The Obama Administration should have anticipated the mid-term election disaster. They had ample warning but failed to take counter measures. If a similar result is to be avoided in 2012, if Obama is to prevail in the Presidential election, Democrats have to absorb four critical lessons.
There has to be a permanent campaign . In 1980, Democratic strategist and columnist Sidney Blumenthal observed we'd entered the era of the permanent political campaign. Republicans have learned this. Democrats haven't.
At the onset of the Obama Administration, Republicans began their campaign to win the mid-term elections by opposing every Presidential initiative. (In January of 2009, House Republicans unanimously voted against the stimulus package even though there was huge national support for it.) Obama did not appear to understand the dogmatic nature of Republican opposition. As a result he lost time, and allies, trying to obtain GOP support.
As a consequence of the President's indifference about politicking, the 2010 Democratic campaign was incoherent and uncoordinated. One seasoned political operative termed it "political malpractice."
Democrats have to control the message . E.J. Dionne continued, ""Politicking' is nothing less than the ongoing effort to convince free citizens of the merits of a set of ideas, policies and decisions. Voters feel better about politicians who put what they are doing in a compelling context." Republicans did this. Although experts such as George Lakoff and Drew Westen urged them to, Dems didn't.
The dominant 2010 Democratic message was, "Let's not go back to the Bush era." The subliminal content was: "We don't have anything positive to say."
The cornerstone message must be simple . At the core of the Democratic political context should be a single compelling idea.
The electorate's big concern is jobs. The Republicans had a simple response: "Lower taxes and fewer regulations create jobs." The Democratic response was "Trust us. We're not the Republicans."
The Obama Administration may have a straightforward plan that will fix the economy and create jobs, but no one outside the White House knows what it is.
Democrats must keep faith with their base. Just before the election, the NEW YORK TIMES ran a front-page article "Obama Coalition is Fraying, Poll Finds". Their poll reported that key groups, like White Women, were planning to vote for Republicans. If the reporters had dug deeper, they would have found a bigger story: the Obama Administration had managed to piss off their key supporters, both individuals and groups. This was the guts of the "enthusiasm gap;" Obama hadn't just lost White Women, he'd shortchanged them at best they felt disappointed, at worst betrayed.
In one progressive sector after another, the Obama Administration reneged on promises or gave up hard-earned progressive gains, all in the name of securing Republican votes that never materialized. It made many Democrats wonder if they could trust their President, their leader.
Searching for Superman? In addition to learning these four lessons, Democrats have to decide what to do about Barack Obama.