DUMMERSTON, Vt. - A year ago this week, Hurricane Katrina slammed into New Orleans and the Gulf Coast.
What made Katrina a singularly horrific tragedy were the images the world saw after the storm had passed.
Badly-needed emergency aid was slow in coming, and people were literally dying in the streets of New Orleans waiting for food, water and medicine that arrived too late.
Why did this happen? It happened because of conscious decisions made by people who believe that government is evil and exists only to reward friends and punish enemies. It happened because of an administration that believes the private sector can do things better and gutted the very institutions that could have saved lives in New Orleans.
Alan Wolfe, a professor of political science at Boston College, wrote an essay earlier this summer that sums up the problem. Entitled "Why Conservatives Can't Govern," Wolfe put forth the idea that "contemporary conservatism is a walking contradiction. Unable to shrink government but unwilling to improve it, conservatives attempt to split the difference, expanding government for political gain, but always in ways that validate their disregard for the very thing they are expanding. The end result is not just bigger government, but more incompetent government."
The perfect illustration of Wolfe's view is the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Under President Clinton, FEMA shifted its focus from preparing for a nuclear attack by the Soviet Union to dealing with more likely and predictable natural disasters. It worked closely with state and local officials and responded promptly and efficiently when disaster struck. It is not a stretch to say that by the end of the Clinton years, FEMA was one of the best run federal agencies.
When George W. Bush assumed office in 2001, he put Joe Allbaugh, a former campaign aide with no emergency management experience, in charge of FEMA. After the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FEMA was folded into the Department of Homeland Security, an agency that Bush initially opposed until political pressure forced his hand.
Allbaugh left for the private sector in 2002. His handpicked successor, Michael Brown, had even less experience. They did, however, had one thing in common - they believed FEMA was just another federal entitlement program that needed dismantling.
Allbaugh and Brown privatized many of FEMA's functions and shifted the agency's focus from responding to natural disasters to preparing for another terror attack. Even though FEMA stated before 9/11 that a major hurricane destroying New Orleans was one of the three most likely catastrophic disasters this nation would face (a major earthquake in San Francisco and a terrorist attack in New York were the other two), FEMA had its disaster preparedness money cut. Scores of the agency's professional staff, people who knew something about emergency management, left in disgust and were replaced by a variety of political cronies and appointees.
What happened once Katrina hit was almost inevitable: a total lack of leadership in the first days of the disaster that was nothing short of criminal negligence.
Why did it take until Sept. 2, five days after the storm, for President Bush or any other high-ranking official to set foot in the Gulf Coast? Why did FEMA turn away rescuers and supplies from New Orleans? Why did it take days for food and water to reach victims? Why was most of the Louisiana National Guard, which would have been quickly deployed in New Orleans, stuck in Iraq with their equipment? Why did it seem like our federal government was uninterested in providing the essential services of government - providing security, rescuing those in need and preparing for disasters before they happen?
Why? Because of the core belief of conservatism that government is bad. In Wolfe's view, conservatives "can't govern for the same reason that vegetarians can't make a world-class boeuf bourgunon: if you believe that what you are called upon to do is wrong, you are not likely to do it very well."
At the heart of homeland security is the protection of citizens from disasters, manmade and natural. Hurricanes and floods are more likely and more destructive than terrorist bombings. But the Bush administration chose to ignore this. Cutting money designed to minimize the damage of a disaster that everyone expected would happen had deadly consequences for the people of New Orleans and the Gulf Coast.
"Human beings can't prevent natural disasters," wrote Wolfe, "but they can prevent manmade ones. Not the Bush administration. It's ideological hostility toward government all but guaranteed that the damage inflicted by a hurricane would be exacerbated by the human damage caused by incompetence."
The toll for one of the worst natural disasters this nation has ever seen? More than 1,500 dead and 1,500 missing, hundreds of thousands of people displaced and more than $80 billion of damage. How much can be blamed on the human incompetence that left a great American city to die?
In the year since Katrina destroyed New Orleans and the Gulf Coast, about 60 percent of New Orleans is unoccupied. The job of cleaning up storm debris remains unfinished and basic services like water and electricity remain spotty at best.
Randolph T. Holhut has been a journalist in New England for more than 25 years. He edited "The George Seldes Reader" (Barricade Books). He can be reached at randyholhut@yahoo.com.
