Tags for This Article:

Voter Disenfranchisement (1623)  Voter Fraud (366)  Voter ID Laws (241) 

Populum Tag Cloud
       Control Panel
Fine tune your search to access content
Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s): ; ;
Add to My Group
August 5, 2007 at 10:07:53

"Voter Fraud" Keeps Voter Suppression Policies Alive

by Project Vote     Page 1 of 2 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 
Tell A Friend

(0.0 from 0 ratings) View Ratings | Rate It

Weekly Voting Rights News Update

This an entry in a series of blogs to keep people informed on current election reform and voting rights issues in the news.

Featured Stories of the Week:

Special vote to require photo ID – Atlanta Journal Constitution

Handel rehashes voter ID ploy – Atlanta Journal Constitution, Editorial

Federal Panel on Voter Fraud Scrutinized – NPR

Democrats Plan to Assess Voting State by State – New York Times

Voter ID is back in the news this week: Georgia Secretary of State Karen Handel announced that photo ID is required to vote in the state's Sept. 18 elections in about 18 counties, according to Jim Galloway of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. This is bad news for increasing voter participation, but good news to those who have adamantly sought the passage of policies that suppress voters in the name of the phantom issue of “voter fraud.”

Handel “made the move despite the likelihood that opponents will seek another court order blocking implementation,” Galloway wrote. Two lawsuits thwarted enforcement of the state requirement to present government-issued photo ID at the polls in recent elections. But, one case was dismissed last month and the other, a federal case brought by Common Cause of Georgia, may go back to court on August 22.

“'Hopefully, [the judge] will reinstate the injunction, as he has done three times previously,'” Emmet Bondurant, lead plaintiff's attorney in the Common Cause lawsuit.

“Judges have agreed with voting rights advocates, who point out that it is unconstitutional to construct barriers to the ballot box,” wrote Cynthia Tucker for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution editorial board. Studies have shown voter ID requirements hinder voter participation among minority, elderly and low income voters.

According to a 2006 Election Assistance Commission study, an analysis of the impact of voter identification laws on over turnout revealed that there was a 2.7% decrease in overall turnout in states that required documentary ID compared to states that required voters to give their names. The decrease in voter turnout is dramatically higher among minorities. For example, among registered voters in the 2004 Current Population Survey, Latino voters in states that required a form of ID were 10% less likely to say they had voted compared to Latinos in states where ID was not required. Black (5.7%) and Asian (8.5%) voters reported the same. Moreover, a Brennan Center for Justice study found that more than 21 million (11%) of Americans do not have government-issued photo ID, such as driver's licenses or state ID.

“Of course, that's the very reason the Republican Party has embraced strict voter ID laws in the state legislatures across the country: Those laws shave off a small number of voters who tend to support Democrats. In close races, that can make the difference,” Tucker wrote.

Handel said she had a “comprehensive outreach program” that will educate voters on the new requirements. “But that's not enough,” Tucker said, calling the overall measure “political gamesmanship,” unless Handell launches a program to get every Georgia voter a state-sponsored ID within the next three years. However, she said, “it would require money to purchase vans and buses to go into rural areas as well as resources to help the elderly and poor secure any documentation they might need to prove citizenship.”

“Political gamesmanship” has come up regarding the recent EAC report on voter fraud. The commission is currently being investigated by Congress as a result of potential political pressure by the Bush administration to change the results in their December 2006 voter fraud report, which the bi-partisan panel “strongly denies,” according to Pam Fessler of Pam Fessler of NPR. Tova Wang of the Century Foundation, one of two consultants commissioned to help with the report said, “we found that the instances of voter impersonation at the polls – polling place fraud - is pretty overstated.” What the commission released was “substantially different” from the report she and colleague, Republican election attorney Job Serebrov originally submitted, which found that “polling place fraud is not a big problem.”

“News of the EAC's revision also came at the same time as revelations that the Justice Department targeted U.S. attorneys for not going after voter fraud cases. Commission members deny that any of this was a factor for them,” Fessler said. Interestingly, former DOJ Civil Rights attorney and current controversial Federal Elections Commissioner nominee Hans von Spakovsky complained about Tova Wang in a 2005 email, saying her “pronounced partisan and one-sided view of voter fraud issues” should be grounds for the EAC to reconsider her contract. He was on the EAC advisory board at that time.

 1  |  2

 

www.projectvote.org

Project Vote is the leading technical assistance and direct service provider to the civic participation community. Since its founding in 1982, Project Vote has provided professional training, management, evaluation and technical services on a broad continuum of key issues related to voter engagement and participation in low-income and minority communities.

Contact Author
Contact Editor
View Other Articles by Author

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
2 comments

Michael Collins is a writer who focuses on clean elections and voting rights. See this summary of his articles plus Election 2004: The Urban Legend and groundbreaking research and commentary in "" His web site, Election Fraud News & The Money Party, offers a collection of resources and commentary on critical issues facing the country.
Michael CollinsMichael Collins is a writer who focuses on clean elections and voting rights. See this summary of his articles plus Election 2004: The Urban Legend and groundbreaking research and commentary in "" His web site, Election Fraud News & The Money Party, offers a collection of resources and commentary on critical issues facing the country.

Excellent Post

"Voter Fraud" has a long tradition, one that goes back to the Mississippi Constitution of 1890 and other schemes specifically designed to disenfranchise and suppress voting  by black Americans.  The fact that states adopt and then courts affirm this racist legacy, with the same intent today, shows that we're still  struggling to achieve free and fair elections.  The US Attorney's scandal reflects the hypocrisy.  I can't believe that even one of the current US Attorneys believes that the 6 convictions a year for voter fraud represents even a definable crime.

