[10th entry in the "Press the Battle" series.]
Summary: From the perspective of the evolution of life, it can be seen how value is an emergent -- but none the less real -- dimension of the reality of creatures like us humans. Evolution operates on the principle that life is better than death. Operating on that basis, evolution brings into existence creatures who experience that fulfillment is better than misery. That is the foundation of value. and it makes value fully real in every way it could be.
Previously, I asserted that:
- 1) the imbalance in intensity in the political battle raging in America is largely due to the deficiency of moral and spiritual passion in Liberal America,
2) this deficiency is the by-product of the worldview that is strong in Liberal America, according to which "value" is considered a matter of subjective opinion, and thus not really real, and there can be no such thing in the human world as "the battle between good and evil," and
3) it is a mistake to believe that intellectually responsible thinking about the evidence of our world requires that we reach those conclusions.
In other words, the path of evidence and reason can provide us good answers to those vital questions of value -- answers that can connect us to those deep parts of our human core from which comes the passionate intensity required for this urgent battle.
Specifically, a naturalistic perspective can show us: 1) The reality of value; and 2) the reality of forces, operating in the human system, whose characteristics warrant their being called "good" and "evil," and a dynamic in which these two forces contend in a battle to shape the destiny of human systems.
In this entry, I will discuss the first of these. The second will come subsequently.
THE REALITY OF VALUE
Having discussed questions of meaning and value with Liberal America for more than twenty years -- on the radio, on the web, and with groups in person -- I've encountered first-hand the various beliefs that make "value judgments" suspect. It is routinely said that value is a matter of opinion. That it's all just "subjective." That value is just a social construct. Etc.
All these sorts of beliefs have the effect of leading people to take their own values, their sense of right and wrong, of good and evil, less seriously. They all have had the effect of weakening people's response to a destructive force, as in America today, when they confront it.
This way of thinking about value, I will argue, is fundamentally flawed. The notion that value has to be "out there" makes no sense. And the dichotomy between our subjective feelings and the objective world has been overdrawn because of a lack of understanding of how our own natures evolved in relation to the world around us.