Since the day Russia dramatically escalated the war in Ukraine there have been odd conversational confusions. Two people who both claim to oppose the war discover that they oppose opposite sides of the war. Or they discover that one of them opposes both sides of the war (true story, it actually exists, I'm one of them) while the other believes that only Russia is waging war at all, while Ukraine is waging something else entirely.
Since the days when Teddy Roosevelt could advocate for war for its own sake, a certain segment of Western populations has changed. We still have those eager to wage war in Ukraine, or at least to have Ukrainians wage war in Ukraine, and to call it war. Some openly call it a war for NATO expansion, while most call it a defensive and justifiable if not absolutely inevitable war against evil, and of course its quasi-official name: The Unprovoked War. But they still call it a war.
Then there are those who think of war as horrible mass murder (which, of course, it is) and as something that they would never participate in or support. If you describe one of these people, who supports the Ukrainian side of the war, as supporting the Ukrainian side of the war, they will grow quite indignant and explain that only Russia is waging war, that Ukraine is simply fighting and killing, and bragging about the body counts, in order to end Russia's war. Fighting to end Russia's war is thus anti-war. In fact, it's peace work. In addition, it's socialism. So you will learn. You may find this a nonsensical way to talk. Supporters of the Russian side don't talk like this, even though they also claim to be doing the defensive, the justifiable, and the inevitable. But, nonsensical or not, this is how leftist-ish supporters of the Ukrainian war-fighting have talked for over a year and a half, and there's no point in pretending they haven't.
If you click on a link to a National Public Radio story from April 2022 about a Ukrainian band bringing an anti-war message on a U.S. tour, you will soon discover that it is a pro-war message, although like every other pro-war message in the history of the world, it is against the other side of the war:
The band in question has a video with the words "No War" and "Stop Putin." The way they intend to stop Putin is, however, with war. I don't advise listening to the music, which clearly had nothing whatsoever to do with garnering NPR's approval.
As early as February 2022, as you can read in this Deutsche Welle article, there were pro-war rallies held around the world under the banner of "anti-war." Here's the headline:
[if images were allowed]
While such rallies were promoted as anti-war and understood by some as simply expressing sympathy for the victims of war (at least on one side), and while even the article above quotes one person blaming "both sides," the events were packed with pro-war signs and supporters, and were used by the Ukrainian, U.S., and NATO governments as support for war. President Zelensky thanked people for the support. A photo collection at The Atlantic shows many messages against war ("Stop the War," "We Want Peace," etc., but also the subtly different "Stop Putin," "Stand with Ukraine," etc.)
One could almost call it a harmless mistake. People oppose a murderous invasion of one country by another. They have no idea what led up to this catastrophe and could not even tell you what unarmed civilian defense means. If they oppose the murderous invasion they are antiwar and also, simply inevitably, pro-war. But they want to communicate clearly, so they'll need to avoid calling their pro-war position pro-war. After all, they want the war ended. They'll not do terrorism but counter-terrorism, launch no offenses but only counter-offenses, and wage no war but only unwar.
But after many months of both sides predicting imminent victory while quietly admitting there's no end in sight, and after many months of seeing both sides refuse to negotiate peace, and in particular after many months of watching Ukraine be prevented from negotiating peace by Western demands and by Western weapons supplies, can it possibly remain honest to go on calling war support "antiwar"?
One group that calls war support antiwar is the so-called Ukraine Solidarity Network, which is supported by various people who have opposed numerous past wars. Just as anyone in the U.S. peace movement knows dozens of people who have supported the Russian invasion of Ukraine, one also knows people who have opposed dozens of wars and now support the Ukrainian side of the war, people like Lawrence Wittner, John Feffer, Bill Fletcher Jr., Rory Fanning, and Howie Hawkins. Of course, the Ukraine Solidarity Network often does admit that Ukraine is waging war. How could it not, when its purpose is precisely to support that war?
"It is urgent to end this war as soon as possible. This can only be achieved through the success of Ukraine's resistance to Russia's invasion. Ukraine is fighting a legitimate war of self-defense, indeed a war for its survival as a nation. Calling for 'peace' in the abstract is meaningless in these circumstances."
But this group also advertises its speakers as heading out on antiwar tours. Why would Counterpunch publish a pro-war announcement just because it's labeled antiwar? Why would Democracy Now invite the speakers on? Maybe The Nation isn't quite as out of character, but still. One clue may be found in this exchange:
"AMY GOODMAN: . . . . But you're on an antiwar speaking tour.
"HANNA PEREKHODA: Yeah. Actually, for Ukraine, this is a war of self-defense. And I think it's very important to make a difference between, you know, the use of violence with the aim of aggression and the use of violence with the aim to protect your own existence. So, this is why in Ukraine, as I said, all the civic and political organizations are united by this consensus that, you know, the political life in Ukraine, for example, the life of the civil society is possible under the is not possible under the condition of a foreign occupation, an occupation by a foreign army, which actually commit war crimes."
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).
