I met Steve in his living room where his pencil drawings decorate one entire wall and his little dog, Tache, kept us company.
Steve: A mechanistic organization or a command-and-control organization isn't efficient or effective, at least in the medium term.
If you look closely at an autocratic organization like Home Depot that is currently being celebrated in Harvard Business Review and BusinessWeek as a best practice, you can already see the problems of staff morale that lead to poor customer service, that lead to a doomed business model.
The complaint about these approaches is not just that the folks at Home Depot are miserable BusinessWeek confirms that they are. The real problem is that while this approach can make some apparent short-run gains, it just doesn't work in the medium term.
Thus Home Depots stock price is below what it was in 2001, before the supposedly successful transformation. So Wall Street doesnt buy the transformation story. The fact is that the autocratic approach might have worked once upon a time, but it doesn't work in a sustainable way with the kinds of challenges faced by organizations and knowledge workers that we have in the early 21st Century.
So what's the alternative? In my view, it's a shift in the approach to leadership and management, a kind of change in the DNA of organizations, so that the default position of leaders in organizations is one of collaboration and interaction with all stakeholders, and so that command-and-control and mechanistic management is universally seen as an anomaly, an aberration, an exception to be used only in very unusual circumstances, if at all.
Seth: Command and control makes it difficult.
Steve: The problem is that command-and-control kills passion. In terms of a global movement, a network is much more powerful than an organization.
Steve: An organization can be wiped out. But a network of believers is almost indestructible.
Seth: Will that network just be people inside the organization?
Steve: No. For example, I contributed to and became part of a global network of people who were interested in knowledge. The World Bank got swept up in that.
What we want to do is change the DNA of organizations. Organizations now automatically shift into command-and-control. We want to change that DNA so that command-and-control is seen as an anomaly, not the norm. Collaboration should be the default. Command-and-control should be a rare technique that you use in times of crisis when all hell has broken loose and the ship is about to founder, but all other times youre in a collaborative mode.
Seth: And you do that is through storytelling
Steve: And networks. An organization cant change the DNA. Its through the networks that people collectively realize, There is a better way. All our futures depend on making a shift. At the time it probably wont even feel like a shift. It will just seem obvious. Who could have thought of anything else?
This will happen when people have effective tools to make collaboration work. The reason that the collaborative approach doesnt get the recognition it deserves is that people dont have usable tools.
You have to get down to a finer level of granularity, more specificity what do you do Monday morning if you want collaboration? What does it look and feel like? How do you actually make it happen?
Im starting to map the different ways of getting peoples attention. Im looking at the different ways you stimulate people to want something different. Thats where story really comes to the fore. Story is almost the only way you can get people to really believe in a different kind of future and start wanting something different.
There are twelve different types of stories that work to build a collaborative approach, to create high-performance teams. I will be speaking about them at the Smithsonian this April. They can also be found in Chapter 7 of The Leaders Guide to Storytelling.
Steve Denning hosts The World's Premier Organizational Storytelling Event: Smithsonian Storytelling Weekend April 21-22 2006 Washington, DC. Visit www.SteveDenning.com to learn more & register