On Tuesday January 25, at the same moment Congress gathered for the
State of the Union address from Barack Obama, almost a hundred
people gathered to discuss "Torture, Guantanamo and Accountability" at
DePaul University Law School in Chicago.
It's been difficult over the last 2+ years to fill a room for such a
discussion, so we were heartened by the participation of 40 law
students and attorneys. Dr. M. Cherif Bassiouni, a distinguished
research professor emeritus at the law school, and founder of the International Human Rights Law Institute
; and Candace Gorman
, who represents two men imprisoned at Guantanamo, spoke with me on the panel.
Dr. Bassiouni described the "chasm" between the promises made by
Obama while campaigning and the actions of Obama as president, regarding
the rule of law as represented by the United States. Candace told the
story of one of her clients, still in Guantanamo. He is apparently one
of the 48 who will be detained indefinitely, bringing some of the
students to tears of frustration. We'll have more on the program soon.
Listen to Dr. Bassiouni and Ms. Gorman in an excellent hour-long discussion
on Chicago public radio WBEZ.
This year the President's bitter surprise for the prisoners
(which has encouraged a widespread peaceful protest at the prison, as reported here) was two-fold. The first was his failure to veto a military spending bill
passed by Congress, which contained cynical and unconstitutional
provisions preventing the transfer of any prisoner to the US mainland,
in which lawmakers also demanded the power to prevent the release of
prisoners to countries regarded as dangerous"
The second bitter surprise for the prisoners was the announcement last week, first mentioned by the New York Times,
that, although federal court trials have effectively been suspended,
specifically derailing the administration's stated intention to prosecute Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four other men
accused of involvement in the 9/11 attacks in federal court, the
administration is preparing to push ahead instead with trials by
Military Commission for at least some of the 33 men recommended for
trials by Obama's Task Force.
No, none of those plans were part of the State of the Union
address. Those of you listening for "real change" in Obama's direction
on the wars Tuesday night were disappointed. Rocky Anderson, former
mayor of Salt Lake City, and an opponent of torture, spoke on Democracy Now
January 26 about the speech:
"He didn't mention human rights at a time when he has assassination
lists for the first time in our nation's history, that include U.S.
citizens. No due process--we don't just have indefinite detention
anymore; we just go out, put their name on a list, and kill them. The
invocation of state secrets, it's absolutely obliterated any notion of
checks and balances. Our courts have been removed from that equation, by
and large, when it comes to torture, when it comes to warrantless
wiretapping by our government. No discussion about that, of course. And
we're seeing, really, an institutionalization by this president of some
of the worst abuses and what we, a lot of us, thought were just
aberrations during the Bush years."
I'd like to note what Obama did say:
""because we've begun this work, tonight we can say that
American leadership has been renewed and America's standing has been
restored. Look to Iraq, where nearly 100,000 of our brave men and women
have left with their heads held high. (Applause.) American combat
patrols have ended, violence is down, and a new government has been
formed. This year, our civilians will forge a lasting partnership with
the Iraqi people, while we finish the job of bringing our troops out of
Iraq. America's commitment has been kept. The Iraq war is coming to an
"We've also taken the fight to al Qaeda and their allies
abroad. In Afghanistan, our troops have taken Taliban strongholds and
trained Afghan security forces. Our purpose is clear: By preventing the
Taliban from reestablishing a stranglehold over the Afghan people, we
will deny al Qaeda the safe haven that served as a launching pad for
Thanks to our heroic troops and civilians, fewer Afghans are
under the control of the insurgency. There will be tough fighting ahead,
and the Afghan government will need to deliver better governance. But
we are strengthening the capacity of the Afghan people and building an
enduring partnership with them. This year, we will work with nearly 50
countries to begin a transition to an Afghan lead. And this July, we
will begin to bring our troops home. (Applause.)"
Last I heard, the Defense Department is balking at even a 2014 pull
out date of Afghanistan. The unjust, immoral, illegitimate occupations continue, and with them, the "war on terror" against civilians across
the region. It's up to us to bring out that reality to people.
I saw John Boehner pinch up his face when Obama obliquely mentioned
the repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." As much as the reactionaries
howled against letting gays be out in the military, I have to say that
any gay person who actually decides now to enlist has lost their mind.
Just because one can now serve openly does not mean the whole enterprise
of occupying countries and killing civilians should involve you! I
say, "don't ask, don't tell".no -- DON'T GO!" It's a bad thing, as
several professors have written me, that because DODT is being repealed,
colleges are now planning to open the doors once again to military
I'll see you in Washington D.C. on March 17-19 as we step up the visible protest on the anniversary of the Iraq war.
|The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author
and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.