I dare to repeat here my diary entry from Sept. 11 2005
Murder of Dignity
It is better to be rich and healthy than poor and sick
::::::::
Russian saying
You really don't want the real poor to come out, do you?
Bertold Brecht
The threepenny Opera
We finally cleaned up the public housing in New Orleans
We couldn't do it but God did.
Rep. Richard Baker, GOP, LA, Baton Rouge in his discussion with lobbyists, Sept. 9, 2005 (per DNC blog, September 11, 2005)
The first man I met in New Orleans in Y2003 was dressed in a cellophane and duct tape. The tape covered him from top to bottom; it streamed all over his body down to the worn out sneakers, back to the waist and then concentrated in a form of some grotesques gagging bubble in front of his face. The poster in the man's hand said ," Homeland Security". That's how I understood that I was in another world. The world where poor people lived a dignified life.
In the US it is a crime to be poor. Of course, it is not officially unlawful to be one but the poor person, group, state or even country are considered as someone who cannot take care of themselves, thus requiring help and as such cannot have dignity. " Empty sack does not stand", said Benjamin Franklin and he was right, that wise man. That is the empty sack does not have to be filled. It can be tramped upon, thrown away, even filled with garbage. Empty sack has no dignity; its existence is defined by its emptiness.
Surely, there is a lot of rich people who cannot take care of themselves. It is sometimes painfully obvious. Take George W. Only the richness of his family, the belonging to the people with money prevented him from becoming a bum of bums. By the age of 40(!) he was a good- for- nothing drunk with no profession, no skills, no dignity and no stamina. He remains that way until now but it is not a crime to be a career criminal in the US as soon as your career is power. And if you don't have any dignity, malice is at your service to replace the void, so to speak.
New Orleans was different. It was obvious from the start that the primary idea, the main purpose of that city was for all people, affluent and poor alike to sustain dignity as something unique, maybe even something cajun, something specifically bayou. The descendants of slaves and white/Creole slave owners mixed together after the Civil War to create a race unique in its heritage, it its character and its dignity. In fact, dignity was the main cement that race was based upon. It made it stick.
What did we know about them? Robert Penn Warren, Mardi Gras and Ann Rice? Vampires and Shrimp Creole? Hey, good-looking , what's you gotta cooking? The Jazz funerals and Louis Armstrong? Richard Gere running away from mobsters with Kim Basinger? Not much. But it was there, in the New Orleans that Uncle Tom met Evangelina St. Clair and it was there that District Attorney Jim Garrison charged the first JFK conspiracy. Was there a connection between the slave and the white man who challenged the system? Yes it was. They were both dignified people.
New Orleans lived its own life and did its best in the country which did not appreciate the poor. New Orleans did its best for all people to live in harmony. The atmosphere of quite dignity, of everyday good humor and sarcasm worked on everyone in the city and eventually people drifted into it first reluctantly and then- more and more willingly. Only in the Big Easy I could see a distinguished attorney distributing the free condoms together with his daughter and only there I could see people in Armani suits seating peacefully at the same table with the people in rags.
The Big Easy, what does that mean? Who personifies the real New Orleanian character: Vampire Lestat, Robert De Niro's Devil, Willie Stark, the Boss or maybe an extraordinary Ignatius Reilly created by John Kennedy Toole, that genius of one book? Who knows? But I guess there is something from Ignatius in every native of that city as well as surely there is something from the RP Warren's Sugar- Boy, that loyal bodyguard who lost his purpose after the Boss was killed. There was dignity in both of them, the dignity of the poor and independent nonetheless.
And so they lived in that place below the level of the sea, protected by levies, lonely, dignified, insulated survivors, open to everyone and accessible to no one as if they knew the mantra of Joseph Brodsky, "If you are born in the Empire, try to live in the far province by the sea." And that was true- the sea was there, it helped to breath, to obtain sustenance, it also brought all those big cruise ships and the tourists to see the most extraordinary city in the world, to smell the free spirit, something which existed only there. They knew their power. No matter what they were; if the person was to live among them, that person had to follow their rules and that (at least they thought so) had made their power known all around the country just by their existence.
But uniqueness is a tragedy. The more they isolated themselves, the more the Empire squeezed them and in their pride they didn't see it. They had their senators, their nice Governor and their young mayor. But they didn't give a damn about the war in Iraq and I guess, governor Blanco did not complain that the Louisiana boys had to go there instead of staying here. I bet she did not mention that the trough, that perfect wind pattern which protected the Gulf shore was gone and nothing now would prevent any hurricane from slamming into the coast. I bet she did not even mention any of that.
