Share on Google Plus Share on Twitter Share on Facebook 2 Share on LinkedIn Share on PInterest Share on Fark! Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Tell A Friend (2 Shares)  
Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites View Stats   28 comments

Life Arts

The U.S. (in)Justice System Doesn't Work. The Alternative Just Might

By (about the author)     Permalink       (Page 1 of 2 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

Must Read 3   Interesting 2   Valuable 2  
View Ratings | Rate It Headlined to H1 12/10/10

Become a Fan
  (20 fans)
- Advertisement -

I've been thinking a lot about justice lately, pondering the injustice of the way that justice is administered in this country. For years I've pointed out and lamented the racial bias evident in both law enforcement and the criminal courts. For years, I've wished to live in a world in which the determination of guilt and the administration of punishment were both completely uncorrelated to race or any other demographic characteristic.

Today, I'm no longer satisfied with just that.

For those of us living in the United States, "doing justice" is mostly synonymous with administering punishment. We may not literally follow the Biblical edict of "an eye for an eye", but most of us still believe that "the punishment must fit the crime". More than that, many of us are not only willing but insistent that the punishment be cruel decades of incarceration, sometimes in solitary confinement. Punishment, after all, is supposed to be unpleasant. Besides, even the Talmud tells us that

"If we are kind to those to whom we should be cruel, we will ultimately be cruel to those to whom we should be kind."

Given these options, the choice is an easy one. Surely our friends deserve our kindness more. But why do we have to choose one over the other? More to the point, why must we limit ourselves to just these two choices?

I don't want to choose between being cruel to someone who deserves it and being cruel to someone who doesn't. Sure, that's an easy choice, but it's set up to be an easy choice in order to justify being cruel to someone. I reject the dichotomous options. I refuse to be intentionally cruel to anyone.

Second, the term "kindness" in this context is designed to provoke a negative response. Why should we be kind to those who chose to inflict pain on others? Alternatives to systems that administer retributive justice do not advocate kindness. They advocate compassion -- the not-so-radical idea that this person who may have done some terrible things (let's assume that his innocence is not in dispute) is still a person with the same basic needs as any other person.

Compassion is not kindness. It is not forgiveness. And it certainly is not a lack of accountability. It just means that I believe that no one is born wanting to rape and kill (psychopathy may be a special case) and the fact that some person has done so -- perhaps multiple times -- means that his/her life has been filled with so much pain that rape/murder was preferable to just carrying on. I don't condone his/her choices and I don't want to do anything to compromise the safety of others, but I feel compassion for the person who experienced such pain.

- Advertisement -

To be compassionate is to recognize everyone's humanity and to value everyone's needs. This works because compassion is not a zero sum gain. My feelings of compassion for one person do not lessen my compassion for another. To the contrary, my personal experience is that when I am in a more compassionate and loving space, I have more to give to everyone around me.

Though I talk about giving, compassion is not charity either. To be sure, it can be a tremendous gift to another, but it is a gift to ourselves as well. Just as torture and other acts of cruelty dehumanize not only the person tortured but the torturer as well, so do compassion and empathy reconnect us to our own humanity.

I recognize that there are people who lack the capacity to feel empathy for others, people who enjoy inflicting pain. I recognize that our need for safety may require some people to be incarcerated. But I recognize as well that involuntary confinement sometimes results in more violence, not less. For every convict that is rehabilitated, there are probably several that become more angry, more resentful, and more violent especially in a society in which ex-convicts are legally second-class citizens with no voting rights and few employment opportunities.

If there were no better options, we could justify continuing with business as usual. But there is, in fact, an alternative. It's called restorative justice.

There are many restorative justice systems. The one I've been studying is Restorative Circles (RC), a system developed by Dominic Barter in the shanty towns of urban Brazil and now spreading across the world as a means of promoting and facilitating social justice, group cohesion, resilient relationships and personal healing.

- Advertisement -

Dominic Barter workging with community leaders to develop a restorative system by Dominic Barter

Restorative Circles provide a way for individuals and communities to handle conflicts, including racial conflicts, compassionately rather than punitively, as well as to heal and learn from these conflicts.

To the uninitiated, restorative processes may appear idealistic and naive. After all, they reject the two core aspects of the traditional justice system: the assignment of blame and the administration of punishment. Instead, the goal of the Circle is for the parties involved in the conflict to first gain mutual understanding of the others' experiences and needs and then to restore or build a mutually satisfying relationship.

