Share on Google Plus Share on Twitter 1 Share on Facebook 1 Share on LinkedIn Share on PInterest Share on Fark! Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Tell A Friend 1 (3 Shares)  
Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites View Stats   7 comments

OpEdNews Op Eds

Conservatives, Democrats and the convenience of denouncing free speech

By (about the author)     Permalink       (Page 1 of 3 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

Must Read 2   Well Said 2   Supported 1  
View Ratings | Rate It Headlined to H2 9/16/12

Become a Fan
  (121 fans)
- Advertisement -
Cross-posted from The Guardian

Westerners love to decry censorship aimed at them by Muslims while ignoring the extreme censorship they impose on them 

[Updated below]

Nothing tests one's intellectual honesty and ability to apply principles consistently more than free speech controversies. It is exceedingly easy to invoke free speech values in defense of political views you like. It is exceedingly difficult to invoke them in defense of views you loathe. But the true test for determining the authenticity of one's belief in free speech is whether one does the latter, not the former.

The anti-US protests sweeping the Muslim world have presented a perfect challenge to test the free speech convictions of both the American right and the Democratic party version of the left. Neither is faring particularly well.

Let's begin with the Democrats. On Thursday, the Obama White House called executives at Google, the parent company of YouTube, and "requested" that the company review whether the disgusting anti-Muslim film that has sparked such unrest should be removed on the ground that it violates YouTube's terms of service.

In response, free speech groups such as the ACLU and EFF expressed serious concerns about the White House's actions. While acknowledging that there was nothing legally compulsory about the White House's request (indeed, Google announced the next day they would leave the video up), the civil liberties groups nonetheless noted -- correctly -- that "it does make us nervous when the government throws its weight behind any requests for censorship," and that "by calling YouTube from the White House, they were sending a message no matter how much they say we don't want them to take it down; when the White House calls and asks you to review it, it sends a message and has a certain chilling effect."

Right-wing commenters loudly decried the White House's actions on free speech grounds. Some of their rhetoric was overblown (the sentiment behind the request was understandable, and they did nothing to compel its removal). But, for reasons made clear by the ACLU and EFF, these conservative objections were largely correct.

- Advertisement -

Click Here to Read Whole Article


- Advertisement -
Build a Community of Supporters

Ad info: click here

Top Content
in the Last 2 Days
(by Page Views)

Washington's Fifth Columns Inside Russia and China by Paul Craig Roberts (see # of pageviews)

Why is Bernie Sanders popular? by M. Martin Hine (see # of pageviews)

"If Not Capitalism, What?" Posted by James Quandy (see # of pageviews)

A Welcome To Our New VA Leadership by Pat Smith (see # of pageviews)

Dung Beetles: Pope Denounces Davos Dominionists by Chris Floyd (see # of pageviews)

The OSU Band Exemplifies Why Economists Err by Ignoring Corrupt Culture by William K. Black, J.D., Ph.D. (see # of pageviews)

A Haven From the Animal Holocaust by Chris Hedges (see # of pageviews)

Listen to WSJ's Bret Stephens Secretly Plot With "Pro-Israel" Evangelical Group Against Iran Deal by Glenn Greenwald (see # of pageviews)

The Water Crisis is Here by Sherwood Ross (see # of pageviews)

Roll Call Embarrasses Congress into Considering Whistleblower Protections for Its Staff by Marcy Wheeler (see # of pageviews)

Noam Chomsky: "Why You Can Not Have a Capitalist Democracy" by James Quandy (see # of pageviews)

The Revolt Against the Ruling Class by Robert Reich (see # of pageviews)

Decades of Climate Deception by Richmond Shreve (see # of pageviews)

Need New Olympic Committee by Suzana Megles (see # of pageviews)

No Class. No Compassion. No Brains. The "Take Us Seriously" Circus Mocks America and God by Rev. Dan Vojir (see # of pageviews)

Obama's Africa Hypocrisy by Margaret Kimberley (see # of pageviews)

$1000 a Pill? Yes Says Big Pharma. by Martha Rosenberg (see # of pageviews)

Bigger Thomas vs. Rove Dirty Tricks & Koch Heads by Marcello Rollando (see # of pageviews)

"Journalists" Agree to Keep Mum on Conservative Donors at Koch Brothers Event by Common Dreams (see # of pageviews)

Psychologist openly admits he trains police officers to shoot first and ask questions later by Daily Kos (see # of pageviews)

Lay Cecil the Lion to Rest on the White House Lawn by Marc Ash (see # of pageviews)

Halfway to Hell: Global Temperatures Hit Critical Point, Warn Scientists by EcoWatch (see # of pageviews)

Reshuffling Eurasia's energy deck -- Iran, China and Pipelineistan by Pepe Escobar (see # of pageviews)

Sorry, Hillary Clinton fans: her email errors are definitely newsworthy by Trevor Timm (see # of pageviews)

The Palestinian Bubble and the Burning of Toddler, Ali Dawabsha by Ramzy Baroud (see # of pageviews)

Go To Top 50 Most Popular

- Advertisement -

The Last War Crime movie
What if there was only one chance for justice?

- Advertisement -

Traces the pathway the Republican-Christian Alliance took, from historical reality to an all-too-predictable dystopic future What if there was only one chance for justice?

Classics of Liberal Thinking

Progressive Radio Links

- Advertisement -
Help us restore justice and free Don Siegelman