No matter where you stand on health care, you can agree on two intractable facts:
a) our health system costs much more than similar care in similar countries and
b) our care is statistically no better (and sometimes worse) than their cheaper care.
To learn why, you have to follow the money, as always: who plants it? Who tends it? Who finally harvests it and how does it end up in their particular barns?
Everybody has a designated villain: the docs are greedy fat cats; the drug companies are greedier and egregious liars to boot; the hospitals are insanely expensive and their bill items have no relationship to real-world prices; the medical records departments still use quill pens and eye shades; the insurance parasites suck appalling sums into paper pushing and even more appalling sums into their profit columns.
Needless to say, each of these worthy establishments blames the collapse of our medical system on one or more of the others. Each defends its own charges with the same pious assertion: “We absolutely need [some say deserve] every penny that we screw you for.”
Are they telling the truth? Where do those trillions of pennies go? “Research,” say big druggies; “Quality of Care,” say the hospitals; “Med school debt and malpractice suits,” say the Hippocrates. As for the insurance giants, they wrap themselves in red-white-and-blue free market bromides and hum the National Anthem. But when asked to break these costs down, nobody speaks up. Nobody answers commonsense questions, like:
Pharmaceuticals, why do the same drugs from the same companies cost so much less in Canada?
Hospitals, why are cheap over-the-counter medications charged at ten bucks a pill?
Physicians, why should you be worth more than everyone except rock, sport, and film stars (those indispensible social contributors)?
Insurance behemoths, why does paper work cost so much and -- disregarding your contorted accounting methods -- how much profit do you really make?
Hmm; I thought I just heard a pin drop.
I’m no expert in economics or health care (I was an English major, which accounts for my life-long genteel poverty) but I found one specific line item on one actual hospital invoice and decided, what the hey; why not give it a hypothetical, as Texans like to say? The item was a CT scan and was charged at just around 7K, give or take. That’s Seven. Thousand. Dollars.
Lemme see now: CT labs work 24/7 because of ER crises and emergencies among patients already hospitalized. Let’s say that a well-utilized facility averages ten scans a day. Move the decimal and you get 3,650 procedures per year at $7,000 a pop, or $2,555,000 per annum. (Move that decimal again to cover the, say, ten year life span of the equipment and the total charges come to $25.6 million.)
Where does all that good money go? A layman can only imagine:
Personnel: technicians to make scans and physician specialists to read them; nurses or orderlies to schlep the patients in and out; staff engineers to maintain the hardware; hospital cleaning, linen, and maintenance staff.