In 2008, a District of Columbia v. Heller Supreme Court amicus curiae submitted by 15 prominent academics and writers concluded as follows:
"Historians are often asked what the Founders would think about various aspects of contemporary life. Such questions can be tricky to answer."
"But as historians of the Revolutionary era we are confident at least of this: that the authors of the Second Amendment would be flabbergasted to learn that in endorsing the republican principle of a well-regulated militia, they were also precluding restrictions on such potentially dangerous property as firearms, which governments had always regulated when there was 'real danger of public injury from individuals.' "
Law Professor David C. Williams says Second Amendment interpretation reflects myths about America. The framers believed in unity, he said.
Modern interpreters endorse distrust and disunity, he believes. The Second Amendment guarantees individuals the right to bear arms only as part of a united and consensual people, he stresses.
Obtaining guns today is almost as easy as buying toothpaste. America's framers had no such intention in mind. Constitutional reinventionists decided they knew best.
Modern US culture is violent. Gun ownership bears much responsibility. Violent films are some of the most popular. So are similar video games and music. Lyrics glorify guns, rape and murder.
US society is called a "rape culture" for good reason. Sometime during their lives, one-fourth of adult women are victimized by forcible rape. Often it's by someone they know. Family members share guilt.
One in four women report being sexually molested in childhood. Repeat violations over extended periods are commonplace. Three-fourth of US women experience some form of extreme violence in their lifetimes.
Domestic violence is the leading cause of injury. It's the second leading cause of death. Guns play a leading role. Children, like adults, are harmed.
What kind of country facilitates endemic violence instead of acting responsibly to curb it? What kind of government endorses easy access to dangerous assault and other deadly weapons instead of prohibiting it?
Against this backdrop, no wonder massacres like Norwalk, CT, Virginia Tech, Columbine High School, Atlanta, GA stock trader killings, six by a lone Fort Worth gunman, 10 Washington, DC sniper shootings, a Carnation, WA Christmas eve massacre, Northern IL University killings, 13 more at Ft. Hood, the Tuscon, AR incident killing six and leaving Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords seriously wounded, as well as dozens more incidents too numerous to mention.
No wonder domestic violence is out-of-control. Lone gunmen incidents reflect ingrained values. So does America's history. It's notably harsh against dissidents, labor, minorities, street protesters, ethnic and religious groups, as well as others targeted.
Most one-on-one incidents pass without notice. US history is sanitized to forget what's too monstrous to remember. Native Americans were nearly slaughtered to extinction.
Black slaves endured whippings, other beatings, rapes, mutilations, forced family separations, and even amputations as punishment for runaways.