Send a Tweet
Most Popular Choices
Share on Facebook 47 Share on Twitter Printer Friendly Page More Sharing
Life Arts    H4'ed 3/1/12


By       (Page 1 of 1 pages)   5 comments
Message robert wolff
Become a Fan
  (30 fans)

When  I watch or read news about what is going on in our world, I am struck by the disconnect between what politicians say and what they do. All polls make it abundantly clear that Americans are concerned about jobs, jobs, jobs. But "news" must be about numbers and/or disasters, the Media yell about the numbers of unemployed and then go on to the tornadoes, warm winters, hot summers, while sowing doubt about global warming.. 

Unemployment, and underemployment, is of course about jobs, about earning enough money to pay for food, transportation, mortgage, debts. But it has another meaning as well. In our culture when you get fired the message is "we don't need you any more. Your work does not have enough value to keep you on." In modern American we don't use the word "worth" except for things; the worth of a gold coin. We don't associate worth with people. A Samoan man used it when he said  "You first palangi tell some we is worth" His English was limited--do I need to add that I knew no Samoan--but the meaning was all too clear: You are the first white person who has ever told us that we have worth.  He had spent the day walking me around the tiny island, far from civilization, introducing me to people who knew healing. I had spent years in travels to many islands searching for remembered shreds of what some call "native healing" and here was an island so isolated that it still had people who had that knowledge. 

His parting words shocked me because it is all too true that we rarely if ever acknowledge a person's, or a culture's, worth. We judge worth by how famous she is, how much money he makes. The extreme inequality created in the last twenty, thirty, years between the hyper rich and the rest of us has given us the idea that worth is measured in money. Money is power; power is worth.

Of course our worth is also what we do well, talent, education, skills. But that is not what the Samoan man meant. He meant something more basic, our worth as humans. The worth we too often deny to people who we see as other.

In a hierarchical society with our wealth and power (and a shockingly wasteful life style) we see others as less, below us and so having less worth. For instance, we expect everybody in the world to understand American English. Many Americans feel superior to recent immigrants, assuming that "of course" we are not fully equal. The Media are convinced that "ordinary people" cannot understand complexities so they must simplify all issues to one sentence. Some, perhaps many, educated people talk down to those they assume know nothing. The one percent does not even see us. I hear the politicians who yell their wildly exaggerated ideas so that the populace will get their sincerity not needing to understand the consequences of their ideas if they were to be practiced. 

It is how we have designed our societyI a layered pyramid. We the People at the bottom, the one percent on top; politicians right under the top. We are even told that the wealthy few will generously leak a few dollars down. Nationwide unemployment emphasizes the layers. The statistics--an unemployment rate of eight point something--does not count the people who may have some work but part time or it does not pay enough to live on, as well as people who have given up. In fact a stunning number of people is very marginally "employed." They have work now and then, but where a few years ago they got paid $45 an hour, forty hours a week, now they must accept a job that paus $20, and then the work giver will try to get him or her to work for $15. Even if that were 40 hours a week--it isn't-- that is not a living wage. 

On the national stage the vicious arguing about what to do about the economy ignores the effect of having no job. Unemployment and underemployment has other, maybe more serious, effects than the loss of income. It is also a loss of worth in a society where worth is counted in dollars. I see it in young people but particularly in older people, who feel thrown away, worthless. And that stays. It is a very real PTSD. 

Yesterday I watched again one of my bookmarked short movies: talks= robert_neuwirth_on_our_shadow_cities.html= >   One billion people (maybe two billion by now) live in shadow cities, slum cities; in Brazil called Favela. A million people living in cardboard shacks, six or more to a tiny space. No bathrooms, no government support or rules. But a close community, extremely creative. One sentence in the movie thundered in my mind: Nobody is unemployed, everybody works. From the context it is clear that does not mean jobs, working for someone, for a company, five days a week. Everybody works means everybody does whatever s/he has to do to survive. Doing whatever it takes to eat, to have shelter, to raise children, to live. That is what worth is.

I don't know whether the economy can grow again, or even whether it is supposed to. I know that eternal growth is a myth; nothing can grow forever. For many thousands of years we survived without what we call "work." We did what we had to do to live, to eat, to make love, save the species, to talk story as we say in Hawai'i. We know how to recover from disasters, cleaning up the mess, finding something to eat, maybe moving on to the next valley. We know how to survive, that is our worth.

Today we find ourselves stuck in a crumbling empire on a warming planet. We are drowning in frantic speeches about going back to a growing economy that may provide "jobs" for some or perhaps more than some. In the real reality our worth, the ability to survive, is immensely more important than money. Survival requires a community. Survival is always WE. People cannot be dismissed. If society is so structured that it takes away our worth we ourselves must recover our own and our neighbor's worth. Isn't that what the Arab Spring, the Occupy movement, is about: to  regain our worth from a system that has demeaned us by measuring our worth in money. The outlandish theories politicians dream up and the media feeds us ignore who we are. Our true nature is not being followers, swept along by emotional orators. Our true worth is our joyful ability to survive. Slaves have that worth, people living on small islands have that worth. The billions of the shadow mega-cities have that worth. It is in all of us.

Well Said 2   Supported 2   Must Read 1  
Rate It | View Ratings

Robert Wolff Social Media Pages: Facebook page url on login Profile not filled in       Twitter page url on login Profile not filled in       Linkedin page url on login Profile not filled in       Instagram page url on login Profile not filled in

robert wolff lived on the Big Island, called Hawai'i

his website is He passed away in late 2015. He was born in 1925, was Dutch, spoke, Dutch, Malay, English and spent time living and getting to know Malaysian Aborigines. He authored numerous books including What it Is To Be Human, (more...)

Go To Commenting
The views expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.
Writers Guidelines

Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
Support OpEdNews

OpEdNews depends upon can't survive without your help.

If you value this article and the work of OpEdNews, please either Donate or Purchase a premium membership.

If you've enjoyed this, sign up for our daily or weekly newsletter to get lots of great progressive content.
Daily Weekly     OpEd News Newsletter
   (Opens new browser window)

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Have We Lost Our Humanity?


Have We Lost Our Humanity?

Is there an alternative to constant economic growth?

Strange, very strange, dangerously strange

Money - and why we must learn to do without

To View Comments or Join the Conversation:

Tell A Friend