They forgot or maybe never heard of the first Law of any Empire- it kills its independent and it kills its poor. The Big Easy was a ghetto but it was an independent ghetto. It had to go. And here comes Katrina.
I can only guess that the idea to use an opportunity and murder the ghetto first sparked in the heads of the Crawford praetorians on the Sunday afternoon, August 28 when according to the perfect timeline chronicles published by Jackson Thoreau (see ' Timeline shows the depths of callousness by Bush and Co. displayed after Katrina hit') Bush, Brown and Chertoff were warned by the Dr. Max Mayfield, director of the National Hurricane Center that the levies might fail. It was at that moment, precisely that the evil thought had appeared, " Let those levies breach and then we let them die."
The most evil things in the world usually do not happen because someone plans them. They happen because there is someone who wants them to happen and does not prevent them from happening.
The praetorians had all the reasons in the world to ' clean the public housing'. Not only they would be able then to take a full control over that region both militarily and politically. They also needed desperately to destroy the spirit of independence. Look at the survivors and you will see. Hungry desperate, with nothing; no possessions, no connections, no money, they are fully dependent on whatever scraps the mighty government can throw at them; they depend on virtually everyone and power is the last thing they think about. Who cares? And who can blame them? Nobody. They are trapped.
Of course, the praetorians didn't get all what they wanted either. The press, the media did not let those people just to die peacefully as they hoped. But they capitalized nicely. They are in charge. Their role is even bigger. They have all the money and all the military. Already they talk about New Orleans- a symbol of the Empire, they distribute contracts to Halliburton and Bechtel while the true spirit of the city is either dead or scattered. Did any one ask those evacuees in the Astrodome or in other shelters how they want their city to be rebuilt? Did anyone invite them to the reconstruction meetings? Did anyone, whoever stayed in front of them and promised that they all would be able to return and benefit? Not a chance. All they will get will be FEMA handouts and maybe Brownie will return to private practice. Life goes on. And Death goes on too.
The Power of the people belongs to all of us and if it is tramped upon, dumped, ridiculed or destroyed, all of us loose big time. Not all of us may be like the people of New Orleans. Not all of us understand their way of life. Not all of us understand anything at all these days. But be warned: there is a direct link between the Afghanistan and Iraq massacres, PATRIOT ACT, Gitmo, Abu- Ghreib and those dead people in the Convention Center and St. Rita's. It is the work of the same hand. Americans are now confronting a phenomenon that other nations had confronted before and paid dearly for the lessons; we are facing the government for itself, the government against the people, the government of the national destruction. We already started to pay but it is only the beginning. After the spirit is dead there it is a body that is targeted. Constitution and Law are our body and they are already severely compromised. Where is the Law for the Katrina survivors? Where are the criminal cases against the criminally negligent? Where is the criminal investigation of the murder attempt? Where are all those attorneys? What had happened to the relentless pursuit we are so famous for? The Empire had struck a deadly blow but it did not get everything. It is reeling in cover-up. There is still a chance. A very slim chance, though. The only way to stop them and to get them is to understand that they are there to do you harm and as soon as they are there, that harm will be done. All the movements must unite, all the people must participate, and the People's Front for the saving of the US Democracy has to be proclaimed.
Here is my final question to all who will read this. Do you want to die? If not, please, wake up. You cannot think that you can live all your life now without giving a damn about what is going on around you. The predators are afoot. And they will kill you. They are there to kill. And you, my lonely friend are a much easier prey than the proud and sturdy New Orleaninans. The Empire needed not God, but the Devil to destroy them. To deal with you and me it will not need such a powerful ally. Remember what the blind Colonel Slate said in the movie 'Scent of a Woman' ,"There is no prosthetic for the amputated spirit".
Everything I have written here is written with love. There is no mockery and no malice; just plain, sad truth.
Mark Sashine, aka Panurg
by
Mark Sashine (50 articles, 19 quicklinks, 242 diaries, 3437 comments)
on Wednesday, August 30, 2006 at 12:24:10 PM
1 comments
How would you rate this?
You must be logged in (if signed up) to do ratings.
It's free to signup! And easy. And takes just a minute or two....