Home
Refresh   Tag(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (more...) ; ; ; ; ;  (less...)
Add to My Group
July 10, 2006 at 20:34:20

View Ratings | Rate It

Legal Defamation - When Major Media Provides the Outlet for Courts to Disparage Their Critics

by Zena Crenshaw     Page 1 of 1 page(s)

www.opednews.com


Tell A Friend

Many who challenge government misconduct through legal proceedings amass a virtual warehouse of related papers or files. I certainly have my stash and have seen the similar treasure troves of others, cluttering the floors and counter-tops of their homes and/or offices. These items are simultaneously among our greatest strengths and weaknesses as they substantiate our intricate accounts of horrendous injustice. In fact, our evidence becomes so overwhelming after compounding over years, sometimes decades of adjudication, that no one is willing to thoroughly sift through and understand it but us and our apparent adversaries. Herein lies the problem.

Effective advocates limit their presentation of protracted cases to a relatively few salient points
that support them or capitalize on the sheer volume and perhaps complexity of such cases to obscure critical issues when it benefits them to do so. The outcome depends primarily on the competence and integrity of their fact finder or adjudicator as that impacts the level of attention given the matter, another important consideration. Whatever the ruling, it may be subject to good faith challenges. This writing does not lament how any one or a collection of cases were resolved, per se. Instead it focuses on the prospect of legal decisions, ostensibly based on prior findings that were simply never made. It seems the New York Law Journal extensively covered such a case in reporting the reciprocal disbarment proceedings of Israel Weinstock by the Southern District of New York Grievance Committee.

Israel Weinstock is the namesake for federal legislation proposed by National Judicial Conduct
and Disability Law Project, Inc. (NJCDLP), a nonprofit legal reform organization combating
abuses of the American legal system that are facilitated by judicial misconduct. Soon after it was founded in January of 2005, NJCDLP submitted what was coined "The Weinstock Act" [see:
www.njcdlp.org/TheWeinstockAct.html ] for consideration by every member of Congress. The
proposal seeks to create some procedural protections for lawyers and judges facing disciplinary charges for allegedly maligning one or more judicial officers. Israel Weinstock was not disbarred for challenging the judiciary, but seeks to expose its alleged role in covering up a multi-million dollar fraud that a New York jury reportedly recognized [see: www.lawyerfraud.com ].

The details of Weinstock's case implicate some influential lawyers and judges as well as a
phenomena that Dr. Judith Lewis Herman of the Harvard Medical School describes:


In order to escape accountability for his/her crimes, the perpetrator does everything in his power
to promote forgetting. Secrecy and silence are the perpetrator's first line of defense. If secrecy
fails, the perpetrator attacks the credibility of his victim. If he cannot silence him absolutely, he
tries to make sure no one listens.

Obviously a lawyer is discredited when his or her professional discipline becomes public, whether through substantial coverage or a brief comment. Imagine the debilitating effects of that publicity when it comes courtesy of major media and quotes scathing judicial proclamations, unbridled by findings of record.

In case number M-2-238 before the U. S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, the Southern District of New York Grievance Committee (SDNYGC) claims to have "carefully" found that Israel Weinstock used "extortionate threats", and brought "meritless legal actions" against his ex-wife "in order to harass and maliciously injure her." Weinstock contends that the words "extort", "extortion", and/or "extortionate" do not appear anywhere in his disbarment record, nor the precipitating trial record. He denies being previously accused of bringing "meritless legal actions", prompting the question of why he was purportedly disbarred for doing so as to his ex-wife.

Remember my reference to virtual warehouses of papers and files? Well, Israel Weinstock has
one which I have seen. Droves of people could converge on it like a swarm of worker bees,
intent on confirming or refuting his characterization by the SDNYGC. All involved could be dumfounded by the utter lack of basis for sullying him with such charges. No action in defamation would lie as a result. All members of the SDNYGC are immune from liability for such claims which are hardly available against the prestigious New York Law Journal for merely reporting their legal decision. How convenient - except for Israel Weinstock, other government critics, and those unpopular people subject to legal action that major media is free to publicize. We are prime candidates for what is essentially legal defamation that is usually vindicated by appeals as effectively as bells are un-rung.

