Most Popular Choices
Share on Facebook 51 Printer Friendly Page More Sharing
Exclusive to OpEd News:
OpEdNews Op Eds    H2'ed 1/2/20

Trump and Lynching: An Historical Comparative Analysis

Follow Me on Twitter     Message Steven Jonas
Become a Fan
  (21 fans)


"Either this nation shall kill racism, or racism shall kill this nation." (S. Jonas, August, 2018)


"To announce that there must be no criticism of the President . . . is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public. Nothing but the truth should be spoken about him or anyone else. But it is even more important to tell the truth, pleasant or unpleasant, about him than about anyone else."

Theodore Roosevelt, Editorial in The Kansas City Star May 7, 1918


Author's Note: Back in 2007, I published a column on the original BuzzFlash entitled "SS Guards at Play ." At the request of my dear friend Mark Karlin, editor and publisher of BuzzFlash, I revisited that column, with some new perspectives added.


At the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC is an extensive collection of photos from the Nazi extermination camp at Auschwitz. The photos show these extermination camp guards "on break," in 1944 at the height of the camp's mass murdering campaign, having picnic lunches, engaging in choral singing, playing with their dogs, gathering for smiling group photos, and smoking cigarettes. (This was so even though at Hitler's behest in the 1930's, the Nazis had instituted the world's first comprehensive anti-smoking campaign, in Germany. And there you thought that all German armed forces members always followed orders.) They even decorated Christmas trees (after all, the slogan "Gott mit Uns" was on their belt buckles). And all this time, thousands of Jews and other nationalities were being gassed and burned at the camp every day. Talk about the banality of evil.

Picture of a German soldier cutting a Polish man's beard - Oskar Schindler's Deutsche Emaillewaren-Fabrik (German Enamelware Factory).  Oh what fun, for the guard.
Picture of a German soldier cutting a Polish man's beard - Oskar Schindler's Deutsche Emaillewaren-Fabrik (German Enamelware Factory). Oh what fun, for the guard.
(Image by Jorge Lascar)
  Details   DMCA

Among the reactions to the contents of the exhibit was expressed by The New York Times columnist Roger Cohen ("Down Time from Murder," NYT, 9-24-07): how could those Germans go about their daily lives and laugh on breaks and retreats? Oh those "just awful" Germans. "How unique they were." Oh really?

Funny, but I was reminded of the set of photographs taken over many decades, some of which were actually made into picture postcards sent through the US mails, of public lynchings in the U.S. South. (You can see an extensive collection of them here.) People, other than the victims, laughing, smiling, kids playing , (no link necessary for this one) having lunch, and acting as if a lynching was a celebratory spectacle. How could that happen? And how indeed, only the Germans did that later on during the Holocaust. And then I also thought of those smiling photos of the guards at Abu Ghraib, Iraq. Just ordinary folks, having fun while brutalizing Iraqi prisoners. And then, we have the reports of the for-fun shootings of Iraqi civilians by Blackwater mercenaries in Iraq and the ongoing horror of Guantanamo.

Interrogation Procedure 1.  This must have been fun too.
Interrogation Procedure 1. This must have been fun too.
(Image by adilbookz)
  Details   DMCA

So, is it just us and the Germans who goes about our business while horrors are committed in our name? Well, no. It is any nationality that is fed the line that certain people who look just like humans, actually aren't. For the Germans, the Jews the Romanos and the Slavs were subhuman. For the Turks, it was the Armenians.. For the American South it was (and unfortunately in a variety of parts of our country it still is) that Blacks were subhuman. For Trump, it is brown people trying to save their lives by coming to the US. For certain members of our Armed Forces, there was a message delivered to them somehow, that somehow their Iraqi prisoners were subhuman. Humans don't do to other humans what the particular members of our species recorded in all of these photos did. Those deeds are done only to "sub-humans."

But it couldn't happen here again, could it? Nah. Couldn't possibly. We're just too advanced. No one could get away with labeling all of their political opponents as "traitors," as "Godless," as "just not like us," as "not Christian and thus not qualified to govern" (and yes, none other than "the maverick" John McCain said that in so many words back in 2007 (The Progress Report, "Blackout and Brownout," Oct. 1, 2007), and thus quite possibly somehow less than human. Couldn't happen here, could it. Could it? Just look at Trump, and the answer is yes.

