply to any work... every task can be considered an act of service to our nation when that task is done well.   In this way every act can be an act of public service... In this way each and every person can have the highest level of significance.

If we accept this assertion as true, then it is immoral to warehouse people in prisons when they have a chance to become better citizens.   This is particularly true when we know other working alternatives to prison.

Therapeutic Courts  

Substance Abuse is an epidemic in this country. Studies report that one in five children/adolescents has an emotional or behavioral disorder; that one in ten has a substance-abuse disorder, and only about 23% suffering from a mental-health disorder get treatment. [i] Evaluations of adolescents in substance-abuse treatment have revealed that between 50-90% are suffering from co-occurring disorders. [ii]   And since 2005, being adolescent and having a "dual-diagnosis" is now considered the norm. [iii]

I was the presiding officer for our county juvenile-offender drug court for 4 years.   When you see the disease of addiction up close you realize how deeply it rests in the problem of dysfunctional character. In drug court the kids suffer from depression to post-traumatic stress disorder. The types of mental-health problems existing in drug court and the dependency system are legion.

However, research has shown that drug courts effectively address these dysfunctions.   The National Association for Drug Court Professionals (NADCP) sums it up like this:

Our nation's scientific community put Drug Courts under its microscope. After all of their rigorous testing and research they concluded that Drug Courts work. Better than jail or prison. Better than probation and treatment alone. Drug Courts significantly reduce drug use and crime and are more cost-effective than any other proven criminal justice strategy. [iv]  

And in my view, given the evidence from Therapeutic Courts we need to go even further in this "therapeutic" direction and promote the full development of a "functional character" in each and every one of our citizens.     

The Obligations of Citizenship

In a very real sense, good citizenship is as simple as elementary-school conduct.   As an old elementary school and AAU coach, I know that good citizenship is essentially the same as being a good teammate.    Legendary UCLA basketball Coach John Wooden has conclusively defined what it means to be a successful team member.   In his book Practical Modern Basketball Coach Wooden said:

True success can be attained only through self-satisfaction in knowing that you did everything within the limits of your ability to become the very best that you are capable of becoming...

It is impossible to attain perfection, but that should be the goal.   Less than 100 percent of your effort in every respect toward attaining your objective is not success...


Coach Wooden's meaning is clear in the context of a team.   But why should this team obligation be limited to sports?   Why shouldn't this obligation be the essence of all our social relationships?

If accepted, these ideas would mean that it must be the obligation of every citizen to strive for self-perfection -- just as it was the obligation of every team member under Coach Wooden's tutelage.   It means that this is what every citizen would be OBLIGATED TO GIVE to their fellow citizens as an essential feature of their citizenship: striving to be their best self.

The Expectations of Citizenship 

Conversely, each and every citizen should have a basic expectation of WHAT THEY ARE ENTITLED TO RECEIVE from our nation.   A full description of such rights is a much deeper and complex discussion better left for another time.   However, there must be certain minimums.   On this point, my article entitled:   Plutocracy Ignores Purpose presents the following quote:

President Franklin Delano Roosevelt said, ""Our true destiny is not to be ministered unto but to minister to ourselves and to our fellow men." I assert that every single person has a purpose. No one is insignificant.

As such, each citizen has the right to expect his society to treat him or her as having inherent purpose and value.    No one should be treated as insignificant.  No one should be treated as a throwaway.

Redefining Citizenship 

Such a redefinition of citizenship--as an obligation to strive to become your best coupled with an entitlement to have that effort supported--would end the war on drugs.   This ethic of significance would make such a war obsolete.

[1] The New Jim Crow at 97.

[i] Professor Holly Hills, PHD 2008 National Drug Court Conference Presentation Materials

[ii] Reebye, Moretti, and Lessard 1995; Rounds-Bryant, Kristiansen and Hubbard, 1999.

[iii] Roberts and Corcoran, 2005.

[iv] See research National Association of Drug Court Professionals at: http://www.nadcp.org/learn/drug-courts-work-0

Submitters Website: http://www.ezlight.wordpress.com

Submitters Bio:

Eric Z. Lucas is an alumnus of Stanford University (Creative Writing Major: 1972-1975), the University of Washington (1981: BA English Literature and Elementary Education) and Harvard Law School, J.D. 1986. Since law school he has been a public servant: a prosecuting attorney, a city attorney and a trial judge. Born in Spokane, Washington where his military family lived until the age of twelve, he still resides in Washington State. Married to his wife Beth since 1974, they have four adult children and two grandchildren. Further discussions of Eric's work are available on the website: The Path of Public Service. Eric is the author of the following books: a children's book entitled: "The Island Horse," November 2005; "The Tao of Public Service" published February 2013 by Balboa Press, and "All Lives Matter: Essays, On the Need for a New View of Citizenship" published by KindlePublishing e-book July 2015. Eric's books are currently available from: Amazon.com, Barnes and Noble, Balboa Press and Self Discovery Publications directly or through the website listed below.