Back   OpEdNews
Original Content at
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).

May 26, 2011

The Book of Mormon: the Musical

By Dr Stuart Jeanne Bramhall

The creators of South Park released the cast recording of their musical The Book of Mormon last week. Although it bashes Mormons (very slightly), it's really an extremely funny satire of the unique American fad known as positive thinking.


This past week NPR (Terry Gross Fresh Air) played a selection of tunes from the new Broadway smash hit The Book of Mormon, by the creators of the irreverent TV series South Park -  (Trey Parker and Matt Stone  -- with musical assistance from Robert Lopez). The digital cast recording is already number ten on iTunes, after being released on May 17th. It will be available as a DVD on June 7th.

The creators categorize The Book of Mormon as a religious satire musical and deny that any Mormon-bashing occurs. I would disagree. However their attack on religious fundamentalism is disguised in the form of chirpy upbeat Rogers and Hammerstein style music and dance numbers, which sends the message home without being overtly offensive. Critics seem to especially like the way The Book of Mormon pokes fun at the Broadway musical as an art form. In fact some have compared it to The Producers, the musical (and later movie) about a gung ho producer determined to stage an upbeat musical about Adolph Hitler called Springtime for Hitler.

My favorite song is a tap dance number called "Turn it Off," which I believe perfectly captures the essence of Mormonism and all fundamentalist religions. It conveys the expectation that believers will deal with all personal, family and social problems and all unpleasant feelings by shutting them out of conscious awareness. In psychology the process itself is referred to as"repression," while the end result of repressing unpleasant thoughts and feelings is called "denial."

This is the chorus: "Turn it off like a light switch. Just go click. It's a cool little Mormon trick. Turn it off. We do it all the time. The first three verses concern a Mormon missionary shutting out recollections of his drunken father beating his mom, a second missionary refusing to think about his sister's  death by cancer and a third struggling with feelings of latent homosexuality.

The Doctrine of Feigning Happiness

The plot of The Book of Mormon concerns two Mormon missionaries who are sent to Uganda, where there are forced to confront the immense misery of population struggling with poverty, famine, AIDS and a ruthless dictator -- circumstances that none of their missionary training has prepared them to deal with. They quickly learn the people they are working with have no chance of overcoming such extreme misery by feigning happiness, as Mormon doctrine teaches.

Instead of "Turn it Off," the Ugandans sing a zippy little number when bad things happen called "Hasa Dega Eebowai" -- English translation "Fuck you, God."  Unable to cope, one of the missionaries obtains a transfer to Orlando. While the other manages to convert a number of Ugandans by weaving teachings from Star Wars and Lord of the Rings into conventional Mormon doctrine. Understandably, he comes under heavy criticism from church leaders when they find out. Here the authors play up the irony of expecting converts to believe the equally fantastical teachings invented by Joseph Smith (found in the actual Book of Mormon) -- including the claim that God created the first human being in Missouri and that Native Americans are really a lost tribe of Israel that somehow migrated to the New World.

Denial Comes in Secular Flavors

Unfortunately reliance on repression and denial to cope with daily life isn't limited to Mormons or to religious fundamentalists. Repression and denial clearly come in secular flavors. The current "positive thinking" fad -- a mind-training technique focused on quashing all negative thoughts to focus exclusively on optimistic ones -- is an excellent example.

Thanks to the transformation of news reporting into the mass distraction known as "infotainment," Americans are continually confronted with the expectation that they repress, deny and self-distract, rather than acknowledging or confronting the global crises -- climate change, food and water shortages, mass unemployment and homelessness -- that threaten the very survival of our children and grandchildren.

In this sense, The Book of Mormon isn't satirizing Mormonism or religion so much as "Americanism," at least as it appears to an industrialized world where everyone else is marching in the streets.

Authors Website:

Authors Bio:
I am a 63 year old American child and adolescent psychiatrist and political refugee in New Zealand. I have just published a young adult novel THE BATTLE FOR TOMORROW (which won a NABE Pinnacle Achievement Award) about a 16 year old girl who participates in the blockade and occupation of the US Capitol. I also have a new non-fiction ebook REVOLUTIONARY CHANGE and a 2010 memoir, THE MOST REVOLUTIONARY ACT: MEMOIR OF AN AMERICAN REFUGEE describing the circumstances that led me to leave the US in 2002 to start a new life in New Zealand. My memoir won an Allbooks Review Editor's Choice Award. I have a political commentary blog at my website.