Back OpEd News | |||||||
Original Content at https://www.opednews.com/articles/I-asked-some-of-my-Faceboo-by-Mary-Lynn-Ritch-130718-305.html (Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher). |
July 18, 2013
I asked some of my Facebook friends about their opinion to the Trayvon Martin verdict
By Samantha Jones
After George Zimmerman was acquitted of all counts for the death of Trayvon Martin, my Facebook Newsfeed blew up with opinions that I had to unsubscribe to a few just so I could see all the pregnancies and updated marathon times. But I decided to ask a few of the most intelligently rabid a few questions to understand their side of the story.
::::::::
(Article changed on July 18, 2013 at 13:24)
(Article changed on July 18, 2013 at 13:23)
(Article changed on July 18, 2013 at 13:22)
After George Zimmerman was acquitted for the death of Trayvon Martin, my Facebook feed blew up with opinions about the trail from the ignorant and otherwise. As someone that lost interest in the trial as soon as celebrities got involved, I found the outburst a little obnoxious quite frankly.
But while sifting through the most ignorantly racist and annoying posts from the trial voyeurs and even reading a few aloud to my brother on the way back home from a wedding (in ironically, Florida), I decided I wasn't giving my rabid Facebook friends with an opinion a fair chance and became slighted with how initially annoyed with them I really was. So instead of writing it off to another stupid, high-profile trial cult-like following, I decided to ask a few of my most avid yet more intelligent Facebook Trayvon Martin supporters why they were so passionate about the verdict to figure out what the anger was really all about. I am not including their name in order to protect their privacy. I wanted them to have the opportunity to vent more publicly. .
1. The Nurse
Where are you from?
What race do you identify yourself with?
Black
Have you followed the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman Case? If so, are you surprised by the verdict? Why or why not?
I have followed the trial and I was surprised by the verdict. While I thought the state failed to prove without a reasonable doubt Zimmerman was guilty of second degree murder, I did think that the jury would find him convicted of manslaughter simply because he deliberately disobeyed the instructions given to him by the non emergency dispatch and placed himself in a situation that he ended up losing control of. I felt that the story he told was very inconsistent and being a nurse, the injuries he sustained were not consistent with his statement on how he sustained them. I think that had Zimmerman identified himself as the neighborhood watch leader, the outcome of the situation would have been different. In my opinion, this verdict tells people that it is ok to profile and stalk someone take matters ,into your own hands and if things don't go like you think they will, you can kill the person you think may be doing something with no evidence of wrong doing on their part.
Did you know Trayvon Martin or do you know George Zimmerman personally? Do you have any ties to the case? If not, do you follow other high profile trials? Why was this particular trail something you found interesting?
I do not know anybody that was involved in the trial and I usually don't follow trials at all, but I found this one interesting because I am a mother with four children, one of them being a boy. I have six nephews and many friends with children as well.
Will you volunteer your time to raise awareness over what you feel is an injustice in relation to the outcome of this trial?
At the end of the day, I feel like George Zimmerman profiled Trayvon Martin (I don't think he racially profiled him because it was dark, how could he know he was black until he actually got up on him?), decided to confront him because he was tired of the recent break-ins in the neighborhood, and simply but of more than he could chew and got his ass kicked by a 17 year old kid. Do I think he had intentions on killing Trayvon? No, I don't. I think he was just fed up and tired of nothing being done about the recent crime in the area and things just got out of hand and someone died because Zimmerman took the law into his own hands. He will forever have to live with the fact that he killed a child that was armed with Shuttles and tea. And he will also live in fear; constantly looking over his shoulder hoping no-one decides to take his life because they felt that justice was not served. I pray for both families and everyone involved.
2. The Disabled Veteran and Aspiring Writer
Where are you from?
What race do you identify yourself with?
White
Have you followed the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman Case? If so, are you surprised by the verdict?
I'm not terribly surprised because honestly the prosecution tried for the murder charge they couldn't get and did a terrible job of proving it.
They should have just tried for manslaughter, and gotten it. I did not know either personally. I followed this trial more because it was more available. I'd be interested to read about the James Holmes trial as well, but I haven't seen much in the MSM.
Will you volunteer your time to raise awareness over what you feel is an injustice in relation to the outcome of this trial?
I will be writing articles on Yahoo! Voices about injustices in the system, but probably not doing more than that.
3. The Deputy Clerk
Where are you from?
White
I have been following the Martin/Zimmerman case and I was shocked by the verdict. I can see how/why the jury found him not guilty of second-degree murder, but I don't understand why they failed to convict him on a lesser charge of manslaughter. I am aware of
I do not know either party personally, nor do I have any ties to the case. However, I do pay attention to current events, national news, and I like to look at cases from a social scientist point of view. I found this trail interesting because it emphasizes the way our society has taught us to social profile.
Yes, I would like to volunteer my time to raise awareness; not only to this case, but to other cases that highlight social constructs we have created that can have a negative effect on our lives. I will be attending a party affiliated gala next weekend to discuss options of unity and ways to better our society.