All they have to do is read their own reports

by Michael Collins (87 articles, 13 quicklinks, 5 diaries, 327 comments) on Sunday, August 5, 2007 at 9:29:23 PM
 


I am a 70 yr old great-grandmother, widowed, a retired RN. My passions are family and politics.
bmobleyI am a 70 yr old great-grandmother, widowed, a retired RN. My passions are family and politics.

"Democrats keep voter suppression policies alive

Folks, the harder you fight this the more Republicans become convinced that there is some "there" there.  The issue aint going away as long as we keep fighting it.  The louder we yell the more convinced they become.  End result: they keep accusing and we keep defending, meanwhile the status quo continues. 

So ask yourself, how can we turn the issue to our advantage and disarm the Republican argument?  Let them have the damned thing.  Then, organize volunteers to use the next 3 years to get people the documentation that is required and get them the ID.  It ain't rocket science. 

I wonder about the stats released by th Election Assistance Commission concerning a decrease in voter participation.  A 10.9% decrease in Latinos.  Why would that be?  That is not the pattern we have seen in the past.  Naturalized citizens tend to vote in higher numbers (percentage wise) than native born citizens.  Those numbers reinforce the belief that illegal immigrants are voting.   If these Latinos are native born, there is no reason needed documentation cannot be aquired.  If they are not, they certainly needed some documentation to become naturalized citizens and they should have those naturalization documents easily a hand.  Those folks, just like me, are required to produce documentation to aquire a drivers licience, a social security number, and in some states, a birth certificate.  (I had to provide all of that to work as a RN in IN).  I can't tell you how many times I or members of my family have had to produce any or all of those.  So what about this might seem suspicious to someone who is already paranoid about  "voter fraud"?  When we respond that for some people, meeting those requirement is an impossibility, anyone hearing that claim knows very well, it ain" so!  It is not only possible, it is almost an absolutely neccessity to aquire a SS number, a drivers license, a passport, a job.  For the handful of folks for whom it may be true, they can be assisted in the aquisition of them by volunteers.  The same argument applies to the Asian number of an 8.5% decrease.  For blacks,  it seems the biggest handicap is a felony record.  There are still states where it is illegal for a person convicted of a felony to vote.  While we can argue that such a law is wrong, (that is certainly my view) even unconstitutional, it  remains a law and thus it is illegal for those people to vote in those states.  Now ask yourself this: what if Florida had had such a voter ID system in place in 2000?  It would have made the voter scrub lists useless.  Because those who were not felons, and whose names appeared on that list would have had that voter ID and would have gone to the polls armed with an unchallengable legal document to prove they had a right to vote.  

As to the cost involved, it costs about $10.00 to obtain a certified copy of your birth certificate.  A copy of your SS card is free, I know this from personal experience.  Virtually everyone in America has a drivers licence, those who don't can obtain a state issued personal ID at a cost of under $20.00.  Anyone surviving in this country without one or more of the above is so far underground that my guess is, they ain't voting.  So far as the cost of transportation is involved, it's a non-starter.  Are you telling me we need BUSSES to get these folks to the court house?  Are you kidding?  Look, every district has an organized Democratic party headquarters.  There are always folks who are glad to volunteer services.  Those folks have cars, trucks, vans.  So why do we need busses?  You wouldn't want to take more than a few people in at a time anyway.  No way you could get more than a certain number processed at one time anyway.  So a carful a day would surely accomadate the number of people in any single district.  Personal donations would, could, should be able to cover the small costs involved.  If the Democrats can't rally themselves to do this small thing, we no longer deserve to call ourselves a political party! 

So, tell me again why this is an issue.  The art of war is find a way to use something being used against you to your own advantage.  Take the club your opponent is beating you over the head with and use it to knock the SOB out of the game! 

Sometimes I dispair at the lack of sensibility in the party I belong to.  I used to think we were the smartest guys in the room.  Lately, I'm not so sure. 

 

 

 

 

by bmobley (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 28 comments) on Monday, August 6, 2007 at 11:29:01 AM
 

 

2 comments

 

Tell A Friend

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2008

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

"Welcome, Rich White Oligarchs!" --Daily Show Billboard Greets Republicans In Minnesota Posted by Rob Kall

Why I Won't Vote for John McCain by Phillip Butler

Carville is a Spy for Bush Posted by Josh Mitteldorf

Virgo New Moon, August 30, 2008 by C.L. Pagano

Howard Zinn's Advice to Obama by Rob Kall

McCrash: McCain's Military Record Revisited by Hill Kemp

The Slow Death of Democracy and the Rise of the Corporate Hydra by Siv O'Neall

Got a Traffic Ticket in the Mail for a Right on Red at an Automated Enforcement Light? by Tumerica

The Rise and Fall of the US Dollar as the The World Reserve by John Little

"Now, This!" by Stephen Pizzo

Popularity Navigation
Control Panel:

Select Time
6 hrs 12 hrs
1 Day 2 Days
3 Days 1 Week
2 Weeks 1 Month
2 Months 3 Months
6 Months Last Year
Select Content
Articles Diaries
Polls Events
All Op-Eds
News Life/Arts/Science
Select Popularity
Page Views
# of Comments
Recommend Emails
  

Go To Top 50 Most Popular