none of such pro-war handwringing makes as much sense as a simple red-white-and-blue bumper sticker that says: "These colors don't run . . . the world." Fierce controversy has focused on terminating a runaway general. But the crying need is to terminate a runaway war.
::::::::
From
BuzzFlash
When the wheels are coming off, it doesn't do much good to change the
driver.
Whatever the name of the commanding general in
Afghanistan, the U.S. war effort will continue its carnage and
futility.
Between the lines, some news accounts are
implying as much. Hours before Gen. Stanley McChrystal's meeting with
President Obama on Wednesday, the
New York Times reported that "the
firestorm was fueled by increasing doubts -- even in the military --
that Afghanistan can be won and by crumbling public support for the
nine-year war as American casualties rise."
It now does
McChrystal little good that news media have trumpeted everything from
his Spartan personal habits (scarcely eats or sleeps) to his physical
stamina (runs a lot) to his steel-trap alloy of military smarts and
scholarship (reads history). Any individual is expendable.
For months, the McChrystal star had been slipping. A few days before
the
Rolling Stone piece caused a sudden plunge from war-making grace,
Time Magazine's conventional-wisdom weathervane Joe Klein was notably
down on McChrystal's results: "Six months after Barack Obama announced
his new Afghan strategy in a speech at West Point, the policy seems
stymied."
Now, words like "stymied" and "stalemate" are
often applied to the Afghanistan war. But that hardly means the U.S.
military is anywhere near withdrawal.
Walter Cronkite used
the word "stalemate" in his famous February 1968 declaration to CBS
viewers that the Vietnam War couldn't be won. "We have been too often
disappointed by the optimism of the American leaders both in Vietnam
and Washington to have faith any longer in the silver linings they find
in the darkest clouds," he said. And: "It seems now more certain than
ever that the bloody experience of Vietnam is to end in a stalemate."
Yet the U.S. war on Vietnam continued for another five years,
inflicting more unspeakable horrors on a vast scale.
Like
thousands of other U.S. activists, I've been warning against escalation
of the Afghanistan war for a long time. Opposition has grown, but
today the situation isn't much different than what I described in an
article on December 9, 2008: "Bedrock faith in the Pentagon's massive
capacity for inflicting violence is implicit in the nostrums from
anointed foreign-policy experts. The echo chamber is echoing: the
Afghanistan war is worth the cost that others will pay."
The latest events reflect unwritten rules for top military commanders:
Escalating a terrible war is fine. Just don't say anything mean about
your boss.
But the most profound aspects of Rolling Stone's
article "The Runaway General" have little to do with the general. The
takeaway is -- or should be -- that the U.S. war in Afghanistan is an
insoluble disaster, while the military rationales that propel it are
insatiable. "Instead of beginning to withdraw troops next year, as
Obama promised, the military hopes to ramp up its counterinsurgency
campaign even further," the article points out. And "counterinsurgency
has succeeded only in creating a never-ending demand for the primary
product supplied by the military: perpetual war."
There
was something plaintive and grimly pathetic about the last words of the
New York Times editorial that arrived on desks just hours before the
general's White House meeting with the commander in chief: "Whatever
President Obama decides to do about General McChrystal, he needs to get
hold of his Afghanistan policy right now."
Like their
counterparts at media outlets across the United States, members of the
Times editorial board are clinging to the counterinsurgency dream.
But none of such pro-war handwringing makes as much sense as a
simple red-white-and-blue bumper sticker that says: "These colors don't
run . . . the world."
Fierce controversy has focused on
terminating a runaway general. But the crying need is to terminate a
runaway war.
Authors Bio:
Norman Solomon is cofounder and national coordinator of RootsAction.org. He was a Bernie Sanders delegate from California to the 2016 Democratic National Convention and is currently a coordinator of the relaunched Bernie Delegates Network. Solomon is the author of a dozen books include War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death.