Back   OpEd News
Font
PageWidth
Original Content at
https://www.opednews.com/articles/Cross-State-Sales-will-Bre-by-John-Retherford-110111-175.html
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).

January 12, 2011

Cross State Sales will Break Health Insurance Just Like it Broke Credit Cards

By John Retherford

The republican proposal to allow the sale of health insurance across state lines could be disasterous if the same policy's effect on the credit card industry is any sign.

::::::::

When the new Republican congress starts talking about allowing people to buy health insurance across state lines keep in mind what this same reform did to the consumer credit industry.  The republican advocates of this reform say it would give customers better deals because more companies would compete over their business, but in reality states would compete over insurance companies in a race to see which would regulate them and protect their customers the least.

The supreme court has set precedent that in cross state transactions the only state that can regulate the transaction is the state the seller is located in.  This creates a strong incentive for insurers to all move to the state that regulates them the very least.  Credit card companies started relocating within a matter of days of this reform in their industry during the late 70s.  With credit cards it certainly did not result in better deals for customers; it resulted in higher interest rates; more tricks, traps, and fees; and a general rise in the exploitation of their customers.

This kind of exploitation is already the norm in the health insurance industry.  If all insurers could relocate to the state with the least regulations, then states would lose the ability to regulate the sale of insurance in their state.  With health insurance it would not be people's credit rating or finances that get screwed, but their health and their lives.  States will be unable to protect their citizen's interests.  Ironically, this Republican policy would force the Federal Government to regulate the insurance markets even more tightly since the states would be powerless to step in. 



Authors Bio:
I'm an author and a life long student student. I'm focused on advancing progressive ideas through writing, networking and activism. I write about wide ranging topics but am especially interested in public policy concerning the mass media, economics, labor struggles, and foreign relations.

I am also interested in science, philosophy, dance, music, and art. When not writing I enjoy practicing martial arts and meditation, dancing, producing music and videos, and cooking good food.

Back