(Article changed on March 15, 2013 at 04:48)
Incidentally, Francis of Assisi recently got good press in the NEW YORKER, an obviously famous secular magazine that is not famous for running favorable essays about Catholic saints.
As the media correctly reported, never before has a Jesuit been elected pope. Because I happen to be a former Jesuit seminarian, a friend asked me what the arguments pro and con are regarding having a Jesuit serve as the pope.
The major con argument is that the election of Pope Francis establishes a precedent for other Jesuits to serve as the pope in the future. Because I see the monarchical aura of the papacy in recent centuries as a serious problem, I see this already serious problem as being compounded by allowing even one Jesuit to serve as pope. The prospect of having more Jesuits serve as pope in the future is not a pleasant prospect for me to consider.
As to the pro argument about having a Jesuit pope, I would say that it is probably safe to say that no Jesuit who could ever be elected pope would turn out to be a cowboy pope -- as George W. Bush turned out to be a cowboy president. If it moves, cowboys want to kill it. But the new Pope Francis will probably practice non-violence himself.
In the book MEN ASTUTELY TRAINED: A HISTORY OF THE JESUITS IN THE AMERICAN CENTURY (1992), Peter McDonough, himself a former Jesuit, calls attention to Jesuit training in his apt title.
Young Jorge Bergoglio may have been a cowboy in spirit when he entered the Jesuit two-year novitiate. But as McDonough's apt title suggests, Jesuit training is astutely designed to take the cowboy spirit out of the man.
Do you remember how King Odysseus went around
The Jungian theorist Robert L. Moore of Chicago Theological Seminary has described Jesuit training as warrior training. He means that Jesuit training is astutely designed to help Jesuits in training to learn how to access the Warrior archetype in the archetypal level of their psyches. Based on my own experience of Jesuit training, I agree with
Digression: Robert Moore and Douglas Gillette discuss the Warrior archetype in their book THE WARRIOR WITHIN: ACCESSING THE KNIGHT [ARCHETYPE] IN THE MALE PSYCHE (1992). Moore and Gillette claim that girls and women also have a Warrior archetype in the archetypal level of their psyches. End of digression.
Now, if you are not interested in entering the Jesuit novitiate, you may be wondering what benefits might come from warrior training involving the Warrior archetype.
I would say that the Warrior archetype is involved in all those work and play situations in life wherein we experience flow, as Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi discusses flow in his book FLOW: THE PSYCHOLOGY OF OPTIMAL EXPERIENCE (1990).
As a matter of fact, his wife Isabella Selega Csikszentmihalyi has published an essay about the early Jesuits and flow: "Flow in historical context: the case of the Jesuits" in the book OPTIMAL EXPERIENCE: PSYCHOLOGICAL STUDIES OF FLOW IN CONSCIOUSNESS, co-edited by husband and wife (1988, pages 232-248).
Through Jesuit training, most Jesuits today learn how to make their work seem like play. That's how well disciplined most Jesuits are as the result of being astutely trained.
Let's review. The papacy in recent centuries has taken on a monarchical aura, which I see as a problem.