Send a Tweet
Most Popular Choices
Share on Facebook 1 Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Reddit Tell A Friend Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites
OpEdNews Op Eds

Sonia Sotomayor's Epic Dissent Explains What's at Stake When the Police Don't Follow the Law

By   Follow Me on Twitter     Message John Nichols       (Page 1 of 2 pages)     Permalink    (# of views)   2 comments

Related Topic(s): ; ; ; , Add Tags
Add to My Group(s)

Funny 1  
View Ratings | Rate It

opednews.com Headlined to H2 6/21/16

Author 29155
Become a Fan
  (23 fans)

Reprinted from The Nation

- Advertisement -
In an opinion that cited Michelle Alexander and Ta-Nehisi Coates, Justice Sotomayor railed against the gutting of the Fourth Amendment.


(Image by Cknight70)   Details   DMCA

The US Supreme Court just made a deeply flawed, and profoundly unsettling, decision that upsets historic protections against using evidence obtained in illegal searches to convict Americans of wrongdoing.

The decision, announced Monday, reinstates the particular convictions of a Utah man who was tried on drug charges. But this is about much more than one case. The Court's 5-3 determination effectively signals that police officers do not themselves have to follow the letter of the law when they are enforcing the law. The calculus, argued dissenting Justice Elena Kagan, "practically invites" police to illegally stop Americans who are not acting suspiciously.

- Advertisement -

That was fine by a Court majority that included Chief Justice John Roberts, conservative Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Anthony Kennedy, and moderately liberal Justice Stephen Breyer. Justice Thomas wrote in a convoluted majority opinion that evidence gathered in an illegal search could be used to arrest and convict the target of the search because the Court majority did not find indications of "flagrantly unlawful police misconduct" in an unconstitutional stop in Salt Lake City parking lot, and because the officer eventually learned of an outstanding warrant against the man who was targeted.

The majority ruling so unsettled Justice Sonia Sotomayor that she wrote a scathing dissent, which spoke with the fury of the classic dissents of Justice Louis Brandeis and Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. that almost a century ago helped to frame our modern understanding of basic liberties. The dissents of Justices Brandeis and Holmes laid the groundwork for later decisions by more enlightened Court majorities.

In her remarkable dissent, Justice Sotomayor found herself raging against the dying of the more enlightened approach that the Court had long accepted as a necessary defense of civil liberties. "The Court today holds that the discovery of a warrant for an unpaid parking ticket will forgive a police officer's violation of your Fourth Amendment rights," wrote Justice Sotomayor.

- Advertisement -

Click Here to Read Whole Article

- Advertisement -
   

Ad info: click here

Top Content
in the Last 2 Days
(by Page Views)

Sins of the Father are then visited upon the Sons: The Saga of the Aspartame-Rumsfeld Plague by Stephen Fox (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

What the Bernie Sanders 2020 Campaign Means for Progressives by Norman Solomon (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

The "Toxic Mythology" of 9/11 is Destroying Humanity by Mark Taliano (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Black History Month: Why African Americans Are Leading Fight for Environmental Justice by Robert Bullard (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Vital Strategic and Tactical Considerations to Ensure that Bernie Wins the Nomination and the Presidency by Stephen Fox (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Establishment Democrats malign Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and millennials at their peril by Egberto Willies (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

It's Official: Bernie Sanders Is Running For President by Ted Millar (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Journalists Had Better Hope I Win My Case Against the Billionaire-Owned L.A. Times by Ted Rall (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Great Again by Craig K. Comstock (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Frayed Colonial Media Propaganda Transmission Lines. Fake Atrocities Used to Justify "Humanitarian War Crimes" by Mark Taliano (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Can Bernie Sanders repeat his surprising success this time around? by Robert B. Reich (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Venezuela Under Washington's Gun by Paul Craig Roberts (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

The Real Emergency Isn't About the Wall. It's About the Separation of Powers. by Thomas Knapp (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

German defence minister: We will stay in Lithuania as long as WE want by Jonas Dringelis (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Sleepwalking into our Constitutional Crisis in the Age of Trump by Juan Cole (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Venezuelan Coup Democrats Vomit on Green New Deal by Patrick Walker (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

It's Back to the Iran-Contra Days Under Trump by Wayne Madsen (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Criminal insanity in DC is bipartisan: Washington's Stealthy Move Towards Nuclear War Against Russia and China by Dave Lindorff (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Tomgram: Stephanie Savell, U.S. Counterterror Missions Across the Planet by Tom Engelhardt (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Daily Inspiration — A way to organize human activity that is beyond our imagination by Josh Mitteldorf (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Worshipping the Electronic Image by Chris Hedges (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Hating Neocons Is Becoming Mainstream Again, And It Is Excellent by Caitlin Johnstone (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Are Homophobic Vatican Clerics Secretly Homosexual? by Thomas Farrell (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Celebrating Black History 2019: Analyzing Bob Marley by Michael Roberts (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Direct Democracy at Each Municipality by Roger Copple (With membership, you can see # of pageviews)

Go To Top 50 Most Popular

- Advertisement -
Classics of Liberal Thinking

Progressive Radio Links