 

Zena D. Crenshaw is presently a lawyer before the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, Executive Director of National Judicial Conduct and Disability Law Project, Inc., and host of the internet radio show "Change of Venue".

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author
and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles

 

Book Recommendations for " Civil Rights Cover"
Literature
by Literature

$16.95

Number of pages: 144
Publisher: Perfection Learning

Remebering Rosa Parks: the life and legacy of 'The mother of the Civil Rights Movement'.(Obituary)(Cover Story): An article from: Ebony
by Kevin Chappell

$5.95

Number of pages: 7
Publisher: Thomson Gale

Coretta Scott King: First Lady of the Civil Rights Movement 1927-2006.(Obituary)(Cover Story): An article from: Jet
by Margena A. Christian

$5.95

Number of pages: 8
Publisher: Thomson Gale

Advocating reproductive rights. (Cover Story: Reproductive Health).: An article from: Igorota
by Corazon L. Pindog

$5.95

Number of pages: 2
Publisher: Igorota Foundation, Inc.

View All Book Recommendations

Share this page: (what's this?)                   Tell a Friend: Tell A Friend

FACEBOOK      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      NETSCAPE      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
2 comments


validating my experience to the max!

I am so glad I read your article; it is so relevant to my case......and as I am sure is true with all of these cases, it is difficult to put them down for a lack of closure, and validation. Thank you for writing the article.....it is very validating. I can also see how these dynamics could be as devastating for a lawyer who gets involved in a case, and ends up having to withdraw from it....as it is for the client (in my case the plaintiff), who is left with injuries that no longer compare to the origional injury but have opened up an unforseen world of new and additional trauma manifested by the neglect, loss, and betrayal of the 'good and trusted' folks...including family, in many cases. I recently commented on an article called Hounddog:Greg Palast .....with "You are not the only one". (a great example to your article) Then I wrote my first article less than a week ago that touches upon 'the case'. Again, Thank You! I will definately seek out the websites you mention.

by Katrin R. (3 articles, 0 quicklinks, 13 diaries, 657 comments [15 recommended, 0 rejected]) on Tuesday, Jul 11, 2006 at 9:20:07 PM

Recommend  (0+)

Reply: PS: Truth Hound: Greg Palast

I accidentially sent off my comment before I had a chance to edit it....which should explain the mistakes.

by Katrin R. (3 articles, 0 quicklinks, 13 diaries, 657 comments [15 recommended, 0 rejected]) on Tuesday, Jul 11, 2006 at 9:26:10 PM

Recommend  (0+)

 
Want to post your own comment on this Article? Post Comment


 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

Rothschild's Federal Reserve Must Be Abolished by Allen L Roland

Photo Essay: Thoughts for the Fourth of July: Talking the Talk and Walking the Walk for Peace by Mac McKinney

Israeli Embassy Correspondence Concerning Spirit of Humanity Capture Clarifies Centuries of Conflict by Meryl Ann Butler

Health Insurance Exec Whistleblower Wendell Potter Testifies Before Congress by Wendell Potter

Tampa, FL - UnitedHealth to Enter Funeral Parlor Industry by James Dunham

Dept. of State Spokesman Addresses McKinney's Capture by Meryl Ann Butler

Obama Has No Legal Authority For Afghan War by Sherwood Ross

Hypocritical Repugnicans Owe WJ Clinton an Apology by David Gray

Torture on the 4th of July by Lawrence Gist

Our Nation has a Great Deal to Learn from Phillip Butler about Morality, Law, and Torture by Lawrence Gist

Go To Top 50 Most Popular

 

Tell a Friend: Tell A Friend

Copyright © 2002-2009, OpEdNews

Powered by Populum