But back to lynching, which was an execution, by mob action, without due process of law. It was carried out primarily in the South, both before and after the Civil War, most often (but not always) against African Americans. Lynching was condonded throughout the slave-holding South, of course during the Confederacy, and then onward from the middle of Reconstruction (1865-77) through the Jim Crow Era. Although its use came to an end around 1968, following the passage of the Civil Rights Act,

Lynching, which could happen to anyone, at any time, at any place, throughout the states of the Old Confederacy, was a primary weapon for the enforcement of the doctrine of white supremacy \. throughout those states. It was vicious. It was murder. It was arbitrary. And by the photographs, which made it onto postcards, it was celebrated throughout the South because, of course, "Blacks" were considered "subhuman," as well as having to be "kept in their place," by the use of random violence if deemed necessary, as well as by the "Jim Crow" laws that enforced legal separation, discrimination and second-class citizenship for Blacks. Lynching indeed was one of the primary weapons used by the Southern states to enforce segregation and its resulting second-class subhuman status for blacks.

Lynching-of-will-james. Look at the crowd.  Were they having fun, or what?
Lynching-of-will-james. Look at the crowd. Were they having fun, or what?
(Image by (Not Known) Wikipedia (, Author: Author Not Given)
  Details   Source   DMCA

And then we come to Trump, who actually used the term to describe the impeachment proceedings which have now been passed in the House as articles of impeachment. How to account for this totally ahistorical use of the term? Briefly, there is a combination of explanations. First of all, he is widely considered to be a racist. Second of all, he repeatedly uses racism and racist tropes to promote himself, his Presidency and his reelection campaign.

But third, and most importantly, that Trump would use the term, which defines the most violent instrument of oppression of Blacks used in the South from the slave era until the very end of the Jim Crow Era, to describe a Constitutional procedure (see Article I; impeachment is a power of the Congress) that has been undertaken against him for infractions of the Constitution. The doctrine of white supremacy, tells you all you need to know about the man. He demonstrates his complete lack of knowledge of American history. He demonstrates his complete lack of knowledge of the Constitution (one has to doubt that he has ever read it, and if he has, he certainly has not the slightest knowledge of what it does and does not provide for presidential dictatorship.). And once again, he reveals the fundamental racism that is at the core of his being.

As the impeachment process proceeds, at the appropriate times and appropriate stages Trump has been provided with every privilege of the due process of law. For him to use the term which described a series of acts in which Southern blacks were provided with not a scrap of due process of law and were extra-judicially murdered in public, with their pictures being taken amidst "celebrating" crowds, to describe what is happening to him as "lynching", once again tells you everything you need to know about this racist, cruel, sociopathic, egomaniac of a man who, because of that descendant of the institution of slavery known as the Electoral College, somehow became President of the United States.

Rate It | View Ratings

Steven Jonas Social Media Pages: Facebook page url on login Profile not filled in       Twitter page url on login Profile not filled in       Linkedin page url on login Profile not filled in       Instagram page url on login Profile not filled in

Steven Jonas, MD, MPH, MS is a Professor Emeritus of Preventive Medicine at StonyBrookMedicine (NY). As well as having been a regular political columnist on several national websites for over 20 years, he is the author/co-author/editor/co-editor of 37 books Currently, on the columns side, in addition to his position on OpEdNews as a Trusted Author, he is a regular contributor to From The G-Man.  In the past he has been a contributor to, among other publications, The Greanville PostThe Planetary Movement, and  He was also a triathlete for 37 seasons, doing over 250 multi-sport races.  Among his 37 books (from the late 1970s, mainly in the health, sports, and health care organization fields) are, on politics: The 15% Solution: How the Republican Religious Right Took Control of the U.S., 1981-2022; A Futuristic Novel (originally published 1996; the 3rd version was published by Trepper & Katz Impact Books, Punto Press Publishing, 2013, Brewster, NY, sadly beginning to come true, advertised on OpEdNews and available on  (more...)

Go To Commenting
The views expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.
Writers Guidelines

Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
Support OpEdNews

OpEdNews depends upon can't survive without your help.

If you value this article and the work of OpEdNews, please either Donate or Purchase a premium membership.

If you've enjoyed this, sign up for our daily or weekly newsletter to get lots of great progressive content.
Daily Weekly     OpEd News Newsletter
   (Opens new browser window)

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Pope Francis and Change in the Roman Catholic Church

Limbaugh, Santorum, Sex, and the Origins of the Roman Catholic Church

The "Irrepressible Conflict" and the Coming Second Civil War

Gay Marriage and the Constitution

The Republican Party and the Separation of Church and State: Change Does Happen

What the Gunners Want: What's in Rick Perry's Pocket, Unlimited

To View Comments or Join the Conversation:

Tell A Friend