Note: This story ran on the Huffington Post a few days ago. It basically died. Until yesterday, that is, when anonymous emails and tips started dribbling in. There might be something here—or not. Some enterprising OEN writers might want to tackle this. As predicted, the Echomusic client list went down after the HuffPo article ran. Whenever stuff starts to disappear, it makes you wonder why.
Fans of up to 200 mid-level artists and lower tier musicians hosted by Echomusic who went to check out touring schedules on their websites in the last few days may have found a darkened site or just a note that the site was under reconstruction. What happened? In a move that is under-reported in comparison to the recent MySpace Layoff of 400 employees, Ticketmaster-owned Echomusic, Nashville, dumped a whole bunch of artists with 30 days notice, took their content, and in effect cast them into the netherworld of cached pages and lost content. When Ticketmaster exercises this much control over an already-stressed and collapsing music industry without giving artists the ability to move their content seamlessly, well it is just bad behavior. The lawyers will have to sort out whether it is more.
Kudos should go to the String Theory Media blog for breaking the Echo Music story. It appears that a full fledged investigation should take place, given this analysis:
Indirectly, it's Irving Azoff's doing. Briefly, Azoff, one of the most powerful and wealthy managers in the history of rock (the Eagles are among his clients), recently presided over the merger of his company Front Line Management Group with Ticketmaster. Simultaneously, Ticketmaster has announced plans to merge with Live Nation, the concert promoter formerly known as Clear Channel's market-dominating SFX. In other words, Azoff is about to assume corporate control over the management of most of the biggest-grossing musicians in pop music, most of the venues in the U.S, and the titan of ticketing, the much loathed Ticketmaster. And for those who haven't been following Nashville music business news at all, echo was bought out by Ticketmaster in 2007 for a reported $25 million.
The little guys will be hurt big by this. I know. I do web design (don't contact me for help--it is a labor of love) and maintenance for some friends in the biz as a hobby. Even if you volunteer, it is expensive and time-consuming. The artists caught in this mess (no one I know) have lost not only their start-up costs of up to $10,000, but also content and contacts--and we all know the email contacts and personal information garnered by websites are priceless. But, it gets worse, according to String Theory:
Furthermore, it was hard not to notice that while echo the local start-up of the late 1990s was a refuge and service provider for many independent, non-star-trajectory artists, the echo of recent years (especially post Ticketmaster) focused on big-time clients like Rascal Flatts, Kanye West and Alicia Keys. In a triumph of inequity, some 20-30 of Echo's largest clients are slated to remain in the echo system, managed from Los Angeles. Insiders say that it goes even deeper than that; when recent mega-clients signed on to echo, at least some had the $20-30,000 fees for their web design and setup waived in exchange for an ongoing share of revenue generated through ticket and merchandise sales. This arrangement, according to sources, was not afforded to mid-level clients, who paid cash up front.
I don't know. There oughtta be a law....this used to be called consumer fraud.
Before it disappears from the web, here are some of the client orders for Echomusic (I do have a screenshot).
My suggestion? Artists should embrace Facebook and get their fans to work their websites. At least the fans care.