Tags for This Article:

Government (2754)  Children (710)  Death (705)  Legislation (637)  Lawsuits (442)  Accountability (321)  Justice Department (306)  Pollution (280)  FDA (153)  Parents (78)  Firearms (37) 

Populum Tag Cloud
       Control Panel
Fine tune your search to access content
Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (more...)  (less...)
Add to My Group
April 20, 2008 at 00:39:26

Promoted to column top on 4/20/08:
Justices Cutting the Legs From Under 'Standing'

by JC Garrett     Page 1 of 1 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 

Tell A Friend

(0.0 from 0 ratings) View Ratings | Rate It

The Supreme Court recently ruled that manufacturers of medical devices cannot be sued for injuries or deaths they cause if the Food and Drug Administration has approved them. A 2001 ruling bars suits even when a company has defrauded the F.D.A. Now, the Court is poised to rule on whether Americans can sue drug companies when their products have maimed or killed people. For the general public's right to 'standing', the future looks very bleak.

The Government claims the F.D.A. is competent enough to oversee the drug and device markets, and courts should not be "second-guessing" the agency. A majority of Justices seems to agree. Both the Government and the Court are dangerously mistaken. The Government Accountability Office and the F.D.A.'s own science board have released reports saying the agency is "incapable" of protecting America from unsafe medical devices, drugs, and even food.

To deny standing to those hurt by medical products just because there happens to be an agency that oversees the industry would be the same as denying standing to residents of communities poisoned by toxic waste released into their water supply because the company responsible for the pollution is overseen by the Environmental Protection Agency. It's the same as denying standing to people killed by defective electrical systems in vehicles because the industry is overseen by the Department of Transportation, or those killed in plane crashes because we have an F.A.A.

Should parents be prevented from suing a daycare center for child abuse because it passed inspection by the Department of Human Services? Are injured patients to be barred from filing malpractice suits merely because their doctor was considered competent enough to obtain a medical license? If hundreds of people are injured by a specific make of firearm because of a structural flaw, should their cases be summarilly dismissed because the overall design was approved by the Federal Firearms Administration?

Many products and services of every kind have been approved by one regulatory agency or another, only to be found defective or unsafe long after they were deemed harmless. The F.D.A. at one time appoved silicon breast implants, DDT, and cigarettes. Just in the past ten tears, at least 12 drugs initially approved by the F.D.A. have been pulled off the market after being found unsafe - and only after scores of people were harmed by them. Other products such as lead paint, asbestos, and mercury have been initially labeled as "safe" by our omnipotent bureacracies, and many men, women, and children have paid for that kind of "oversight" with their lives and health.

Congress should undo these ridiculous Supreme Court rulings with legislation that returns to the public the standing it has always had to seek justice in the courts against careless or unprincipled manufacturers of products that harm them. But if the Government wants to say that regulatory agencies are so competent that they, alone, can decide what is or isn't dangerous, then the agencies themselves should be ready and willing to accept full responsibility for the decisions they make. All lawsuits for every product or service they approve should be brought directly against the approving agency, and standing should be granted to anyone who has suffered from their dangerous arrogance.

Somehow, I don't think that's what the nine folks sitting on the High Court have in mind.

By JC Garrett

 

JC Garrett is a freelance writer and Constitutional scholar from the piney-woods of East Texas. He apologizes to the entire world that the great Lone Star State could have produced the neo-Neanderthal currently occupying the Oval Office. "I'm not ashamed to be an American. I'm ashamed George W. Bush is an American." Mr. Garrett owns and operates an independent recording studio, plays several instruments, writes, sings, and produces music. His stories have appeared in Political Affairs Magazine, ACLU FreedomWire, Online Journal, Infowars, Prison Planet, OpEd News, Consortium News, The Intelligence Daily, Democratic Underground, Truthdig, The Memory Hole, Wired, World Prout Assembly, and local publications.

Contact Author
Contact Editor
View Other Articles by Author

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
4 comments


Wolfie

fooled and drugged abscency

why not trust the pharma industrial complex. aren't we high on pills? one makes us happy, one brings us down. why do we want to hurt our pushers?  let's wash it down with a lite beer and call it a night.

think of all the scientists worrying about we imperfect beings. they make our egoes almost as large as american's tummies. hell no, we won't let the pill box go!

 

wolfie wolfs down his alpo with prozac meal to be a better lap dog.

by Wolfie (9 articles, 0 quicklinks, 19 diaries, 1084 comments) on Sunday, April 20, 2008 at 1:07:54 AM
 


Barbara H. Peterson is retired from the California Department of Corrections, where she worked as a Correctional Officer at Folsom Prison. She was one of the first females to work at the facility in this classification. After retirement, she went to college online to obtain a Bachelor's degree in Business, and graduated with honors.

The most valuable thing she received from her time with UOP was a realization that her life's passion is writing. Now her business degree sits in her d...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Barbara PetersonBarbara H. Peterson is retired from the California Department of Corrections, where she worked as a Correctional Officer at Folsom Prison. She was one of the first females to work at the facility in this classification. After retirement, she went to college online to obtain a Bachelor's degree in Business, and graduated with honors.

The most valuable thing she received from her time with UOP was a realization that her life's passion is writing. Now her business degree sits in her d...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Excellent article

Thank you for posting this. The government is owned by corporations. Corporations do not want to be sued. Therefore, the corporate government will do anything it can to limit liability, up to and including actions that prohibit lawsuits against it or any other corporation that supports it, as this article exposes.

by Barbara Peterson (46 articles, 80 quicklinks, 3 diaries, 416 comments) on Sunday, April 20, 2008 at 1:29:19 PM
 


American citizen. Blogger, photographer. Political ativist.
Zena PrincessAmerican citizen. Blogger, photographer. Political ativist.

FDA

The FDA now has no credibility if you look at some of their history. I trust them as much as I trust Bush. NOT. I think the FDA should be sued itself if this is going to be the case. But then the republicans are trying to destroy our government already, aren't they?

by Zena Princess (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 28 comments) on Sunday, April 20, 2008 at 8:13:14 PM
 

 

4 comments

 

Tell A Friend

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2008

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

Anne Kilkenny Full Email on Sarah Palin by Rady Ananda

John McCain: Morally, Mentally, and Emotionally Unfit by Jim Fetzer

Iran War ~ How It Will Unfold by Lord Stirling

High Treason: 'Pentagon Lied to the 911 Commission' ; Bush's Theory Falls Apart by Len Hart

Sarah Palin, A Wolf in Moose Clothing by Anthony Wade

Librarians Against Palin Founder a Mystery by Judy Swindler

Protester who interrupted McCain's speech is an Iraq War Veteran by Mary MacElveen

Why We're Planning to Prosecute Cheney and Bush by David Swanson

McCain attacked 18 year old Chelsea Clinton in 1998 now says Palin's family & kids are off limits by Steven Leser

Is McCain Campaign Interfering In Alaska Troopergate Investigation of Palin? by Rob Kall

Popularity Navigation
Control Panel:

Select Time
6 hrs 12 hrs
1 Day 2 Days
3 Days 1 Week
2 Weeks 1 Month
2 Months 3 Months
6 Months Last Year
Select Content
Articles Diaries
Polls Events
All Op-Eds
News Life/Arts/Science
Select Popularity
Page Views
# of Comments
Recommend Emails
  

Go To Top 50 Most Popular