For the first year of Democrats in control of everything, the big winners are the lobbyists, at the expense of the people.
There is a reason the president's popularity has fallen from the 70s to the 40s and a reason the Democratic Congress now has an unfavorable rating of almost 70 percent, similar to Republican negatives before 2006 and 2008. Democrats can barely achieve anything today, even with their huge majorities.
::::::::
Let me begin and end this otherwise negative comment with some good
news. While the president will do nothing to fight for a better
healthcare bill in conference, there are sign that Sens. Ben Nelson
(D-Neb.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) are feeling some heat after taking
a beating from the press. The conference battle now begins, and while
the president will be the legislative bystander he has been so far,
House Democrats will weight in, and if they fight, they can win
something back.
The White House anticipates negative end-of-year stories, so the
pre-emptive strike that does not matter has begun. The president and
his aides are in The Washington Post this morning comparing him to
Franklin Roosevelt, reduced to listing the credit card bill, which has
led to eight months of consumers being crushed by banks, among the
Rooseveltian achievements.
Wow.
I hope the president
becomes a good or great president. Some things have been achieved. But
it brings great peril to the Democratic Party for any Democrat to hype
and overstate what has been achieved in the first year of a presidency
with a Democratic president who entered office with huge popularity and
a very large Democratic majority in the House and Senate.
For the first year of Democrats in control of everything, the big winners are the lobbyists, at the expense of the people.
Ronald
Reagan said many things that were wrong, but one thing he said that was
totally right was that elections are won or lost when voters ask: Are
we better off than we were four years ago?
There is a reason the
president's popularity has fallen from the 70s to the 40s and a reason
the Democratic Congress now has an unfavorable rating of almost 70
percent, similar to Republican negatives before 2006 and 2008.
Democrats can barely achieve anything today, even with their huge
majorities. If they lose seats in 2010, as they almost certainly will,
possibly many seats, the golden moment that began in November 2008 will
be dead.
Whether the president compares himself to FDR and LBJ,
or to Millard Fillmore and Franklin Pierce, is irrelevant. While he has
grade-inflated himself from the beginning, his numbers have fallen
dramatically. It does not matter anymore what he says about himself.
What matters is what people think of him, which is decided by what
people think about the state of their lives, not by what the president
says about himself.
In my view, this grade inflation, in the
face of modest results for some and disastrous results for others (such
as the more than 17 percent jobless), this self-praise makes his
ratings go down, not up, and makes his credibility go lower, not
higher. The president still does not understand this. Voters do not
care about a great communicator, they hunger for a great jobs creator.
Ditto for Democrats in Congress.
Here is the most objective
fact, which cannot be denied, after the first year of Obama: It has
been a year for record Wall Street and bank profits. There has been
zero reform, yet huge salaries have become more huge, giant bonuses
have become more giant. Now the pattern repeats for insurers and Big
Pharma. People's premiums and drug prices have risen even higher, and
they will rise even higher, along with huge salaries, along with huge
bonuses, along with huge consumer unrest, if the bill is passed.
In
fact, almost all of the negative events to real people in the real
world under the healthcare bill happen first. Almost all of the
positive events, if they occur, happen four or five years from now.
Even if the healthcare bill has merit, the impact on credibility
against the president and Democrats in Congress will be negative from
today until four or five years from now when the positive events occur,
if they do, which is far from certain.
The president and
Democrats won't gain from hyping this any more than they gain by hyping
a failed credit card bill that has led to consumers being gouged with
higher interest rates, often 30 percent or more, and being gouged with
aggressive fees, cuts in credit lines and punishment of consumers and
small businesses.
People hear the public-relations words and
they know the reality of their lives, and when the words contradict
their lives, they develop contempt for the words that they know are
untrue for them.
I am now seeing liberal senators say things
about the healthcare bill they know are not true, when they hype it in
desperation, after giving up the reforms they know are most important.
I am seeing something I cannot remember in the many years I have been
in Washington, when certain liberals senators, after surrendering the
public option, claim to its supporters that they will start fighting
for it once this bill passes, which only ratifies their surrender
before the House and Senate conference and makes a promise they know is
meaningless.
Let me repeat this for emphasis: I cannot remember
a time when liberal politicians were coming so close to misleading the
base of the Democratic Party in such a sweeping manner, which I believe
poses great and extreme dangers for the future of the party in 2010 and
beyond.
We should pass the healthcare bill in the Senate and
progressives in Congress should fight hard in conference. Lieberman and
Nelson are starting to feel the heat.
What we should never do,
never, never, never, is try to sell the base of the Democratic Party on
things that are not true and promises that will not be kept.
What
we must understand today, as well, is that the issues we fight for are
also shared by the large majority of political independents and voters
as a whole. What is all the more sad about the surrender is that the
president will literally sell out almost anything to get one Republican
on the health vote, but also accepts surrender on drug importation and
insurance price-fixing, which have support from dozens of Republicans
in the House and Senate and 80 percent support from the nation as a
whole.
The fight is not over, but whatever the president and
Democrats do, they must fight harder, and hype less, because the truth
will come out in the daily lives of voters, and the voters cannot be
fooled. Either we tell the truth or we face the consequences.
Authors Bio:
Brent Budowsky is a regular columnist on thehill.com. He served as Legislative Assistant to U.S. Senator Lloyd Bentsen, responsible for commerce and intelligence matters, including one of the core drafters of the CIA Identities Law. Served as Legislative Director to Congressman Bill Alexander, then Chief Deputy Whip, House of Representatives. Currently a member of the International Advisory Council of the Intelligence Summit. Left goverment in 1990 for marketing and public affairs business including major corporate entertainment and talent management.