Reprinted from http://www.corpwatch.org/article.php?id=15918
Shell's plans to drill for oil in the Arctic's Chukchi Sea have been
handed a major setback by a U.S appeals court which ruled that the
Department of the Interior had underestimated the potential environment
impact. The courts ordered the federal government to do a new
Judge William Fletcher of the 9th Circuit Court in
San Francisco ruled that the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)
estimate that Shell would only extract one billion barrels was far too
low. In the court opinion that Fletcher authored, he said that the
numbers were "arbitrary and capricious"
and ordered the agency to re-do the environmental analysis based "on
the full range of likely production if oil production were to occur."
The ruling came as a result of a January 2010 lawsuit brought by a coalition of native and environmental groups
after the U.S. government auctioned off millions of acres in the
Chukchi Sea to oil and gas development in 2008. Shell was awarded the
concession after bidding $2.6 billion.
"It makes no sense to open up the fragile, irreplaceable and already melting Arctic Ocean to risky drilling for dirty oil
that will only exacerbate climate change already wreaking havoc on the
Arctic and elsewhere," said Erik Grafe, an attorney at Earthjustice, an
environmental group that led the lawsuit.
included the Native Village of Point Hope, Inupiat Community of the
Arctic Slope, Alaska Wilderness League, Center for Biological Diversity,
Defenders of Wildlife, National Audubon Society, Natural Resources
Defense Council, Northern Alaska Environmental Center, Oceana, Pacific
Environment, Resisting Environmental Destruction on Indigenous Lands
(REDOIL), Sierra Club, The Wilderness Society and World Wildlife Fund.
Next Page 1 | 2
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).
CorpWatch: Non-profit investigative research and journalism to expose
corporate malfeasance and to advocate for multinational corporate
accountability and transparency. We work to foster global justice,
independent media activism and democratic control over corporations.
We seek to expose multinational corporations that profit from war,
fraud, environmental, human rights and other abuses, and to provide
critical information to foster a more informed public and an effective
Our guiding vision is to promote human, environmental, social and worker rights at the
local, national and global levels by making corporate practices more
transparent and holding corporations accountable for their actions.
independent investigative researchers and journalists, we provide critical information
to foster a more informed public and an effective democracy.
We believe the actions, decisions, and policies undertaken and
pursued by private corporations have very real impact on public life -
from individuals to communities around the world. Yet few mechanisms
currently exist to hold them accountable for those actions. As a result,
it falls to the public sphere to protect the public interest.
In many cases, corporate power and influence eclipses even the democratic
process itself as they exert disproportional influence on public policy
they deem detrimental to their narrow self-interests. In less developed
nations, they usurp authority altogether, often purchasing government
complicity for unfair practices at the expense of economic,
environmental, human, labor and social rights.
Yet despite the
very public impact of their actions and decisions, corporations remain
bound to be accountable solely to their own private financial
considerations and the interests of their shareholders. They have little
incentive, nor requirement, for public transparency regarding their
decisions and practices, let alone concrete accountability for their