| Reaching
Beyond the Choir; Progressives Connecting with the Mainstream
By Wade Hudson
OpEdNews.com
At last, and
none too soon, progressives are learning to connect with the mainstream.
Since most Americans support progressive positions on most issues,
communicating with Middle America is critical.
If Kerry-Edwards win on November 2, the progressive movement will need
to mobilize massive support for the new Administration and insist that it
live up to its promise. By doing so, we can bring "One America"
closer to reality. If Bush wins, the imperative to strengthen our movement
will be even more urgent.
Many methods are needed. The progressive movement needs visionaries who
plant seeds, push the envelope, and open minds to new possibilities. We
need nonviolent, direct action to move matters forward. We need policy
wonks to craft well informed legislation. We need media and marketing
skills to reach wider audiences. And, as Susan Strong, Metaphor
Project founder, puts it, we need activists who know how to "talk
American."
With all this in mind, Toward
Peace, a loose network of activists based in San Francisco, has
initiated an independent Reaching
Beyond the Choir Project that will identify for the progressive
movement one or more concise statements of purpose clearly rooted in
underlying American moral values.
With the 1996 publication of Moral Politics: How Liberals and
Conservatives Think, George Lakoff, a professor of linguistics at the
University of California at Berkeley, made a major breakthrough by
analyzing how political language works. Four years ago, Lakoff co-founded
the Rockridge
Institute to "reframe the terms of political debate."
Recently, interest in Lakoff has increased dramatically. In the last year,
he caused a great stir with his
presentation at the Take
Back America 2004 Conference. He has been consulted by several
Democratic presidential candidates, made a presentation at the Democratic
Senators' annual retreat, been invited to address the California
delegation at the 2004 Democratic National Convention, and worked with
more than 100 advocacy organizations. Magnolia Films is currently
producing a documentary
on his work. He has been widely quoted in the national media and on July
23, he was interviewed on "NOW
with Bill Moyers."
At the Take Back America conference, Lakoff argued that progressive
activists need to use value-based messages that touch people more deeply
than is the case with traditional, issue-oriented platforms. By first
connecting to the progressive side of people who are ambivalent, we can
then talk more persuasively about policy ideas.
According to Lakoff, political beliefs are layered onto deep-seated
moral convictions about what is right and wrong, how people should live,
and how parents should raise their children. These convictions are
instilled at an early age and are often unconscious or semi-conscious.
Political conflict often derives from disagreements about what is moral
behavior.
Americans want government to act in concert with and reinforce their
moral convictions. As they want parents to raise good children, they want
government to foster good citizens. So Americans respond positively to
politicians and activists who share their sense of morality.
Unfortunately, progressives have largely left the moral arena to the
radical right. By appearing to be the ones who care most about morality,
the radical right seized a major tactical advantage. But progressives are
beginning to articulate more clearly the moral foundation of their
worldview. If we continue to move in this direction, we can win the debate
about moral values because our perspective is more inclusive, humane, and
sustainable.
From Lakoff's perspective, personal morality, social values, and
political principles reinforce one another. Progressive personal morality
affirms that both parents are equally accountable for nurturing their
children and raising them to be nurturers who experience empathy and
accept responsibility. This morality leads to social values such as
opportunity, service, cooperation, trust, honesty, strength, and
progressive individualism.
These values promote progressive political principles that are widely
supported by the American people. In particular, most Americans embrace
what Lakoff calls the "American Commitment," which declares that
if you work hard, play by the rules, and pay your dues, the nation will
provide protection, freedom, fairness, political equality, prosperity, the
best possible natural environment, healthy communities, and a reasonable
standard of living. Other principles identified by Lakoff include
political equality, responsible government, and moral leadership.
Bill Clinton demonstrated the effectiveness of talking about values,
but he mistakenly did so by moving to the center, rather than helping to
revitalize America's progressive tradition. "When you move to the
middle, you shoot yourself in both feet," Lakoff stated during a
recent interview on KPFA-FM in Berkeley. "You not only alienate
your base, but you also wind up helping the other side by activating their
model and their positions. So the appropriate thing to do is to speak to
your base, because that also speaks to the folks in the middle."
In this year's presidential campaign, John Edwards adopted Lakoff's
approach and touched a nerve with his "Two Americas" speech. His
call for "One America" affirms that the nation should be like a
family -- united and caring for one another.
After being informed during the "NOW with Bill Moyers"
interview that Kerry recently used the word "values" 28 times in
a 40-minute speech, Lakoff commented, "He's right. You have to say it
over and over. But now there's the next step. You can't just repeat the
word values. You have to say what they are. You have to start talking
about things like fairness, safety, freedom, community, trust, honesty,
integrity. These are values. Then he has to say why he has them in detail.
And then every time he mentions a program or an idea he has to say why
they follow from these values."
To date, the co-sponsors of the Reaching
Beyond the Choir Project are unaware of a short, comprehensive
"Statement of Purpose" for the progressive movement that uses
values-based language of the sort recommended by Lakoff.
So the goal of this Project will be to find any such statements summing
up the key aims of the progressive movement that have already been written
and encourage the writing of new ones. Individuals, informal groups, and
organizations are invited to
submit statements up to 2000 words in length. During and following a
post-election public forum, project participants will discuss, evaluate,
and rank the statements that emerge, and then widely disseminate the
results of these deliberations.
This process may produce one statement that clearly gathers the most
support. Such a statement could help provide a unifying focus for the
progressive movement and help facilitate the formation of one or more new
coalitions that will advance our cause more effectively than would be the
case with continued fragmentation. On the other hand, several statements
with strong support may surface, in which case various statements might be
used in different situations.
Progressive activists need to learn from Lakoff, Kerry, Edwards, and
others, and apply these lessons to grassroots organizing. If we do, we'll
be better able to build a popular force that can persuade elected
officials to practice what they preach.
Wade Hudson (whudson@igc.org),
is editor of Toward Peace.
originally published by CommonDreams.org
|