From Paul Craig Roberts Website
Why economists got Russian sanctions wrong
(Image by YouTube, Channel: CNBC International) Details DMCA
This week I was interviewed on Russian TV about the possible new anti-Russian sanctions that Washington is considering that would prohibit anyone in the entirety of the world from holding Russian government bonds. Think about this for a moment. Washington thinks that Washington has the right and the power to block sovereign countries and their citizens from investing in Russian government bonds. Here we face arrogance that has developed into insanity.
The Russian bonds are an excellent investment. Unlike US, EU, UK, and Japanese government bonds, the Russian bonds pay good interest rates, and Russia has virtually no national debt, unlike the heavily indebted governments of the US, Europe, UK, and Japan.
Moreover, the Russian ruble is protected by immense energy resources on which Europe and China are dependent. The only way the ruble can be driven down is by orchestrated short-selling by Western and Japanese central banks. These central banks can print and waste all the money that they care to. A Western central bank is even less accountable than a Western government.
The Soviet government had more sense than to allow the ruble to be traded on markets that the West can manipulate, but the Russian government, brainwashed as it is by American neoliberal economists, lacks the understanding of the Soviet government.
All of Washington's economic threats to Russia are designed to force the Russian government into accepting vassal status, like all of Europe, Canada, Australia, and Japan. The threats can only work because the Russian government and the Economics Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences have ignored the lessons that Michael Hudson and I taught them. See here, here and here.
Here is how Washington's current effort to destroy Russia's confidence is being played. First Washington announces that it is considering banning everyone in the world from buying a Russian government bond. Citibank, regarded by many as a criminal organization totally dependent on Federal Reserve subsidies, puts out a fabricated "analysis" that, to quote from Bloomberg, would cause the ruble to "plunge by as much as 15 percent and borrowing costs would spike to a three-year high if the U.S. goes ahead with proposals to impose sanctions on Russian government bonds, according to a new model developed by Citigroup Inc." Citi analysts Ivan Tchakarov and Artem Zaigrin said: "The additional capital outflows generated by this event could ultimately weaken the ruble."
This is abject nonsense. If Washington is able to force its vassals to dispossess themselves of a good investment, only Russian brainwashing by neoliberal economics can permit the scheme to work.
If, on the other hand, the Russians would like to free themselves of their neoliberal economic brainwashing, all the Russian central bank needs to do is to buy the Russian bonds that Washington forces its vassals to sell. This is precisely what the US, UK, EU, and Japanese banks have been doing for a decade -- purchasing their own bonds (and stocks) -- thus driving up the price. This is how zero/negative interest rates in the Western alliance have been achieved.
Some time ago Michael Hudson and I pointed out to the Russian government and central bank that the utterly false belief that rules Russia that Russia's development is dependent on foreign loans and selling valuable Russian assets to foreigners for foreign exchange is totally false. The Russian government is trapped in a mindset engineered by Washington.
Hudson and I pointed out in terms that could not be clearer that when Russia borrows abroad for a development plan, the dollars are not spent inside the Russian economy. The borrowed dollars (or UK pounds, EU euros, Japanese yen) go into the central banks' foreign reserve holdings. The central bank then prints the ruble equivalent to finance the development project.
It is clear as day to anyone not brainwashed by American neoliberal economists, who are agents of Washington, that there is no point whatsoever in Russia's foreign borrowing. The Russian central bank can create the rubles to finance Russian development projects independently of borrowing from abroad. All borrowing from abroad does is to enlarge Russia's foreign debt, thereby making Russia more susceptible to Washington's sanctions.
As long as Russia remains in the neoliberal mindset, the American neoconservatives, whose goal is to destroy Russia, can relax. Neoliberal economics will do the job for them.