If you can think of anything to add feel free to do so.
We are all human beings. A crime is a crime. A mistake is a mistake. Everyone should be held accountable for their actions. I still have faith in humanity, but the verdict of the trail illustrates to me that we have a long way to go.
4. The Newsroom Clerk/stringer
What race do you identify yourself with?
African American
Have you followed the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman Case? If so, are you surprised by the verdict?
I didn't watch the entire trial but I knew about the case. I was initially surprised because I honestly thought that a juror of mothers would be able to relate to a mother who lost her son simply because he was in the wrong place at the wrong time. But after the fact, I realized that if
Did you know Trayvon Martin or do you know George Zimmerman personally? Do you have any ties to the case? If not, do you follow other trials for example: the James Holmes or Jodi Arias trials? Why was this particular trail something you found interesting?
With my job, it's hard not to follow breaking news stories such as James Holmes shooting up a theater or Jodi Arias killing her boyfriend but I can relate to this particular case because I am black and I have a step-son, cousins, nephews, and friends who could have easily been in Trayvon's shoes. Why? Because they are young, black men that may even dress like Trayvon would, i.e. wear a hoodie. Also, some of them are not perfect by any means, but do they still deserve the right to walk home at night while wearing a hoodie, and not be looked at as a suspect? HELL YES THEY DO AND SO DID TRAYVON.
Will you volunteer your time to raise awareness over what you feel is an injustice in relation to the outcome of this trial? Why or why not?
If the people who witnessed what happened at the trial can't make a conscious decision to change their actions and way of thinking, then honestly all the volunteering in the world won't do a damn thing. So, I'll answer this question with a quote from the movie "Notorious". "If you want to change the world, we first have to change ourselves". That's how I plan to raise awareness, by working on me and my actions.
5. The Nurse:
What race do you identify yourself with?
African American
I am a RN. I am African American. I have followed the case from the beginning and signed the petition to at least get him investigated. I am unfortunately not surprised by the verdict. I do not believe that he racially profiled Trayvon but I do believe he criminally profiled Trayvon and based his decision on the fact that there had been break ins that has involved young African Americans and he thought he was going to have justice for his neighborhood. He just should have followed the instructions given to him by the 911 operator. I wasn't surprised on how the jury voted because of how GZ was portrayed. The fact is that had he not got out of his car and followed Trayvon there would never have been a fight and he wouldn't have felt the need to use deadly force. Our country is in turmoil right now over race issues and stereotyping that should not still exist in 2013
Did you know Trayvon Martin or do you know George Zimmerman personally? Do you have any ties to the case? If not, do you follow other trials for example: the James Holmes or Jodi Arias trials?
I do not know Trayvon or George Zimmerman personally. I have no ties to this case. I followed the Jodi Arias trials and thought what she did was despicable and uncalled for. She deserved the punishment that she received. This case was an interest just because of the fact that George Zimmerman could have avoided this altogether if he had not taken matters into his own hands. This mattered to me more because I am a mother and I have a young son and this could have easily happened to him if he were Trayvon's age.
Will you volunteer your time to raise awareness over what you feel is an injustice in relation to the outcome of this trial?
I have attended some of the marches and I have and will again volunteer my time to raise awareness over this tragedy that did not have to occur. This is an injustice to not only the African American community but to other racial communities as well. Trayvon was a son he could have been anyone's child no matter what race or nationality. People should not feel as though they can decide to take the law into their own hands and disregard instructions given by law enforcement individuals.
And this nurse ended with "thanks for valuing my opinion" and she actually made me feel glad that I took the time to ask her questions.
The Development Associate:
Where are you from?
What race do you identify yourself with?
Black - Afro Caribbean
Have you followed the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman Case? If so, are you surprised by the verdict?
Yes. I was not surprised by the verdict because even on the day Zimmerman murdered Martin, he was not arrested. They let him go straight home. That showed me how seriously they would take this issue in
Did you know Trayvon Martin or do you know George Zimmerman personally? Do you have any ties to the case? If not, do you follow other trials? Why was this particular trail something you found interesting?
I do not normally follow high-profile cases and I do not personally know either party, but I do know people similar to Zimmerman and Martin. I know people that are overzealous vigilantes looking to find a 'criminal' and shoot them (we have a serious cowboy-culture issue here in the
Yes. I'm already a natural protester and I attend a lot of protests over variety of issues. On Sunday I went to a protest in
Say what you will about the responses you read and although I don't share the same views with a few of the people with the answers given above, it is obvious to me that this trial meant more to some than it being just an unarmed black kid getting shot to death by a mixed man in Florida and nobody has a right to tell them otherwise.
There are those that are slighted by the system and the historical track record of our country has not been fair and it would be sheer ignorance to claim that things are equal today. But how can we move forward from here in a way that properly honors the memory of Trayvon Martin?
Is an aspiring writer and advocate on mental illness awareness.