Dear Doctor Dean,
I have long wished for a way that I could express my
deep disappointment and disapproval of the way the Democratic Party has
been drifting. Then last week I read in a letter from Steve Bhaerman
something that made me take heart: the Empty Envelope Campaign is such
a venue for giving expression to my thoughts and feelings.
Suffice it to say that I heartily concur with everything Steve has said
to you concerning the failure of the Democratic party to represent and
protect freedom in this country. To express that, I am sending no
"financial" political contribution in this envelope. My money will go
to the people and groups who are representing my beliefs and attempting
to care for my needs. This is a desperate attempt to get your attention
and turn you around and jar you into reality. It is sad that our party
has sunk to that level.
Port Townsend, WA
I also got a few letters saying I was taking aim at the wrong target in Dr. Dean, that he is trying to support rebuilding the grassroots of the Democratic Party as opposed to the "corporate" Democrats in the DLC and DCCC. One of the letters is from Miles Kurland, president of Sonoma County Democracy for America. Miles -- along with respected "un-commontator" Thom Hartmann -- believes there is indeed a battle going on for the heart and soul of the Democratic Party, and the battle is between corporate and grassroots. Miles explains why he thinks Howard Dean, despite all external evidence, is with the latter. I am reprinting Miles' heartfelt, articulate (and long) letter below so that you can take his perspective into consideration and act accordingly.
Letter From Miles Kurland:
Im sorry for the length of this reply, but I didnt have enough time to write a shorter one...
I understand the sentiment you express: I am frustrated beyond the limits of my patience with the reticence of elected Democrats to stand up in opposition to the Bush administration and congressional Republicans. Do not make the mistake of thinking that I am a Democratic activist because I am pleased with the Democratic party: just the opposite is the case. I want my party back.
In terms of the DCCC & DSCC, Im easily as outraged as you. Im president of Sonoma County Democracy for America, and I know DFA people in Illinois who were working their butts off on the Christine Cegelis campaign. Im outraged that when there is an excellent candidate like Christine Cegelis on the ground that the DCCC steps in against the interests of the local party activists. We see the same thing in Californias 11th CD with Jerry McNerney who is being challenged by DCCC-backed Steve Filson. Both Cegelis and McNearny were among a few Dean Dozen candidates in 2004 by DFA when Howard Dean still headed the organization.
No, you dont have to tell me to be angry about that. Or concerned. These are examples of a centralized party thats burning its activist base. These are cases where insurgent, grassroots candidates were shunted aside by someone that the DC insiders assured us would be a more electable veteran. Where have we seen this before? Its not news to the grassroots activists working within DFA who remember when it meant Dean for America.
And then theres the story of one veteran who showed real promise as a rising star in the Democratic party, Paul Hackett: squashed by the DSCC. The people of Ohio deserved a primary to choose between Hackett and Sherrod Brown but were denied that by inside party dealing.
But the inspiring part of the Cegelis story, which you left out in your message, is that despite the fact that Tammy Duckworths campaign outspent Cegelis something like 6 or 7 to 1... and despite the fact that she had Kerry and Hillary and Obama fundraising and stumping for her... and despite the fact that the DC insiders predicted a landslide over Cegelis, who they regarded as a weak candidate, Duckworth only barely beat Cegelis by about 2 percent of the vote: 43% to 41%. Thats a pretty strong validation of the power of grassroots organization. If only the DC Democrats had put their faith and resources behind Cegelis and her local organizers in the general election... but instead they pissed off the activist base in Illinois which is inept and wrong.
So, yeah... a war is going on for the heart and soul of the party: I know because Im on the front lines. And the war is between those who want to control the party from the top... because they know whats best for the party (and lose elections), and the local activist base... may not presume to know whats best for the party, but do know whats best for their neighborhood.
The story of this is well told in Armstrong & Moulitsas new book Crashing the Gate. I highly recommend it. (Disclaimer: I also designed the jacket to that book. Having said that, the reason I designed the books jacket is because I agree with the books message, not vice versa.)
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).