WikiLeaks has arranged for three pro-bono lawyers to assist Manning in his case. However, Manning must request they be allowed to see him. Since the Army will not inform Manning of their existence, he cannot ask for them to see him. Joseph Heller would love it, a perfect Catch 22.
As there is a tradition of antiwar soldiers, there is also a tradition that seeks to damn people like Manning and keep their views far from the American consciousness.
In recent memory, this tradition starts with the image of antiwar protesters spitting on returning soldiers from Vietnam, a right wing myth that arose during the Gulf War as part of the effort what George Bush Senior called "getting beyond the Vietnam Syndrome." That's the conclusion of Jerry Lembcke in The Spitting Image: Myth, Memory and the Legacy of Vietnam.
Lembcke looked and could find no evidence at all of spitting. Instead, he says, the image was part of a concerted effort to demonize the antiwar movement and, especially, to distract national attention away from the many instances of returning soldiers and veterans who sympathized with the antiwar movement during the Vietnam War.
Look up the documentary Sir! No Sir! to understand the fear the antiwar soldiers' movement sent into the hearts of our leaders as the Vietnam War derailed. The fact this significant movement is little known shows how effective things like the spitting myth have been.
Ever since the rise of the spitting image, and especially with the Iraq War beginning in 2003, the antiwar movement in America has walked on eggshells when it came to distinguishing the war it opposed from the soldiers sent to fight it.
"Support the troops, not the war" became the mantra. Sometimes the word "troops" is exchanged for "warrior," a term that calls up images of men hacking away at each other with swords and pikes.
In the film 300, the Spartans live a code of "Come back with your shield or on it." When wars begin to fail, this kind of classic Warrior Myth feeds into the first cousin of the Spitting Myth, the Stab In The Back Myth, which suggests that those questioning wars are, somehow, the reason for their failures.
The Stab In The Back Myth tends to appear as wars fall in popularity and begin to make no sense to many at home who pay for them and many who fight them. We are living in one of those times.
Senator John McCain now likes to say, at times like this "we cannot sound an uncertain trumpet." You can see it forming: Those whose trumpet is not certain in the months and years ahead will be blamed for the disaster that is our policy in Afghanistan.