Next Page  1  |  2

Mikhail Lyubansky, Ph.D., is a member of the teaching faculty in the Department of Psychology at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, where he teaches Psychology of Race and Ethnicity, Theories of Psychotherapy, and a graduate-level restorative justice practicum based at a youth detention center. An autobiographical essay of Mikhail's interests in race relations and basketball is available here.

Since 2009, Mikhail has been learning, facilitating, evaluating, and supporting others in the U.S. in learning about Restorative Circles, a restorative practice developed in Brazil by Dominic Barter and his associates. In addition to conflict and restorative practices, Mikhail also has a long-standing interest (going back about 20 years) in race and (more...)

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

Go To Commenting

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Follow Me on Twitter

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles
- Advertisement -

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Ten Things Everyone Should Know About White Privilege Today

The Color of Blood: Racial Dynamics in Harry Potter (Part 2)

Japan's "civilized" response to the earthquake and tsunami has inspired all the wrong questions

A Few Words In Defense of the N-Word, in the Novels of Mark Twain

On 9-11, patriotism, and the U.S. flag

Gates and Crowley: It May Not Be Racist, But It Is Most Certainly Racial


The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
10 people are discussing this page, with 28 comments
To view all comments:
Expand Comments
(Or you can set your preferences to show all comments, always)
And it's gratifying to hear a strong second voice ... by GLloyd Rowsey on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 6:35:15 AM
ignore the law and violate people's rights? If so... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 10:55:13 AM
persecution your profile describes, specifically, ... by GLloyd Rowsey on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 12:40:15 PM
which once helped secure liberty and justice. The ... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 1:31:20 PM
let me know if I'm right here, but it sounds like ... by Edwin Rutsch on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 4:58:46 PM
show empathy, but many of those who seek positions... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 6:57:54 PM
So are you saying you feel some people working in ... by Edwin Rutsch on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 7:51:44 PM
why injustice is rampant and how justice is suppos... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Saturday, Dec 11, 2010 at 11:59:17 AM
from what I see there's 2 basic forms of justice, ... by Edwin Rutsch on Saturday, Dec 11, 2010 at 10:05:00 PM
Would it be possible to state that ' restorative j... by Mark Sashine on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 9:02:00 AM
There is a link to a report on the front page righ... by Mikhail Lyubansky on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 10:59:54 AM
do we have to beg a prosecutor to prosecute crimes... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 10:49:31 AM
"The impact of Reaganite folly has increasingly im... by Arthur Avalon on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 1:49:11 PM
I would argue very respectfully that restorative ... by Mark Sashine on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 2:31:07 PM
This is all nice and sweet and everything, and the... by Ned Lud on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 4:38:33 PM
click here Please take note of the picture of th... by Ned Lud on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 5:04:38 PM
I just received a private message that I think is ... by Mikhail Lyubansky on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 4:39:16 PM
Before we can diminish our sufferings from the ill... by Bill Cain on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 5:05:11 PM
Hi Mikhail It's great to see how your writing on ... by Edwin Rutsch on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 5:15:09 PM
I love spending time in empathic communities, and ... by Mikhail Lyubansky on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 11:22:00 PM
(I updated my bio, hope that helps)"I'm not really... by Edwin Rutsch on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 11:52:17 PM
Y'LL must realize that legal system of anglosaxons... by John Smith on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 8:49:54 PM
as meaning criminal law, Jan. And the most meanin... by GLloyd Rowsey on Saturday, Dec 11, 2010 at 12:13:13 PM
said that black was white, and when a judge does t... by Mark Adams JD/MBA on Saturday, Dec 11, 2010 at 5:19:37 PM
I've never been on a jury - civil or criminal - bu... by GLloyd Rowsey on Sunday, Dec 12, 2010 at 5:40:16 PM
There are many restorative systems. In some, like ... by Mikhail Lyubansky on Sunday, Dec 12, 2010 at 8:45:42 PM
Idea of USA was great. But was here... by John Smith on Friday, Dec 10, 2010 at 9:12:30 PM
Prison sentences are the punishment,prisons are no... by bogi666 on Sunday, Dec 12, 2010 at 5:40:40 AM