Send a Tweet
Most Popular Choices
Share on Facebook 2 Share on Twitter Printer Friendly Page More Sharing
OpEdNews Op Eds    H3'ed 6/17/14

Instant Runoff or Approval?

By       (Page 1 of 1 pages)     (# of views)   3 comments, 2 series
Author 1890
Message Paul Cohen
Voting is the Issue
Voting is the Issue
(Image by Joybot)
  Details   DMCA

Earlier in this series of articles we discussed Instant Runoff Voting as well as Approval Voting and we showed how each of these voting systems could be improved by making them balanced. But only very superficially did we try to compare the two different approaches to voting. Each has its proponents and we are not apt to settle the dispute here, but we will suggest how the dispute might be settled. The Center for Election Science favors AV whereas The Center for Voting and Democracy prefers IRV.

The AV supporters observe (in comparing AV to FCV) that collecting more information from voters will result in better election outcomes. It might seem odd that that this claim would come from the AV camp because it seems to give an edge to IRV over AV; IRV does gather more information from voters.

However, more information is beneficial only if it is accurate. IRV asks voters to construct an ordered list of the candidates they favor and the order is critical for how the votes are counted. A moments reflection should reveal that voters will not always find that order easy to construct and some will perhaps resort to what amounts to a flip of a coin to determine who, for example, should be in third and who should be in fourth place. The extra information that is collected for IRV would seem to include more than a bit of noise and that noise has a potential for producing erroneous outcomes.

The information collected for AV is, except for the order details, exactly what is collected for IRV and this suggests an avenue for comparing the two voting systems. Some elections are conducted using IRV and it would be quite possible to re-count these ballots to determine how an AV election would have turned out. If the results differ, an after-election poll could measure how well satisfied the voters might be with the two different outcomes. Of course this experiment would have to be repeated over many elections for results to be meaningful.

My own view is that BAV (described in an earlier article) is clearly an improvement over AV and that IRBV (described in another earlier article) is clearly an improvement over IRV. Moreover, IRBV collects some potentially noisy data in addition to what BAV collects. If IRBV elections were conducted somewhere, the same kind of analysis of the results could be used to help determine whether IRBV or BAV might be the one to prefer.

 

Rate It | View Ratings

Paul Cohen Social Media Pages: Facebook page url on login Profile not filled in       Twitter page url on login Profile not filled in       Linkedin page url on login Profile not filled in       Instagram page url on login Profile not filled in

A concerned citizen and former mathematician/engineer now retired and living in rural Maine.
Go To Commenting
The views expressed herein are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.
Writers Guidelines
Contact AuthorContact Author Contact EditorContact Editor Author PageView Authors' Articles
Support OpEdNews

OpEdNews depends upon can't survive without your help.

If you value this article and the work of OpEdNews, please either Donate or Purchase a premium membership.

STAY IN THE KNOW
If you've enjoyed this, sign up for our daily or weekly newsletter to get lots of great progressive content.
Daily Weekly     OpEdNews Newsletter
Name
Email
   (Opens new browser window)
 
Series: "Balanced Voting"

Two Properties for Categorizing Voting Systems (Article) (# of views) 07/09/2019
A Voter's Quandry (Article) (# of views) 12/10/2018
Opposites (Article) (# of views) 10/20/2018
View All 37 Articles in "Balanced Voting"
Total Views for the Series: 34119   

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Who Pays Taxes?

Liberate Yourself from the Mainstream Media

Who Pays Taxes II

Conservatives Without Conscience

Rethinking Which Voting System is Best

Can Less be Better?